4 ms·
So, just to be clear, the HN gestalt is that economists generally don't understand anything because "homo econimus" is a fiction and they don't understand the i
by jerf 8y ago
So, just to be clear, the HN gestalt is that economists generally don't understand anything because "homo econimus" is a fiction and they don't understand the impacts of even relatively simple-to-characterize policy changes due to the complexity of a society made up of irrational actors, but it is reasonable to expect computer scientists to correctly predict the impact of their prospective research whose practical applications may not yet even be a gleam in anybody's eye, and decide on that basis what should and should not be researched and/or published and/or written?
The solution to this conundrum is obvious: Take the computer scientists who can make these amazing predictions and move them into the field of economics, where their predictive power can generally do more good for society. Then they won't invent anything harmful and can do trillions of dollars of good for the world economy, which is way better than all but the most black swan-y of research projects they could have come up with.
I'd also observe, HN gestalt, that you believe that pure research should be pursued because it is unpredictable where advances will end up being useful. This contradicts the idea that researchers can guess the societal impacts of their research. If researchers can successfully guess the societal impacts of their research, then people are justified in cutting pure research whenever they decide it's useless, because the judgment process that led to the conclusion "this is useless" is the exact same judgment process you're asking researchers to do here. Accepting that these predictions can be made will rather quickly result in the elimination of pure research. (Because, pretty much by definition, it looks useless for the forseeable future.)
If you want to decide this is a good idea and incorporate it into your worldview, you're going to have to give up several other things to get there. And have a frankly irrational view of the predictability of the universe, in my view.
You can't even really escape from this by saying "But it's so obvious in some cases that research is bad", because it really never is. Even germ warfare research can lead to valuable medical insights, and you really never know what valuable medical insights will lead to something that helps germ warfare. The idea that researchers can predict the future and should exercise some social responsibility by doing so is not some sort of major moral advancement; it's a childish regression from something we figured out decades ago, demonstrating our further scientific decay.
(The other inevitable objection is probably around nuclear bombs. Had the Manhatten Project never existed, there is no world in which we'd be sitting here in 2018 with no nuclear bombs. The only change would be who had them when. Nuclear bombs do not exist because of man's hubris and disregard for consequences. They exist because the laws of the universe permit them.)
- forapurpose 8y ago> economists generally don't understand anything I think this is taking hyperbole literally. The world is not at all completely unpredictable; it's highly susceptible to reason and science - in a way, that's the entire enterprise of the Enlightenment and its child, science. Predictions aren't perfect, but they are hardly useless. Your world is built on them; your alarm will go off; the train will be roughly on time and won't collide with other trains; investors invest based on economic and business predictions; software developers develop based on market predictions and predictions of user psychology; we can predict how well UI's will work, hardware failure rates, etc. The list goes on forever. In particular, economics has provided, especially since WWII, a period of economic growth that is orders of magnitude beyond what humanity ever experienced before. Depressions used to be a regular occurrence; they have stopped. Systemic bank failures no longer happen, we know how money supply works, and the impacts of various policies much better than throwing darts at a graph. Recessions are not as bad; sustained growth is a norm, which is a miracle. The growth of the world economy, lifting billions out of poverty for the first time in history, is beyond all but the most visionary dreams of a century ago. Do economists and economics get it wrong sometimes and to varying degrees? Absolutely. Unfortunately, there is nothing perfect in the world.
- pseudalopex 8y agoIrrational doesn't mean unpredictable. The criticism of "homo economicus" is that it leads people to miss foreseeable consequences.