7 ms·
Didn't the natives have houses or did they just not survive the colonisation?
by k__ 8y ago
Didn't the natives have houses or did they just not survive the colonisation?
- frockington 8y agoA lot of the natives (at least in the NE and Midwest) did not live in shelter that were meant to last for hundreds of years. They lived in semi-temporary small buildings
- folli 8y agoThe Colorado and New Mexico buildings are from the native population.
- alistairSH 8y agoTwo indigenous structures are listed; Colorado and New Mexico both have old pueblo settlements. Many of the indigenous villages in the mid-Atlantic area were burned by the English for one reason or another. I suspect many permanent settlements elsewhere suffered similar fates.
- protomyth 8y agoSadly, all the Mandan earth lodges in the great plains are reconstructions but still worth visiting.
- codingdave 8y agoSo does Utah- Hovenweep National Monument is just inside southeastern Utah, dating from 1200-1300. I'm not sure why it wasn't listed.
- alistairSH 8y agoThe listing is "oldest intact buildings" and Hovenweep is a ruin. Though, I'd agree that the listing, as published, is a bit strange, given the Molalla Log House is also a ruin (collapsed roof).
- codingdave 8y agoFair enough - but then we could also discuss the restored kiva at Edge of the Cedars. It isn't a replica, it is a restoration from the original structure. Would that count? I guess the point being simply that it seems more thought could have been put into the states where Native American structures have survived.
- alistairSH 8y agoI agree. It's a Euro-centric list, no queston.
- pilom 8y agoCliff Palace (the oldest one listed for Colorado) certainly isn't "intact". It's definitely a ruin.
- alistairSH 8y agoThat's what the page claims, not my words, so...?
- HillaryBriss 8y agoBefore I looked at Washington I guessed its oldest structure might be one of the indigenous people's wooden longhouses. But my guess was wrong.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoThis surprised me as well, as I was under the impression that most / all of what's at Fort Nisqually is replica / reproduction, especially given that it was moved many miles from its original location.
- phaus 8y agoI'm guessing a lot of them didn't survive. A lot of white peoples' buildings didn't survive either. I'm actually kind of curious how different this list would be if Sherman didn't burn a bunch of southern cities during the Civil War.
- heartbreak 8y agoProbably would have only affected Georgia's listing, if at all.
- yellowcherry 8y agoYeah, he didn't burn Savannah, which was by far the oldest city on his route. Atlanta wasn't even 30 years old when he burned it.
- phaus 8y agoHe was unusually kind when he got to Savannah. He burned a lot of stuff on the way though. Not sure if any of those places were of significance. He also destroyed some stuff in SC afterwards.
- phaus 8y agoAfter Georgia he went through South Carolina with the specific goal of destroying things to punish them for being the state most responsible for the rebellion.
- madengr 8y agoThe house I grew up in dates to 1840 and served as an armory during the civil war. Though this was in VA.
- madengr 8y agoThere are was a large city just east of St. Louis that existed 1000 years ago. It vanished long before Europeans came.
- gist 8y ago'The Oldest Building' actually should say 'Oldest Known Building'. Hard to believe that in a country this large there aren't structures that are around (occupied or not) that are simply not catalogued in any way or don't fit with what the article considers a 'building'.