4 ms·
This really seems like a problem that could be helped by smarter automation (and a lot of "thinking outside the box") If plastic bags get stuck to the machines
by raverbashing 8y ago
This really seems like a problem that could be helped by smarter automation (and a lot of "thinking outside the box")
If plastic bags get stuck to the machines, then maybe the way to getting rid of them is looking at what happens with them as opposed to other materials.
Also automated identification of materials (by optical inspection or dedicated sensors) looks like it could help.
- cdolan 8y agoThis tech is already applied to MRFs and it still doesn’t work 100% if the time, causing downtime on the line, and lost revenues.
- mihaifm 8y agoI don't understand why it's so hard to build a machine that separates plastic from other materials. I mean in agriculture we have machines that separate tiny seeds from anything else, I don't see why it wouldn't be possible to have a plastic sorting machine.
- lbriner 8y agoBecause of the massive variation in shapes and sizes, the fact that some plastics might have other trash inside them and that plastic drinks bottles are usually more than one type of plastic. There are machines but they can only perform basic sorting so you still need people to do the "intelligent" part.
- schiffern 8y ago>I don't understand why it's so hard ... we have machines that separate tiny seeds Not hard, just expensive. And understanding how seeds are separated (not only that they are separated) makes it clear why plastics require so many more steps. For seeds, it's a two-step process. First comes threshing[1], which is the act of physically breaking the seeds off the plant. Basically they solved this problem by hitting the stalks against a solid surface. This works because all the plants are the same type and age, so you can dial in a force that will break the seeds _off_ without breaking them _apart_. This won't work for plastics, because they're combined with all sorts of other materials that whacking won't dislodge. One shot of that "Plastic China" documentary[2] shows a worker using a box cutter to remove a plastic label that's shrink-wrapped around (not glued to) a crushed container. The second step is called winnowing[3], and it's basically just blowing air through the falling seeds to separate them aerodynamically from the straw and chaff. This works because seeds have a higher ballistic coefficient (mass/drag). Winnowing is also done with screens or slats, relying on the fact that seeds are of uniform size. But plastics have all different shapes and sizes. Wind winnowing can certainly be used as part of a processing chain (eg to separate films from bulk plastics), and so can screens, but they're nowhere near a complete solution. Because of these complexities, automatically processing plastic at scale requires a lot more than just those two steps (which nowadays are combined together with reaping in the cleverly-named "combine harvester" or combine[4]). That means it's expensive, and that means someone in China with cheap labor and "externalized" pollution costs (read: make your neighbors get sick and die, but don't even have the decency to pay their doctor bills or keep their windowed spouses/orphaned children off the street) can outbid you. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshing [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17678513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17678513 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnowing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnowing [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combine_harvester https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combine_harvester
- newnewpdro 8y agoThere's obviously complicating factors. If a consumer thinks recycling is some sophisticated magic, they're likely to use the plastic bag they think is recyclable to encapsulate a load of mixed recycling while it accumulates indoors. Assume this bag now contains a combination of paper, plastic, and cans. Or if they have a plastic container full of fresh fruit with a tuna can from lunch, they might put the empty metal can within the now empty plastic container, closing the container to limit the odor. Eventually this winds up in the recycling bin as metal nested within plastic. Automatically identifying and separating these instances intact, I imagine, is non-trivial. What I don't understand is why we need to separate everything intact and can't just shred it all to a uniform size then automate sorting and washing that product.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoIt has been well over a decade since supermarkets in many countries got automated bottle-return machines. With all the advances in computer vision, is there really no way to have machines that can economically scan returned plastic for its recycling code and direct it towards the appropriate bin, so that the recycler gets a supply of correctly sorted plastic?
- lbriner 8y agoRecycling codes are not consistently applied, a bottle might have lost its label, many plastics use mixed types and lots of food and drink containers are polluted by the food and liquids so they are still dirty. You can tell people to wash things and separate them but you can't really police it and when it doesn't happen, you have to inspect everything to ensure that nothing gets through!
- viraptor 8y agoThere's some threshold where "quick wash of everything not explicitly full of stuff" is cheaper/more economical than inspecting, so that shouldn't really prevent automation. Maybe just make it a bit harder.
- michaelt 8y agoI just finished a bottle of Coca-Cola while I was on a train. The bottle is made of polyethylene terepthalate, while the cap, ring and wrap-around label are made of polypropylene. There's a few drops of coke left in it too. Oh, and I squashed it to save space in the recycling bin. I put it in a 'mixed recycling' bin that also contained prepackaged sandwich boxes, paper towels, plastic bags, and a banana skin. I think this would be very difficult to separate automatically.
- raverbashing 8y agoThere are machines that separate the label from the bottle This video is very informative https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAr4BZM_Tzk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAr4BZM_Tzk
- maxxxxx 8y agoSeparating and processing trash would be a great example where ML, AI, robotics and other stuff would really help progress. It's a really hard problem that should be very interesting to work on. Instead we have the best minds of our generation working on building total surveillance machines and hacking the human brain to sell more crap.