3 ms·
> If there are infinite numbers, and all numbers have a name, then there must exist a number called door, another one named airplane, because at some point you
by SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago
> If there are infinite numbers, and all numbers have a name, then there must exist a number called door, another one named airplane, because at some point you would run out of numbery names, I don't remember what she said, but she didn't answer the question.
Ah, this is the philosophical distinction between every possible thing, and every conceivable thing.
The set of possible number names may be very large or infinite, but it is assembled from a small set of symbols like "one", "two" "seventeen" "million", "and", "times" and "three" "to the power of", etc.
A number called "door" is conceivable (like superman) but it is not a possible under the rules of maths (or physics in superman's case) because "door" is not in that set of symbols.
The set of the possible is a subset of the conceivable. Both sets might be infinite.
- azeirah 8y ago> A number called "door" is conceivable (like superman) but it is not a possible under the rules of maths (or physics in superman's case) because "door" is not in that set of symbols. Certainly you are able to represent "door" in a base-64 numbering system? (or base-36, or even base-28)
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoAh, but "a base-64 numbering system" is a different set of rules ;) And it's rules in which "door" is a "numbery name". And "Достоевский" is not. You could still ask "If there are infinite base-64 numbers, and all base-64 numbers have a name, then must there exist a number called "Достоевский" ?" and the same argument against would apply.
- n4r9 8y agoI think the distinction is really between "A given infinite set" and "every conceivable thing". It's a common fallacy to equate one infinity with any other infinity, and therefore any given infinity must contain all things. This fallacy is very neatly encapsulated by the phrase >If there are infinite numbers, and all numbers have a name, then there must exist a number called door