4 ms·
From the doctors I know, there are far more women than men working less than 40 hours a week (for what passes for full/part time in the medical industry, which
by zdw 8y ago
From the doctors I know, there are far more women than men working less than 40 hours a week (for what passes for full/part time in the medical industry, which can have some heinous working hours in any situation). I attribute this to the following metric - if you're in a career where even part time work is >100k USD a year, having free time soon becomes more valuable than extra money. Women seem to understand this, or at least aren't stuck in the "your job is your life" rut to burnoutville that many men get stuck in.
It seems like the solution here is "get more doctors through medical school if some want to work part time", but instead they came up with this discriminatory solution.
- oh_sigh 8y agoDo you know doctors in Japan? There may be a strong cultural element at play here.
- ramblerouser 8y agoWhy is having more female doctors preferable to more medical services in total? This seems like sentimentality getting in the way of a functioning medical system. I suspect that many here denouncing the Japanese goal of improving their medical system would defend the vague and unsupported "improve campus culture" goal for why women in the West get affirmative action.
- sudosteph 8y ago> Why is having more female doctors preferable to more medical services in total? This is a false dichotomy. They would have more medical services overall if they simply admitted the right amount of female applicants and then expand their training programs overall so that the less-qualified male applicants who are currently getting preferential treatment can simply train elsewhere to become doctors. Sure some female doctors might work less, but some won't, and there would still be more qualified medical professionals in the field overall.
- ramblerouser 8y agoI don't think you understand what a false dichotomy is. Yes. Training more doctors would mean having more doctors. But for any number of doctors trained, why not prefer to train people more likely to put their skills to good use for society?
- dang 8y agoPlease edit the uncivil bits out of your comments here. This one would be fine without the first sentence. If you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting to HN, we'd appreciate it.
- hajile 8y agoWe've over-qualified doctors to a ridiculous degree. After that, 4 years med school, then an internship, and then a few more years of residency. The average doctor finishes with almost $200,000 in debt (around 15% finish with $300,000+ in debt). The biggest issue here is that the government has effectively fixed the price to become a doctor at $200,000 (via stupid requirements) which in turn, fixes the price they must charge patients in order to be profitable. This is in addition to all the unnecessary requirements artificially restricting the supply. Consider Cuba. In 2016, they were spending $813/yr per person while the US was spending $9,403 per person. Despite this, life expectancy was/is about equal. They graduate loads more doctors than the US. Most of these doctor's don't specialize, but instead become primary care physicians. When there are a lot of them, the cost to visit your doctor for day-to-day complaints decreases and disease is caught and treated much earlier (an ounce of prevention). Degree inflation is a real killer here. A doctor must have a Batchelor's because it was decided that nurses should have one (though everything past the first 2 years makes basically zero difference on the floor). Then there's a huge middle area, so we train nurses to be not-quite doctors in an attempt to deal with the problem, but the schooling requirements for everyone just keep soaring. Eliminate the Batchelor's requirement and instead require only the classes that are actually pre-requisites for med school. These are more than sufficient to weed out all the really unqualified individuals, but would reduce the cost of schooling by many tens of thousands (allowing lower charges to patients) and reduce the time-to-market by 3-4 years. That time to market is extremely important. That's an extra 3-4 years of work before retirement. That's also an extra 3-4 years of experience (experience often being the most important thing) and those years are shifted earlier to when learning is easier. For more dexterous (eg, surgical) professions with long residencies, that 3-4 years is a huge amount of the useful lifespan. Finally, open a few more medical schools to allow more doctors to be trained. With lower costs and faster time to market, costs for all medical visits (but especially primary care). The only potential concern here is "unqualified people", but none of the tests have changed. Med school hasn't gotten easier either. The big change is more people are able or willing to give it a try and the risk is much lower.
- pragone 8y ago> [Cuban medical schools] graduate loads more doctors than the US I'm guessing you mean per capita...? > A doctor must have a Batchelor's because it was decided that nurses should have one I'm not sure where you got that from. Nursing going to the BS model is extremely new compared to physicians doing so. > open a few more medical schools to allow more doctors to be trained The hold-up here is on training positions. New schools are opening every year, but that's just exacerbating the problem on graduation - we're getting to having (we might already be there, I'd have to check the numbers again) more graduates than we have training positions.