10 ms·
A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person
- nck4222 16y agoMaybe I'm missing the point of the article but... "A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person. But it may make you happier." I would argue that if you're a happier person, you are a better person. So if a minimalist lifestyle makes you happier, a minimalist lifestyle makes you better. Seems like an odd article to me. EDIT: Seems like I'm getting flack for about "what if the person is evil but happy, are they a better person?..." Apologies for not explaining my argument well the first time. The author argues that being minimalist makes him happier, less worrisome, less irritable, and have less liabilities, but not a better person. If being minimalist makes you all those things, then I think it does make you a better person than if you weren't minimalist.
- runjake 16y agoI agree. I thought that the article's points contradicted each other and that it reads like a hastily-written lecture against the minimalism fad, whatever that is. I assume the author was targeting the average person in regards to the "better person" comment, in which case a happier person does make a better person. Their confidence is improved, and thus they tend to be nicer to others. No need for an evil clause.
- shawndumas 16y agoIt seems like you're conflating disparate things. Being curious can lead to being educated, can lead to a good job, can lead to more money, can... but being curious does not equal more money. Keeping cause and effect straight is a "happy" thing. Also, all happiness may equal better but not all minimalism equals happiness. And, most of all, being happy does not mean you are a better person. What if hurting kittens makes you happy?
- nck4222 16y ago"Also, all happiness may equal better but not all minimalism equals happiness." I agree "And, most of all, being happy does not mean you are a better person. What if hurting kittens makes you happy?" Well you're right, but extreme outliers about kitten hurting aside... If something makes you happier, less worrisome, less irritable, and have less liabilities, (like the author is saying being minimalist does for him), then yes he's a better person than if he wasn't minimalist.
- shawndumas 16y agoOk, leave sociopaths aside: Arguing makes some people happy. ;)
- sz 16y agoI think the author meant better in the sense of morally superior, not happy.
- BrandonM 16y agoAnd I would argue that an unhappy person is much more likely to be immoral. I know that it's at least true for me.
- pvg 16y agoI would argue that if you're a happier person, you are a better person. I'm sure there are plenty of perfectly happy assholes out there.
- etruong42 16y agoI would argue that they are better than unhappy assholes. As a corollary, the happier the assholes are, the better person/more agreeable they would be, and I have found that statement to be true.
- shawndumas 16y agoI would argue that they are better than unhappy assholes. What if doing hurtful things makes them happy?
- gjm11 16y agoThat doesn't say anything about whether making them happy in other ways reduces their assholishness. It might do. (Perhaps they have a certain happiness setpoint, and if they're not made happy enough by other things then they'll achieve it by being assholes.) Or it might not. (Perhaps they associate happiness with assholishness, and an increase in either provokes an increase in the other.)
- shawndumas 16y agoOk, what if being an asshole makes one happy? ;)
- tome 16y agoThis sounds highly implausible from what I know of happiness. Being an asshole helps them cope? Sure. Makes them happy? No.
- jfager 16y agoA minimalist lifestyle can have many legitimate motivations. Sanctimonious anti-consumerism isn't one of these, nor is saving money. Why not? A minimalist lifestyle can save a ton of money. I have a year-long runway to work on whatever I want full-time because I kept a pretty minimalist lifestyle for the last 3 years.
- Kliment 16y agoFrom what I understood, the point of that bit of the article is that having less stuff (for the same functionality) often costs more, and he justifies it by the digitalization of his library and media library. Therefore if your only motivation was saving money, the author argues you'd be better off doing something other than reducing the amount of stuff you have.
- access_denied 16y agoWell, I think he is wrong in regards to beeing a better person. "Costs less" can mean "costs less" environmental desctruction or social unjustice.
- qntm 16y agoIt depends on the type of thing you're trying to minimise. A low-cost lifestyle is not synonymous with a minimalist one, they are related goals but different on a practical level. Some kinds of minimalism can be very expensive. Replacing your car with a bike and a set of walking shoes will save you a tonne of money. But it might incur more effort and planning. There'll be times when the weather is rough or the distance is too great or time is too short, when having a car would have been (more money but) much less hassle. Replacing all your books with a Kindle will probably cost you because you have to buy your books all over again (you'll probably wind up in the red even if you sell all your physical books second-hand). Does going to restaurants instead of keeping food at home count as "minimalism"?
- futuremint 16y agoI think this article (and some of your points too) are conflating minimalism with simplicity. Minimalist is buying 1 Kindle and putting all of your books on it and then selling them. This is more expensive. Simple is keeping your books you want to read again and getting rid of books you've read and aren't going to read to reduce your bookshelf space. Then get a library card and check out books to read from there. Less $ and simpler, though not necessarily the most minimalist you can be. I think minimalism is one aspect of simplicity, but not the only one. Simplicity also involves practicality, economics, sustainability, etc.
- sz 16y agoI've been wanting to start an inventory of every item I own with the goal of going minimalist but it's so daunting I haven't started yet. And I'm a college student! (Maybe there's room for an app here?)
- ljlolel 16y agoWhy would you do that? Just open your closet and throw out each thing unless you used it in the last week. Just throw it out now. Tomorrow is a euphemism for never. You can always buy or borrow if you need it later. http://www.jperla.com/blog/post/stuff-minimization-framework http://www.jperla.com/blog/post/stuff-minimization-framework
- sz 16y agoAgain, I'm a college student. Re-buying stuff I threw out based on a naive criterion like that would be terrible with my limited resources. An inventory would help me better decide what to throw out and keep me organized. If someone built an inventory app that could keep track of purchases via bank reports and OCR'd receipts, I would probably pay for it.
- thecombjelly 16y agoWhat I did (http://www.thintz.com/essays/less-stuff http://www.thintz.com/essays/less-stuff) is to take stuff that I didn't think I needed and move it to the basement. If it stayed down there for awhile and I didn't miss it, then I knew there was a good chance that I didn't need it anymore.
- jtbigwoo 16y agoMy friend uses a less wasteful, but slower technique. Here's what she does every spring and fall: 1. In the fall, she boxes up or separates everything she hasn't used in the past week. For clothing, she just turns the hangers in the closet around (so the open part of the hook is facing you.) 2. She lives her life for six months. Every time she uses something, she puts it back in the normal cupboard rather than back in the box. 3. In the spring, she simply gives away all the boxes and all the clothing that is hanging backwards. She allows herself a couple of "passes" for special clothing (e.g. she might know that she has a few weddings coming up so she'll keep an extra dress.)
- pvg 16y agoSame topic but with more funny - http://bikesnobnyc.blogspot.com/2010/09/minimizing-windows-just-call-me-aimless.html http://bikesnobnyc.blogspot.com/2010/09/minimizing-windows-j...
- taylorlb 16y agoThe bike snob anti-new-minimalism thread is highly entertaining and informative. The idea that those suffering from extreme poverty are the ultimate minimalists puts the recent "wearing minimalism on your sleeve" trend in perspective IMO.
- adamhowell 16y agoAnd then you have a kid.
- notauser 16y agoWhy do children need lots of stuff? My grandfather was one of seven children, and they had one drawer each for toys and another drawer for clothes. They seemed to turn out OK. Of course this kind of thing requires the co-operation of both parents, but that's true of a lot of things.
- adamhowell 16y agoI wasn't implying that kids need lots of stuff. I was implying that then you have a kid and have more urgent things to worry about than whether or not your life is perfectly organized. Like how to get the kid to stop wiping their poop on the dog.
- runjake 16y agoTry having triplets. A perfectly organized (and frugal) life suddenly becomes a huge priority, whether you like it or not. In my case, I also took a minimalist approach and work towards getting rid of clutter, selling off spare computers or equipment for hobbies I don't have time for anymore. I haven't had a "singleton" (single born child), but I can imagine the same organizational/simplifying demands are made of you, but to a lesser extent.
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoHaving had one and having seen friends with twins, multiples are definitely harder. Yes there are certain economies of scale but I don't think they even come close to balancing up the additional chaos, effort and exhaustion. (And +1 for sympathy and respect that you've had triplets and are still here to tell the tale).
- runjake 16y ago
- futuremint 16y agoWe don't spend too much time talking or thinking about it in my house, but we do periodically clean/throw out old junk that piles in closets & the garage. I agree with his point regarding being sanctimonious about it though. We don't brag to anybody, or even talk about it much. Its just a matter of doing something we know makes us feel better and thats about it. However, over time it does save you money, because if you have to move or change your surroundings, you only need enough room for your body and not your stuff. We're moving to a new house that is only marginally larger than our current house because we're planning a larger family (it also is a higher quality house too)... not because we need more space for stuff. Its nice to only consider your living space from the perspective of what you do in it, and not have to also worry about how all of your stuff goes into it too.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Qz 16y agoFrom the comments here, it's fairly obvious that people have multiple conflicting ideas of what 'minimalist' actually means, which makes this blog post moot because no one will ever agree.
- edw519 16y agoA minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person But a minimalist coding style does make you a better programmer. I really don't mind a few extra Philips screwdrivers, kitchen knives, or pairs of shoes in my house, but I every superfluous bit of code in my repository drives me nuts. Others say I go overboard and they're probably right, but I can't help myself. If a 6 character variable name can be shortened to 5 characters without losing meaning, then I do it. Same thing with labels and function names. If I find the same line of code twice, I write a function (but only after whipping myself). Complex If Statements are replaced by Case. Complex Case Statements are replaced by arrays and pointers. Two programs look alike? Replace them with one parameter-driven program. Two forms look alike? Replace them with a flexible form app. Reports? Same thing. Old data? Archived! Old programs? Archived! Old notes? Archived! And not one trip to Goodwill, just to my e: drive. I'm so proud of myself when I can fit the software needed to run a $100 million company on a 256K thumb drive. There must be a 12 step program for people like me. But then, by the time I was done with it, it would be a 7 step program.
- robryan 16y agoGoing a bit off topic but I really hate when you have a bit of code you can either have 2 functions with some repetition or one function that gets ugly because of the number of if statements required based on parameters. Both options feel suboptimal.
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoI've found that sometimes passing in a function/function pointer as a parameter makes this a lot cleaner.
- fragmede 16y ago> If a 6 character variable name can be shortened to 5 characters without losing meaning, then I do it. So.... what, you get rid of vowels, web 2.0 style?
- Raphael_Amiard 16y ago> If a 6 character variable name can be shortened to 5 characters without losing meaning, then I do it While i totally agree with the general sentiment of your post, i'm really not sure about this one. Or rather, im rly not sure abt dis one ;) It's all about balance really, and very often this balance is only subjective, even if we generally don't like this idea
- sprout 16y agoI think the author means to say that a minimalist lifestyle does not make him a better person. He really has no idea who any of us are, or what our goals are, or more importantly what our vices are. Some of us probably would benefit from a more minimalist lifestyle.
- roel_v 16y agoPedantic note: "There is one Phillips screwdriver in my house." Uh oh. Philips screwdrivers come in varying degrees of bluntness, with the very blunt ones for the very big screws and very pointy ones for small screws. Phillips screwdrivers are not the right area to avoid redundancy. (buying one with variable bits that fit on it would be a better option).
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoNot to mention if you try using the a small Phillips screwdriver suitable for changing a plug to screw in the sort of screw you want for a sturdy book shelf (or vice versa) you're going to find yourself in all sorts of bother. Then he got rid of his books so that's not an issue he has I guess... Interesting that he does identify that you need more than one kitchen knife. Minimum for me is a decent general knife (say 7") and a bread knife.
- kingnothing 16y agoGenerally there are two essential knives; a chefs knife and a paring knife. I agree that a bread knife is nice to have, but I could probably get by without it.
- hugh3 16y agoIn a pinch (like when I find that my proper knives haven't been washed) I find that my steak knives will cut anything, from raw meat to vegetables to cheese to bread to steak. But the kitchen is a lousy place to practice minimalism anyway.
- brk 16y agoDepends on how frequently you use it, and even then it may not be a big deal. I do tons of home repairs, automotive repairs, build things, take stuff apart and so on. I have enough tools to equip a small production woodshop, plus a growing collection of metalworking equipment. And even after all that I probably use a #2 phillips screwdriver on 99% of anything that has a phillips head screw. For a "typical" person, a #2 phillips will probably serve all their reasonable needs.
- eiji 16y agoReminds me of [Paul Graham]: http://www.paulgraham.com/stuff.html http://www.paulgraham.com/stuff.html
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- aplusbi 16y agoI always wonder what the super-minimalists (< 100 personal items) do about food. I easily have 100 (less if you consider redundancies: should I count each fork individually?) things in my kitchen and most of them get used regularly. Either they are eating out all the time or they are using someone else's kitchen, both of which seem somewhat antithetical to sub-100 minimalism.
- motters 16y agoA lifestyle without redundancy is a very precarious one. Without redundancy any single failure could turn your day into a nightmare.
- hugh3 16y agoThat's why I have two hearts, in case one needs surgery. Seriously though, what kind of redundancy are you suggesting? I could have two cars, or two ovens, or two hot water systems in case my first one breaks down, but I can get by with workarounds for a broken-down car, oven and hot water system anyway.
- timwiseman 16y agoThere are very few things you could not do without for a short time or quickly get a substitute. For those few things, make sure you have a spare. For everything else, the spare is probably a waste.
- jrwoodruff 16y agoIt shouldn't be conspicuous and self-congratulatory Does writing a blog post about your minimalist lifestyle count?
- qntm 16y agoNo, but submitting it to HN does
- devmonk 16y ago'A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person' I'd like to understand why, but fixed-width, left-aligned layout at 1680x1050? Fluid width or at least centering the text would be helpful.
- jarek 16y agoHTML is a wonderful thing. It conveys structure; CSS conveys presentation, but can be overriden at user's wish. Your browser should have a zoom function. Your browser should have a CSS override function. Your browser should have a "readability" function.
- devmonk 16y agoBut a user should not be forced into using any of those things. imo, if I have an Apple monitor used by a large number of potential site visitors set at maximum resolution, then the page should at least center the div if you are going to do a fixed width layout, so 1/2 of the right side of the screen isn't a plain otherwise empty blue background. That way at least only 1/4 of the page is empty on both sides, which is less distracting. Fluid width with adjusting fluid left/right % columns (divs, or table if you must) also works.
- frou_dh 16y agoTalk about a first world problem. Who cares how the blueness is distributed in your needlessly maximised browser window? It bothers you so that you won't even read the blog post, swoon!
- jarek 16y agoA user maximizing his browser on a screen 1680 pixels wide is not a user whose particular aesthetic preferences are worth accommodating. If you choose to make your browser window wider than a line of text you'd comfortably read, you also can choose to apply any settings that will make sites look more to your liking.
- qntm 16y agoI apply a minimalist ethic to all kinds of things, including the amount of effort I put into designing my site ;)
- dockd 16y ago"I can't stand clutter" That pretty much sums up the article for me. I'd rather hear from someone who switched to a minimal lifestyle than from someone who apparently has always favored it.
- c00p3r 16y agoDoes HN transforming into a magazine for housewives? ^_^
- yason 16y agoI think that it's most important to know what you want yourself first. If you know that, then you can easily spend your money on the right things for the right reasons and, thus, spare yourself from owning all kinds of cool, new, luxury, status, or whatever objects that you only bought because you wanted to be cool or successful or you thought you wanted them. For example, I don't need a new car, a high-end mobile phone, or the ultimate gaming setup with a ridiculously expensive graphics card. They wouldn't produce much extra value to me so I don't feel justified to pay for them. However, I do love photography so buying a new DSLR and a set of lenses instead of a pocket camera was well justified even though the money spent on the DSLR was probably ten-fold.
- balding_n_tired 16y ago"There is one Phillips screwdriver in my house." How many screws do you strip by not having the right size of Phillips screw driver? How many more can you not engage? Or have you gone really minimal and guaranteed that you have only one size of head on all your screws?
- iuguy 16y agoI'd say it does. I was a gadget fiend. I know I don't want an iPad, but I would've needed one if I hadn't have tried to declutter my life. Having done so, my tiny house is now that much more spacious (but slowly clutter creeps in and now and again I have to have a massive clearance) and as the article says, I have less to worry about. In addition to this I no longer need an iPad. In fact I used one for a few hours and found it quite heavy. This year I bought an ebook reader, not because I wanted one but because I was going on holiday and wanted to read 10 books. The cost of an ereader was cheaper than buying those 10 and losing the luggage space. I read 15 books on that holiday, mostly from Project Guttenberg. I could've took a laptop and read them on that as a compromise, but I wanted something my eyes wouldn't get tired over, and a computer screen would've reminded me of work. My E-Reader now sits in the kitchen until the next time I take it out - I'm in the middle of Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five and I know I should read it but I don't. Still, next year I'll take it out and I'll get my books for much less than taking physical copies. Last year I had a clear-out of all my old DVDs - and I used to have more than my local Blockbusters (as a massive film buff a lot were obscure too) so I gave them away to charity shops. If I can find epubs of my books I think I'll do the same with them next year.
- nialo 16y agogeneralization/key point as I see it: doing x for x's sake or as an excuse to be self-righteous is bad, do things because they make you happy or make something easier. This is actually a really useful rule in a lot of other places too.