4 ms·
All of these things should certainly be given the right to exist and to be documented, but not in an encyclopaedia. Going through all your reasons: If an idea
by PeterisP 8y ago
All of these things should certainly be given the right to exist and to be documented, but not in an encyclopaedia. Going through all your reasons:
If an idea is badly argued - it's not yet ready/mature enough to be described in encyclopaedia.
The best way to critique an idea into the ground needs to happen in the scientific discussion, and only the aftermath of that critique needs to be included in an encyclopaedia.
Poking holes in our best ideas - again, that's the scientific discussion happening on papers in response to other papers; this process is good and important, but it should happen in that medium, and kept out of Wikipedia.
More awareness of wrong ideas without appropriate disclaimers that they're wrong and why they're so leads to mass disinformation and is essentially harmful propaganda. There is a tradeoff between being authorative+truthful and all-encompassing; getting one of those requires to actively work against the other. As Wikipedia has chosen that it "wants" to work towards the first, so it's chosen not to be the place that will facilitate "more awareness of the kind of ideas that exist in the world" - this was a contentious issue some decades ago, resulting multiple other wiki-like resources with lower criteria for notability, achieving what you propose but sacrificing other things that are important for Wikipedia.
An outlier opinion can later be shown to be right - when that happens, an encyclopaedia like Wikipedia should describe it.