3 ms·
"Only your friends can add you into groups." And how many of your "friends" are ACTUALLY your "friends"? As much as it was once fun to reconnect with somebody
by uptown 16y ago
"Only your friends can add you into groups."
And how many of your "friends" are ACTUALLY your "friends"? As much as it was once fun to reconnect with somebody I shared an elementary-school classroom with, that's a connection I'll need to revisit if they're given the power to latch my profile onto whatever cause they want ... implying my support of that movement.
Facebook seems to have created Groups as their implementation of Twitter Lists. I can create a list and call it whatever I choose ... adding whomever I choose to it. But my sense is that the perception of a Facebook Group is different than a Twitter List because Facebook already has/had the concept of groups, and they DID require opt-in.
- Stwerner 16y agoYeah, this seems kind of silly. I think of facebook friends as people I might have met once, not people I would trust to add information to my profile.
- sofuture 16y agoSo don't friend them on Facebook? No snark intended, I don't understand why that's always off the table in Facebook discussions. I have 95 friends, they are all family or friends or coworkers. I previously had a lot more friends, but what's the point? I'm not friends with them, I don't care what's happening in their lives nor they in mine. I'm not even leaving room for the 'trust to add information to my profile argument'. Your perception of Facebook is kind of irrelevant, Facebook is giving you a platform that does one thing. You don't get the option to disagree with what it does based on a perception of what you think it does or should do -- aside from not engaging with their product or engaging in a way based on what the platform actually does.
- chopsueyar 16y agoFacebook is giving you a platform that does one thing But that one thing keeps changing at the whim of Facebook. The service 'evolves' and expects the users to do the same. As a user adjusts to the facebook eco-system, some arbitrary fundamental change comes out, making the user constantly reevaluating their 'friend' relationships. This can be a real time suck.
- rb2k_ 16y ago> And how many of your "friends" are ACTUALLY your "friends"? 100%, but I seem to be in a minority with that decision
- sofuture 16y agoI'd say about 70%. The other 30% are family -- lord knows I'd defriend them in an instant if we didn't have to see each other on the holidays!
- X-Istence 16y agoYou are not the only one. Only real friends are added to Facebook. Same thing with LinkedIn ... although I am a tad more lenient with that!
- sprout 16y agoDo you remember what Zuckerberg said with this announcement? The 'pristine' social graph? That's the whole point. He's trying to restore the meaningfulness of saying someone's a friend. Friends don't enroll friends in NAMBLA. I have to say, for the second day in a row I kind of agree with Zuckerberg. This isn't going to be popular, but it could actually lead to Facebook being less of a distraction and more of a genuine form of communication.
- rhizome 16y ago>"And how many of your "friends" are ACTUALLY your "friends"?" By this token, I feel kind of sorry for those friends of mine who have gotten all MySpace about it and have 1,000 friends. They're the ones who are going to be most affected by this change. Perhaps the net effect will be that people will start unfriending more and honing their friend lists down to those who they actually know or who are not annoying. This would have an added benefit of increasing the quality of peoples' friend lists, or in other words, to more-tightly integrate users with their friends.