2 ms·
> Relative wealth is very important because it distorts the market. No, that's not correct. What distorts the market are artificial constraints on the market.
by pdonis 8y ago
> Relative wealth is very important because it distorts the market.
No, that's not correct. What distorts the market are artificial constraints on the market. You mention Bay area housing prices, but you fail to point out that those prices are skyrocketing because of enforced scarcity: the supply of housing in the Bay area is not being allowed to grow in response to growing demand, but instead is held fixed by local laws and regulations. That is what is distorting the market.
Relative wealth does give an advantage in this kind of situation, but that doesn't mean fixing the wealth disparity will fix the market. It won't; it will just mean that the scare Bay area housing gets rationed by some other method than who has the most money. It will still have to be rationed because demand far outstrips supply; and no matter how it is rationed, many people will be left out and will complain that the system is unfair. The only long term fixes for that are to either expand the supply of housing (by letting it respond normally to market forces), or for a lot of people to stop feeding the monster and abandon the Bay area for someplace that offers them better opportunities--which again is a normal response to market forces. And what empowers people to make those choices is absolute wealth, not relative wealth.
- lev99 8y agoThere are always going to be limited quantity goods, and inequity will drive up the price of those goods. Land is a fantastic example of this, and the Bay area housing problem is made worse by laws and regulations, it is not created by laws and regulations. Harvard only produces a limited quantity of lawyers every year, and those lawyers are paid a premium in large part because of the limited supply. A Harvard education isn't a process that can be infinitely scaled. Income inequality drives up the prices for limited quantity goods.
- pdonis 8y ago> There are always going to be limited quantity goods Some limited quantity goods are unavoidable, yes. The quantity of land in the Bay area is limited. But the quantity of housing in the Bay area does not have to be limited by the quantity of land. If it is, that's a choice people have made to impose scarcity. And decreasing relative wealth inequality won't fix that problem; you have to fix it by taking away people's power to impose scarcity to further their own ends at the expense of other people's. > Harvard only produces a limited quantity of lawyers every year Yes, which is another example of a choice to impose scarcity. See below. > Harvard only produces a limited quantity of lawyers every year But you don't need a Harvard education to become a lawyer. A Harvard educated lawyer might be better able to handle certain legal matters, but most people who need lawyers don't need that level of expertise. In fact, most people these days who need legal documents prepared don't even need lawyers; the free market has created plenty of services that provide such products at a much lower cost. The only reason why many people still need lawyers is artificial scarcity: lawyers write most of our laws, and of course have written laws saying that you have to have a licensed lawyer to prepare various legal documents, even though the lawyer doesn't actually add any value to the process. You can't fix that problem by reducing relative wealth inequality. You have to fix it by taking away people's power to write laws to benefit themselves at the expense of other people.