4 ms·
There's not much to the article. It seems that 70% figure includes people who discovered a problem with the house after they moved in or discovered that they d
by jandrese 8y ago
There's not much to the article. It seems that 70% figure includes people who discovered a problem with the house after they moved in or discovered that they don't like mowing the lawn. Also, it included the sage advice of not buying a home that's too expensive for you to afford.
The article did suggest that you should get your home inspected before you buy it like pretty much every bank doesn't already require that. It also failed to mention that home inspections are largely useless.
- thebooktocome 8y ago> It also failed to mention that home inspections are largely useless. According to whom?
- jandrese 8y agoA lot of times it comes down to conflict of interest. They are hired by the agent who is only interested in selling the home and getting the commission. Even when they aren't, finding a reputable one who will actually do a good job is extremely difficult. Most are just looking to run through a house as fast as possible and collect their fee. There isn't some directory of problems they've missed. As far as I know there isn't any way to recover costs from them over issues that they missed and caused you to buy a home that you would not have given the problems. This makes them quite prone to being a rubber stamp and yet another fee for home buyers.
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoYou're correct that if they have a conflict of interest, they are definitely useless. Don't hire the agent's inspector. Likewise, make sure you have your own agent, don't use the seller's. And if you're in court someday, don't expect one lawyer to represent both parties. Simple stuff. It's similar to buying a car: don't ask the dealer's maintenance department whether it's a good car. Drive it to your independent mechanic on the test drive and ask them to take an unbiased look at it. If you don't know a reputable home inspector, you could ask your painter, contractor, or handyman if you have a good relationship with someone who knows houses to take a look.
- jandrese 8y agoOf course if you're a first time homebuyer who has been previously renting you won't have any relationships with painters, contractors, or handymen...
- smileysteve 8y ago> As far as I know there isn't any way to recover costs from them My home inspector had a 1 year warranty on anything that he tested in his report. Does that mean the company will cover all damages or buy the property from you, no; but it is a small disincentive to be a rubber stamp.
- jandrese 8y agoI bet you would find that his report is worded carefully to not include anything that would be expensive to repair. And really, the most expensive repairs are on things you can't see. Wiring. Plumbing. Damage to the structure of the house. Even then I wouldn't be surprised if they tried to weasel out of for example your roof started leaking 2 months after you move in. The inspector will point out that there was no water damage when he inspected it so the issue developed after the inspection.
- dmschulman 8y agoThe buyer has every right to find and hire their own home inspector...
- jandrese 8y agoSure, but do you know which one is going to do his job properly? This is knowledge that very few personal home buyers have. Professional house flippers/real estate speculators might have guys they know, but shopping around as an individual there is precious little information available on how good a particular inspector is.
- dmschulman 8y agohttps://www.yelp.com/c/la/home_inspectors https://www.yelp.com/c/la/home_inspectors Also friends, family, coworkers, local real estate agents you trust, etc. Going into the entire home buying process without preparing adequately is the buyer's first mistake.
- jandrese 8y ago> real estate agents you trust The buyer's second mistake.
- davidp 8y agoThey are hired by the agent You can and absolutely should hire one yourself. Additionally, if you have a buyer's agent, don't make the mistake of using theirs either -- the buyer's agent has the same conflict of interest that the seller's does, despite the fact that in most cases they have a fiduciary responsibility to you, the buyer. Another complication to be aware of: Inspectors can face "blackballing" by banks or realtors if they scuttle too many deals by finding bad things. If you find an independent inspector, don't balk at paying a little more -- they may need it to make up for business lost from being honest.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Additionally, if you have a buyer's agent, don't make the mistake of using theirs either -- the buyer's agent has the same conflict of interest that the seller's does Not exactly. Real estate agents do care about repeat business and referrals.
- gnkiubb 8y agoNot a chance. They're rats out to make money for near-zero effort. No better than lawyers and used car salespeople. Scam artists.
- VBprogrammer 8y agoI'm not an expert but I'd tend to agree. There are simply too many things which can't easily be inspected without causing damage. We paid over £1000 in two different inspections when we purchased our house. Since moving in I've discovered that the entire extension to the house was built without lintels, electrical work which is not even close to complient and brickwork which is little more than rubble. The structural engineer said he was unable to determine whether the lintels were sufficient (because they were hidden behind plaster and face bricks) and he said that there is some evidence of electrical rewiring but that we should commission a report into that.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoIMO house surveys in the UK are a joke and surveyors are a wildly overpaid joke profession. A typical survey, even a "full" survey, is 90% disclaimer. The remaining 10% is often obvious to anyone with working eyeballs. If you want a useful opinion hire an experienced builder to assess the property - perhaps under the pretext of costing possible renovations. When I was selling my mother's house a few years ago, a builder who viewed it instantly spotted all the problems that professional surveyors either missed or couldn't be bothered to mention.
- ams6110 8y agoIt's the sort of business with low barriers to entry, and very few repeat customers. Ideal for scammy and fly-by-night operators.
- vorpalhex 8y agoI've used inspectors on both of my home purchases, and both times it was a major lifesaver. The first one caught that the house had a leveling issue (and had us bring in a foundation repair company to measure) and the second one caught a dead heater and a hole in the roof. That being said, I always hire my own certified home inspectors. Both my spouse and I have enough understanding to know when an inspector is blowing smoke and when they are looking at a real issue, and we monitor them while they do the inspection. A home inspector can't go into details on an issue - that isn't their job - they are only there to tell you what experts you need to call in during your option period.
- Johnny555 8y agoI've never had a bank require a home inspection report, and in my area, the home market is insane, so many people waive their inspection contingency entirely and skip the inspection. Though my banks did require an appraisal, and the appraiser does do a physical inspection to look for signs of gross neglect. Many buyers here also waive their appraisal contingency too, so if the appraisal comes in low, the buyer has to kick in more cash to cover the difference in the loan value.
- jandrese 8y agoAppraisers are also a scam IMHO. We weren't sure what a good price for our house would be when we were thinking of selling so we called a couple of appraisers and they both told us the same thing: they pretty much just report whatever the bank wants. Even if we paid their fee they wouldn't even send someone out to look at the house, it would be 100% just looking at comps in the area--which we dismissed because it was the middle of the housing crash and almost every comp was a short sell of a unit that had been utterly trashed/gutted on the inside.
- verelo 8y agoYep, exactly this. The bank needs to see a number so they can certify the mortgage. Unless it's something absurd, they generally just agree with whatever the sale price is. Which, if we're being serious, is fair market value by definition...but it's still pretty weird.
- toast_coder 8y agoEntirely true. I bought i super unique house, 100 years old out in the country. While talking to the appraiser asking him if the house was worth what i had offered, he said somthing like 'well if thats what your offering thats what it's worth'. In hindsight, the market would tell me the house definately was not worth it. Really i think the appraiser is there to prevent simple fraud.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> he said somthing like 'well if thats what your offering thats what it's worth'. The appraisers real job (when a mortgage is involved) for the bank is to assess the best offer they could get besides yours, since the bank wants to know what the property would sell for were your unable to pay the mortgage. Presumably, if you are buying the house, you are (exceptions clearly exist, this is a simplified model) the most interested buyer, they really should be looking as to what the next most interested buyer would pay. With large enough markets and commodity properties, which probably account for most housing sales, it's not entirely unreasonable to assume that the difference between those two is negligible, though, so I can see how it becomes a default approach.
- icameron 8y agoHome inspections are not very good at uncovering non-obvious issues. Some people want to get validation or guarantee they have a solid house without problems, however inspectors will not (cannot) dig in to find out the extent of a problem, and most trivial problems will be documented as 'recommend licensed contractor to repair' The real value in a home inspection is to have leverage to negotiate your offer down from where you started. "Licensed home inspector says this is a potentially unsafe electrical panel. My counter offer is $4000 lower"
- verelo 8y agoSadly in the Toronto market, the issue runs even deeper. Home inspections are almost always provided by the seller, and if you try get your own, as the market is so hot, the sellers typically refuses to allow it. Home inspections are mostly useless (i want to say always, but im sure there is some exception out there), but they're even more useless when they're provided by the seller and the market is so healthy that they don't feel the need to allow an independent view.
- sgslo 8y agoIn the US, at least, inspectors are liable for issues not uncovered during the initial inspection. Seller-hired inspector missed a malfunctioning AC unit? It's on the inspector - or their insurance - to cover the cost of a fix.
- jandrese 8y agoYeah, they turn it on and cold air blows, check box. Not as many will tell you that the AC unit is 26 years old and likely to die soon. In my experience you have a 50/50 shot of them actually telling you that, but my sample size is very small.
- verelo 8y agoFor large appliances yes (AC/Oven/Stove/HVAC etc), that should happen, but for other issues it's 50/50 on if you'll get covered (probably even less). Single data point: I just (last week) had a title insurance claim for ~$21,000 for re-wiring of a property denied, despite the fact that I have documentation from the purchase process stating "All Knob and Tube wiring has been removed", and a home inspection report (seller provided) that did not uncover any K&T wiring. It was missed because whoever "removed" the old wiring (owner before the previous owner) left old wiring in between circuits and the outlets, which we found by accident when removing part of a wall. Electrical safety code requires that if we need to revise any wiring on these circuits that we bring them to current code, which to confirm there is no old wiring left at all means deactivating the circuit and re-running the entire circuit. Additionally my home insurance does not cover K&T wiring, as such i have 60 days to become compliant or my insurance is void. My option here is now to lawyer up, which at best, I'm going to get $21k out of, for a $1.58m house. There should be stricter and clearer liability here, but unfortunately it's just not how the law is structured here in Toronto.
- LargeWu 8y agoThey're not useless. They're designed to find non-obvious issues that might have structural or safety implications. I've bought and sold a few houses, and most homes I've looked at either have obvious disqualifying problems, or are in fairly good repair; in the former case the inspection would reveal obvious problems, in the latter there would be none to reveal. It's when they do find something important that they show their worth. They're also useful for getting the seller to correct minor problems so they don't become major problems (here in the midwest that usually equates to preventing water from getting into the structure)
- donald123 8y agoHome inspection cannot uncover everything, but without one, nothing will be uncovered before moving in. Besides, home inspection report can also be used to negotiate price, of course YMMV.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The article did suggest that you should get your home inspected before you buy it like pretty much every bank doesn't already require that. Banks require appraisals, not inspections. While the two things seem descriptively similar, they are functionally radically different: an appraisal tells the bank a number that represents the market value of the house (used to determine if the value of home combined with the requested loan amount fits within the maximum loan-to-value ratio the bank is willing to accept—or allowed, for programs with mandatory limits), an inspection identifies specific problems and recommended corrections/mitigations. > It also failed to mention that home inspections are largely useless On both homes I've been involved in purchasing from the buyers side, the home inspection has been quite useful (though less critically so in the one that was new construction, though there's no guarantee that that is the case.)
- jofer 8y agoMost banks require an inspection as well as an appraisal. (Or at least every one I've ever dealt with has. I suppose it varies by region.) It's also common to require a foundation survey in addition to the inspection (a.k.a. a leveling survey) in areas with shrink-swell clays.
- ssully 8y ago> home inspections are largely useless Horseshit. When looking for a house earlier this year we had an offer accepted on a place we loved. Only question mark was the basement. Independent inspector took a through look at the basement and plumbing and basically said we will be living with water during the storm season without mitigation that could range between 5k and 25k. I have two plumbers in my family that took a look at the photos/report and confirmed the price estimate/work was spot on. On top of that he found asbestos (we knew before hand) and high radon levels (we did not know). Needless to say the $600 I paid for the inspection was the best money I've spent in a long time.