3 ms·
Fundamentally, the size involved. Your amplifier's capacitors were extremely large for the power the amplifier was using, as their purpose was to reduce the rip
by mindslight 8y ago
Fundamentally, the size involved. Your amplifier's capacitors were extremely large for the power the amplifier was using, as their purpose was to reduce the ripple voltage from the power supply.
One of those "1 Farad" car stereo caps (not the classiest example) can store 72 joules (watt-seconds). So to handle a 1kW excursion for 5 seconds, would take over 70 of them. Possible, yes. But probably not worthwhile.
The frustrating thing about this article is that it keeps conflating fundamental physical problems (like needing to store energy to deal with peaks), with the limitations of currently-productized circuit topologies. It's not hard to imagine an inverter that would do something similar to MPPT without needing to pull/dump the maximum power possible, would manage a small bit of local storage (a combination of caps and abused batteries), and could intelligently load shed (with "kind" brownouts) on multiple outlets.
It's also not hard to imagine an inverter (brushless motor) air conditioner that would be a lot kinder of a load, and could even operate at variable power.
But of course with the current state of homebuilding, these are bespoke ideas better filed as "off the grid". Which is the entire larger point - an "off the grid" system fundamentally costs more in materials and also presently application engineering time, than the on-grid systems being sold to homeowners.
(Although I do have to wonder about adding a piece to the current puzzle that would generate/manage a local grid frequency, and shed excess power using off-the-shelf electric heaters.)
- WalterBright 8y ago> over 70 This doesn't sound that bad to me. Size isn't much of an issue, houses have room for them. Prices for them seem all over the place: https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/1-farad-capacitor.html https://www.alibaba.com/showroom/1-farad-capacitor.html https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00381UKD0/ref=psdc_2230642011_t2_B000701BA6 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00381UKD0/ref=psdc_2230642011_t2_... The idea with a capacitor is they shouldn't degrade like batteries do. The same with an inductor, which is just a coil of wire.
- mindslight 8y ago$30 x 35, assuming a 50% discount for wholesale [0], is still $500. This may be worthwhile, but it's certainly not negligible. Electrolytics do wear out. Lifetime hours versus temperature/ripple current is a key design parameter. [0] And assuming stuff designed for the car stereo market actually meets its advertised specs. I just went to Youtube to verify that said devices weren't just a can with other components inside of them. A video with a freehanded jigsaw set to hip hop confirmed.
- WalterBright 8y agoJust to be clear, the caps were bought from the Caltech EE supply desk. They weren't for car stereos. It was before car stereos became a thing.
- mindslight 8y agoI was just using car stereo caps as an easy-to-reference bound. (I'm not in tune with current cost of bulk energy storage caps) As I was saying before, the main difference from your amplifier was the amount of power involved. In general, audio amplifiers have large capacitors on the power rails to smooth out the ripple voltage, and will coast for quite some time as they don't actually need that much power for typical music and volumes. Here's a similar example - high current USB charging bricks, with a power indicator LED. If you have no devices connected and unplug it from the wall, the LED will stay on for quite some time. The LED just doesn't draw that much current (say 10mA) compared to the capacitance, which has been designed for smoothing the full charging current of 10A. Also the LED will happily ride the voltage down from 5V to its junction voltage of 2.5V or whatever, using even less current. And due to the logarithmic nature of your eyes (ears), you don't fully perceive that dimming.
- WalterBright 8y agoThe caps were way, way excessive for the application, I was just having fun putting them in. And they didn't just smooth out the power, they were capable of running the amplifier for a few seconds. (It was a 125 watt Universal Tiger amp.) I do know that caps decay over time, but have no idea how that compares with batteries. I expect, though, that long life caps could be built. I also wonder about using inductors instead. They are, after all, just a coil of wire.
- mindslight 8y agoI feel like you're asking the equivalent of why we use DRAM instead of SRAM, or spinning rust instead of flash. And I don't want to shout that down because, as in the latter, constraints do change. But the current state of things is fundamentally based on a cost tradeoff. https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/42084/can-you-store-energy-in-an-inductor-and-use-it-later https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/42084/can-yo... https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/326177/energy-density-comparison-between-inductors-and-capacitors https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/326177/energ... Perhaps in the future we'll have supercooled inductors providing power storage, and not requiring periodic changing the way say batteries do. Alas, it's just not right now. As an aside, it's amazing how little power it actually takes to produce worthwhile sound out of modern speakers. I once wanted to test some tower speakers without a proper receiver around, so I wired up a breadboard with some stupid opamps around poorly-heatsunk transistors, powered by a lab supply. The speakers turned out to be disappointing, but not because of the amplifier!
- thinkythought 8y agoInverter drive home AC systems that are reasonably priced do exist, you can get a mini split for under $1000 now with variable drive compressor and fans. I was shocked last time i looked that up actually, as i had similar thoughts a few years ago for this application and barely anything was on the market. There's also inverter drive microwaves, and fridges even. My friend's new condo has an inverter drive fridge