3 ms·
I feel like the issue here is that there simply isn't any data that definitively maps out where neighborhoods are. I have never been certain where neighborhood
by jrockway 8y ago
I feel like the issue here is that there simply isn't any data that definitively maps out where neighborhoods are. I have never been certain where neighborhood boundaries are in any city I've lived in. I remember when I lived in Chicago I looked around
for an official source and found one from the city... except the districts had no resemblance to what people were calling the neighborhoods. Meanwhile, real estate types always had very generous boundaries ("this isn't Cabrini Green, it's Lincoln Park" ok...).
Anyway, authoritative data could exist, but you'd have to collect it by survey and you'd have to get a lot of people to truthfully reply to the survey. No financial incentive exists to collect this data, apparently; wrong data sells condos (see the Cabrini Green quip above) and correct data gets you nothing except a map that more people agree with.
On some level, perhaps people read too much into neighborhoods. "I'm a good person because I live in neighborhood X." That is probably not an association worth making, but I think it exists because the reactions to wrong information in Google Maps apparently elicit so much vitriol.
- abrahamepton 8y agoFor Chicago, specifically, the closest official equivalent is the 77 community areas (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_areas_in_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_areas_in_Chicago), which definitely don't align with how residents see neighborhood boundaries. That's in part because the CAs were created decades ago by the U of C, and aren't really allowed to change so that longitudinal comparisons can be made using them. Just speaks to how tricky the question really is. Cities have legally-defined boundaries for very good reasons while neighborhoods just...don't, so what is a mapmaker supposed to do?
- moorhosj 8y agoThe city has boundaries for neighborhoods too [1], they just aren't "official" like the Community Areas. [1] https://data.cityofchicago.org/browse?q=neighborhoods&sortBy=relevance https://data.cityofchicago.org/browse?q=neighborhoods&sortBy...
- askafriend 8y agoNextdoor.com maps out most neighborhood boundaries with some inputs from users. The boundaries are also allowed to “evolve” as time goes on and areas change.
- flomo 8y agoIn this case, there are official boundaries and they actually matter quite a bit for local politics. "East Cut" is a local neighborhood association which rebranded itself so it could expand its territory.
- ghaff 8y agoI recall a website that tried this for Boston. There was strong agreement on some neighborhood boundaries defined by particular streets. Others were literally all over the map.
- NittLion78 8y agoThis Google Map overlay is the best Chicago neighborhood map I've seen. https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/1/viewer?msa=0&mid=13rPY3gTMOtHUdmp-VKa4waVj6es&ll=41.83409121914807%2C-87.6853585&z=10 https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/1/viewer?msa=0&mid=13rPY3gTM... My only real complaint with its accuracy is I recognize that Wicker Park extends north to the Bloomingdale Line, but otherwise, it's pretty good. It includes a lot of pocket neighborhoods like Palmer Square and the Wrigleyville portion of Lakeview, too.
- jrockway 8y agoI haven't lived in Chicago for 6 years, but is that area west of the loop to about Ashland not called "West Loop" anymore?
- moorhosj 8y ago==On some level, perhaps people read too much into neighborhoods.== I think this is part of the argument the article is making. People who buy real estate put an emphasis on the neighborhood, thus realtors have an incentive to create "new" neighborhoods. West Bucktown in Chicago is an example where realtors they didn't want renters or buyers to think they were in Humboldt Park so they made up a new neighborhood.