6 ms·
I deal with this with one of the web sites I maintain. I think, as noted in the article, that it seems Google sometimes uses names from advertisements as if th
by reaperducer 8y ago
I deal with this with one of the web sites I maintain.
I think, as noted in the article, that it seems Google sometimes uses names from advertisements as if they are canonical.
In my case, the city in question puts out a very specific, very legally defined map of each neighborhood, and has for more than a century. But real estate agents make up names for the neighborhoods, or fudge the boundaries to improve selling prices (thus commissions) and make their offerings more attractive.
About a year after a new neighborhood name is invented by a real estate agency, it starts showing up on Google maps. Then I have to deal with people complaining that our locations are mislabeled, because if it's on Google, it must be right.
It happens so often that I have an e-mail macro to respond to these people. And since the web site is very well respected by the locals, a couple of times a year I get requests from real estate agents, developers, and others, to change our maps to match their needs.
I got a particularly ridiculous one just this week saying that it's "our policy" (the real estate developer's) that maps should be drawn along a certain set of lines, and that we (the web site) are required to adhere to their policy.
I laughed.
- duxup 8y ago>I got a particularly ridiculous one just this week saying that it's "our policy" (the real estate developer's) that maps should be drawn along a certain set of lines, and that we (the web site) are required to adhere to their policy. My mom says you should do something....
- daveFNbuck 8y agoWhat makes the maps that the city makes up better than the ones that the real estate agents make up? If people are using the latter to determine where to live, doesn't that define a neighborhood?
- bkor 8y agoCity council determines the areas within a city; it is NOT made up. Some areas are much more popular than others. Leaving this to random people is absurd. The areas don't suddenly change. Anyway, this is how it is like in The Netherlands.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoSo the maps made by the city council are superior because they're a better reflection of how popular an area is?
- extralego 8y agoNo. It defines advertising. Neighborhoods imply far more than geography; things like culture, traditions, cooperation, people define a neighborhood. This is, among other things, the contents of trust. The idea of a foundation on which to make a happy life amongst they neighbors can involve many different things, so it’s vague, but the most important part is that the participants themselves are who develops the neighborhood; not capitalists trying to profit from it. Gentrification is a prime example of where this becomes a cruel and unusual form of manipulation, but it’s not the only one. What Google is doing should absolutely be considered a crime.
- reaperducer 8y agoWhat makes the maps that the city makes up better than the ones that the real estate agents make up? In this case, the city designations are important because each year the city divides a pot of money that goes to supplemental infrastructure improvements in each neighborhood. Because it's supplemental money, it is a fixed amount for each neighborhood. If a neighborhood's boundaries increase, then money available for improvements in that neighborhood is stretched thinner. If a neighborhood's boundaries shrink, then more money is available for improvements per block. This is why boundaries matter, and why they are codified.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoThat's a good reason for why the city shouldn't arbitrarily change its official definitions of neighborhood boundaries without also changing budget allocations. Why shouldn't everyone else define neighborhoods however they feel is most useful to them?
- Retric 8y agoWho else should make that decision? Agents will arbitrarily change maps basted on what their current listing are and would happily change them daily. Longer term there is little point changing place names as changing demographics will eventually adjust the meaning of these names even if no lines move on a map.
- Spivak 8y agoNobody/Everybody, if people start calling a region by a name it makes sense to record the usage and put it on the map. Sure, it probably makes perfections and planners twitch but it makes maps more useful.
- extralego 8y agoI notice a lot of Americans love referring to Canada as “Canadia”. I can’t make a bit of sense out of it, but by your logic we should update the maps already.
- com2kid 8y agoThe maps made by the city have legal impact. They control everything from funding to allocation of community resources. For example, in my city each neighborhood has an official community association that is acts as a liaison to the city. Improvement projects are also designated by neighborhood, long term planning and resource allocation is on a per-neighborhood basis.
- ErikAugust 8y ago"I think, as noted in the article, that it seems Google sometimes uses names from advertisements as if they are canonical." --- "Currently the predominant business model for commercial search engines is advertising... We expect that commercial search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers..." - Sergey Brin and Larry Page, 1998 http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html
- dickbasedregex 8y ago"...or live long enough to see yourself become the villain."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- extralego 8y agoNice link. It is incredibly interesting that the Google founders were so outspoken against advertising. I’d love a detailed account of the process which derailed these moral ideals. Anyone?
- mschuster91 8y ago> I’d love a detailed account of the process which derailed these moral ideals. Anyone? It's relatively easy and fits into what Google has been doing: they want advertising to fit the (current) needs of the consumer, and the better the fit, the more money they can command for ad slots - compared to the "old guard" which simply firehosed advertising around without any kind of conversion tracking or effectiveness. For example, when I'm in Munich and searching for a haircut and I get ads for a haircutter in Berlin, that ad money is wasted for the advertiser, and I as a customer lose one potential spot for a Munich based haircutter. When Google now shows me an ad for a Munich haircutter, or even better, one that is less than 5min of walking away, then both the haircutter benefits (from my haircut) and I benefit (for not having to walk more than I need to). Or, to expand on this example, metadata like opening hours - advertising for a store that is closed is wasted money when I need an open store. All that acquisition of ever more data is what drives Google: the more data they possess, the more fine they can tailor your advertising, and thus be geared towards both advertisers and users at the same time. After all, if the ads aren't effective, the advertisers will pack up shop and leave, and the users will be frustrated because they don't get what they need.
- ben_jones 8y agoAnd this was how my definitely in the Tenderlion apartment showed up as SOMA in all searches.
- raldi 8y agoSan Francisco also puts out an official map, but like many other official maps, it lacks many of the neighborhoods people expect to find: Sunnyside, Japantown, the Tenderloin, Dogpatch, Hunters Point, Mission Bay, Hayes Valley, Miraloma, Cow Hollow... and so in order to give users what they want and expect, Google has to gather data from other sources. http://sfplanninggis.org/NeighborhoodOrganizations/ http://sfplanninggis.org/NeighborhoodOrganizations/
- batbomb 8y agoWhat a lovely map. Glen Park BART isn't even in Glen Park in that map.
- raldi 8y agoYeah, according to the city, it's in the Outer Mission, directly north [sic] of Bernal Heights.
- samstave 8y agoI like this also: https://i.redd.it/domryaykbdn01.jpg https://i.redd.it/domryaykbdn01.jpg https://www.reddit.com/r/etymologymaps/comments/86eef7/san_franciscos_hidden_etymologies/ https://www.reddit.com/r/etymologymaps/comments/86eef7/san_f...
- adfm 8y agoYou have to wonder if this has anything to do with their Neighborly app. Maps are how we collectively tell our stories and controlling the language used in those stories affects the outcome. Remember when everyone was calling that chunk of SOMA with the shitty overpriced condos the East Cut? What ever happened to all the people that lived there after the crash?
- Apocryphon 8y agoTFA is literally about the East Cut.
- closeparen 8y agoThe build quality here is as good as it gets for multifamily, IMO.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> The company declined to detail how some place names came about, though some appear to have resulted from mistakes by researchers, rebrandings by real estate agents — or just outright fiction. Every lawyer knows what is happening. Copyright 101 - you cannot copyright facts, a big deal for mapmakers. Google is pulling data from a map created by someone else. They are quiet about it because they do not want whoever owns that original map to catch wind that their work acts as source material for google maps. Some map creators fight this by adding fictitious names, even streets, into maps. You can copyright fiction. So if your fake street name gets used in some other map you may have a case (the same game happened with phonebooks). No doubt google cross-checks source maps to detect such things. So it is no surprise that from this shady little battle we get the occasional strange name. My work moved buildings a year ago (military facility). We have been trying to get our location changed on google maps for over a year, but are constantly refused. No matter what we say, taxis and pizza deliveries still go to the wrong place (a couple blocks away). Whatever source maps google uses obviously trump our opinions. We are debating installing a sign at the old location. Maybe google streetview will see it.
- RileyJames 8y agoHave you tried registering with “Google My Business”? I update a local businesses address though that (when they moved location) and it was updated on the maps immediately (possibly a few days delay at most). Who refused you? What other method did you try?
- sandworm101 8y agoI don;t think registering a military airbase on "google my business" is appropriate. We aren't a secret location, but still aren't focused on increasing our web presence. We just want the bus and taxi companies to come to the correct place when we call them. (They never listen to the address we give them. They google us and drive to wherever google maps says.) We tried the "report and error" and "claim this business" functions on maps. Both were rejected. I got a note from a moderator person saying the new location was a construction site, which it was three years ago. Now we are in the new building.
- xbmcuser 8y agoMy previous condo address # suddenly changed to adjacent number in google 2 years ago. I edited multiple times to the correct address and my corrections were rejected every time . Even submitting a government website showing the correct address didn't work. As I had moved I didnt care anymore but a few weeks ago I got a notification that 1 of my edits was approved.