3 ms·
>and how they treated the local Germans in the east as the war wound down You mean by showing massive amounts of restraint? Nobody would have asked "why" if t
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>and how they treated the local Germans in the east as the war wound down
You mean by showing massive amounts of restraint?
Nobody would have asked "why" if the Russians had burned most villages and murdered a good chunk of the German civilian population. More than a few people were surprised when the soviets didn't do that. Likewise nobody would have asked why if the US didn't stop at two bombs.
Sure a few people would have complained had the Soviets burned east Germany to the ground or the US had continued to atom bomb what was left of Japan but there almost certainly wouldn't have been any serious backlash.
The world had seen a lot of death and destruction between 1939 and 1945 (and a decade of depression before that). A couple million more of the people who started the mess likely wouldn't have moved the needle on most people's give-a-shit meter. People care about avenging the deaths of people they know and preventing more people they know from dying far more than they care about civilian casualties of the enemy.
Yes I know this is probably uncomfortable to read from your air conditioned office but when your drive to the front takes you through a burnt out village where some of your distant relatives once lived revenge starts looking better and when every page in your high-school yearbook has a couple people who won't ever be showing up to a reunion turning an island into a smoldering rock in order to not have to invade it looks like a really good option.
- mc32 8y agoWow, so when soviets kill civilians in the aftermath it’s “restraint” but when the US bombed an active enemy it's unreasonable use of force??? I can only imagine what the soviets would have waged on Japan had they landed an invading occupying force.
- coldtea 8y ago>Wow, so when soviets kill civilians in the aftermath it’s “restraint” but when the US bombed an active enemy it's unreasonable use of force??? Well, close to 20 million Soviets died by the war, and they didn't have done anything to provoke it. The US didn't have any of that excuse. And even Pearl Harbor (which was a tiny blip compared to the Russian death toll, and on an annexed island far away from the mainland US) happened after months of purposefully provoking the Japanese to attack so that the US government could convince Americans to enter the war.
- barry-cotter 8y agoThey didn’t show any restraint. They killed anyone who looked at them sideways, raped any woman they fancied the look of and ethnically cleansed more or less every German east of the Oder without regard for who died. The Russians could have done worse, they could have had an actual policy of genocide.
- belorn 8y agoBased on all the historians I have seen talking about that time period, the Russians captured and sent every German they could get their hands to labor camps during the later part of world war 2. An approximate two to three million German prisoners was captured during those years and about 1 million died in the camps. The documentary The World at War postulated that the only reason why its not higher is that when the Germans had lost and started retreating most of the east German population fled in mass to the west because they know the USSR would treat them very similar to how the Nazi treated Russians during the occupation. About 10 million USSR civilians died and about 26 millions in total so the USSR had a lot of reasons. I have not heard any historian that claimed that USSR did not pursue revenge. I have heard however that the only reason Berlin was not razed to the ground was because allied troops rushed there hastily during the siege in order to be able to claim half of it after the war.