3 ms·
>And that was, to the US, unacceptable while the USSR was closing in on Japan from the other side, and they had two perfectly good bombs they wanted to test and
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>And that was, to the US, unacceptable while the USSR was closing in on Japan from the other side, and they had two perfectly good bombs they wanted to test and send a clear, post-WWII-era message.
The final stages of the Manhattan project hummed along without much political involvement. Dropping nukes to show the USSR who's boss really wasn't on the radar of the military (they were preoccupied with the war). Politicians outside the executive branch were mostly in the dark and Truman wasn't exactly keeping a close eye on things.
Remember, the alternative in 1945 was more firebombing and an invasion several months down the line. The Soviets just finished mopping up the problems in central Europe. They couldn't be counted on to commit their armed forces to the far east in meaningful quantities. "But the civilians" isn't really a valid concern when there's a Japanese army running around China committing war crimes and enemy civilians will commit suicide (or be murdered by their army) rather than surrender at all. In 1945 you can't justify the alternative courses of (in)action.
- mistermann 8y ago> "But the civilians" isn't really a valid concern when there's a Japanese army running around China committing war crimes and enemy civilians will commit suicide (or be murdered by their army) rather than surrender at all. When I read people in the 21st century wagging their fingers at people's immoral behavior in the past, I often wonder to myself if they've read any history (or even better in this case, browsed some photos), look at the world through a lens so different than mine that I can't even fathom what the world might look like through their eyes, or with the overwhelming number of conveniences and hyper-optimized processes that power the bubbles we live in, maybe they simply can't see the amount of complexity and uncertainty there is in the world.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoAnd the US casualty estimates for that invasion were staggering. In fact, if a US soldier gets shot in Afghanistan today, the Purple Heart they receive was created for the invasion of Japan. After Korea. After Vietnam. After Grenada, and Panama, and Serbia, and Kuwait, and Iraq, and Afghanistan, we're still using Purple Hearts that were made in 1945 to cover the expected casualties from the invasion of Japan. About the USSR: The deal was that they were supposed to attack Japan three months after the surrender of Germany. They did so to the day, on August 8, 1945 - two days after Hiroshima. You can interpret this two ways. One is that the US wanted to send a message to the USSR. The other is that the US wasn't sure that the USSR would do what they said, or wasn't sure that it would be enough if they did. And in fact, there was a mutiny in Japan to disobey the emperor and keep fighting - even after both atomic bombs and the USSR attack. So saying "that was just politics, sending a warning to the USSR" is very much not warranted, given the situation at the time.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>And the US casualty estimates for that invasion were staggering. In fact, if a US soldier gets shot in Afghanistan today, the Purple Heart they receive was created for the invasion of Japan. After Korea. After Vietnam. After Grenada, and Panama, and Serbia, and Kuwait, and Iraq, and Afghanistan, we're still using Purple Hearts that were made in 1945 to cover the expected casualties from the invasion of Japan. >About the USSR: The deal was that they were supposed to attack Japan three months after the surrender of Germany. They did so to the day, on August 8, 1945 - two days after Hiroshima. Citation? Both of those sounds believable but I want to read it somewhere other than a pseudonymous online comment. >So saying "that was just politics, sending a warning to the USSR" is very much not warranted, given the situation at the time. That's what I'm saying. The political situation with the USSR wasn't even on the radar of the people managing the bomb program.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoTurns out the first quote was a bit off. https://www.stripes.com/blogs-archive/the-rumor-doctor/the-rumor-doctor-1.104348/are-purple-hearts-from-1945-still-being-awarded-1.116756 https://www.stripes.com/blogs-archive/the-rumor-doctor/the-r... says that there have been some new Purple Hearts ordered, but there are still Purple Hearts from WWII in stock, and they are still being given out. For the second quote: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War (first paragraph under "Summary").
- coldtea 8y ago>The final stages of the Manhattan project hummed along without much political involvement. Dropping nukes to show the USSR who's boss really wasn't on the radar of the military Yes, it was on the radar of the government.