3 ms·
As the man once said, it's no more moral to earn your living from cleverness by hoodwinking people than from strength by strong-arming people. Francisco's speec
by barrkel 16y ago
As the man once said, it's no more moral to earn your living from cleverness by hoodwinking people than from strength by strong-arming people. Francisco's speech excoriates the latter; but it has little to say about the former.
In fact, it has contempt for what it describes as fools, and seems to equate monetizable value creation with moral righteousness; as such, it works well as a justification for selfishness for those well placed in the nexus of supply and demand, whether by luck or skill.
Of course, relatively little value creation is monetizable, and that creation which is is generally not rewarded in full according to its value. because of transaction costs. Much as we'd all like to be independent short-term contractors selling our valuable output to the highest bidder at every moment, we can't - the ancillary costs are too high, most of the time. So, most of us undersell our skills for a longer term contract, and the surplus is collected in proportion by those who own the most capital.
It's my personal suspicion that Ayn Rand is held in such high regard largely because of the guilt it assuages in people who would otherwise be uncomfortable feeling "greedy". It doesn't seem to work that way for me though, as it seems to be transparently flattering to the reader, with flimsy, threadbare arguments. That's all besides the tedious writing.