4 ms·
"That is, when they're not too busy partying." Stopped reading there, that is just stupid. So people are supposed to feel guilty because they party now? My su
by Tichy 19y ago
"That is, when they're not too busy partying."
Stopped reading there, that is just stupid. So people are supposed to feel guilty because they party now?
My suggestion: stop breathing, that way you can save Co2 output of your country and aid the developing countries who will be the first victims of the climate change.
Sorry that I can't express my anger in a more sophisticated way. I just think contrasting world problems with party pics is an incredibly cheap shot.
- stcredzero 19y agoWhat you're objecting to is a straw man. No one is requesting that you should become a monk. But maybe just a little more energy and resources directed towards global problems might be a more balanced position. There is even money to be earned in doing so. (The Grameen Bank is a good example. So is Dean Kamen's new distiller.) See Bjorn Lomborg's Ted Talk on cost/benefit in solving global problems! http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/62 http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/62 And lastly, as Abbie Hoffman used to say: if someone ever says something to get your goat, they struck gold!
- davidw 19y agoI read the article, but came away with a sense of "go fix big problems" and very little sense of what sort of thing he thinks people ought to be doing besides > rebuilding a flawed, false global economy: one which actively transfers wealth from the poor to the rich, from the sick to the healthy, from productivity to cronyism. which, frankly, sounds like a little bit more than I can handle at the moment. It also sounds "hand wavy" - it would help if he specified some details. In terms of actual poor people... it seems to me that the Chinese, for instance, are actually getting a lot wealthier these days. But that's happening due to their own opening up, and global trade, not because of some entrepreneur in SV.
- stcredzero 19y agoLarry Brilliant talks about a web crawler constructed with modest resources that could find evidence of emerging pandemics faster than WHO. http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/58 http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/58 So there are things that us hackers could do. Another is a Java project for a low cost medical records database usable by hospitals in the 3rd world.
- davidw 19y agoI've churned out a fair amount of open source software over the years. I like it, but it doesn't really pay. I just feel that his article comes off more like a rant than listing problems that need to be solved, and will generate revenue, because in the end, that's got to be part of the equation too, otherwise he should just be hitting up people with money to spend more of it on charities.
- stcredzero 19y agoClean water is one area where someone stands to make a lot of money and do a ton of good at the same time. And as far as money to charities goes, there's money out there. Figuring out the best way to spend it is an ongoing problem.
- wanorris 19y agoAt the risk of drifting further afield from the topic, isn't the real solution to to scarce water supplies better filtering and water recycling -- in other words, wouldn't there be plenty of water if we just took what went down the drain, filtered it, and piped it back out again? Feel free to correct me if I have misunderstood the problem.
- stcredzero 19y agoDoing it at a cost that people can afford is the issue, especially in the third world.
- Tichy 19y agoBut then it is maybe more efficient to make those people richer than to build cheaper filters. Cheaper filters is just one puzzle piece for getting richer, anyway.
- stcredzero 19y ago
- umair 19y agoguys, 0) if you want responses from me, it would help if you commented where the original post is. 1) these shocks are distinctly not "random fluctuations". they are long-term shifts. 2) what should you be doing? like i said - redress the imbalances these shifts point to. whoever can find a solution to food or water imbalances, for example, is going to be bidding on private islands with larry and sergey. 3) we are very definitely not fixing these problems: the level of cleantech investment is tiny, etc. 4) i appreciate that it's a lot to handle. but aren't you guys supposed to be revolutionaries? thx to everyone for the comments.
- umair 19y agofyi, davidw - your open source point is waaay off base. the point of my post was that solving big problems = big $$$, so we should be investing in them. just my opinion, but cynicism is a great way to never have the imagination to fix these problems.
- davidw 19y agoI could see you not caring for the "hand wavy" or "rant" comments, but my open source line is simply saying it like it is - there's nothing cynical about it. I've spent tons of my own time working on open source software, and while I've gotten a lot out of it and enjoyed it immensely, I don't think that in monetary terms, it adds up to a great deal. Like many people here, I don't have "big $$$", so that cuts me out of the investing part of the equation. Let's put it this way: maybe your article makes more sense if specifically directed at people with money to invest. As a hacker, either I have a big green/anti-poverty/etc... idea for people to invest in, or I don't, and as one without such an idea, your article comes across as a bit of a harangue about something I have little control over, having neither the '$$$', nor that kind of idea. And one final note: there are plenty of practical and noble ideas that could help millions of people that aren't, however, money making ideas. Once again, your article isn't clear (to me at least) on whether that's what people ought to be spending their money on, or if you think that investors can make a buck by investing in this stuff.
- davidw 19y ago> redress the imbalances these shifts point to. To me that sounds like politics, unless you're going to be more specific, or at best economics (distribution of scarce resources). I think many of us are concerned about that kind of thing (and active), but given our own comparative advantages, may feel that it's best to concentrate on what we do best. > level of cleantech investment is tiny There are a few guys here with money to invest, but not that many. That's a fair comment, though. > i appreciate that it's a lot to handle. but aren't you guys supposed to be revolutionaries? I'm not sure I'd define myself that way - I'm a hacker with a predilection for open source software, and I like to "build stuff". I can't speak for other people. Right now I'm simply hoping to be able to find a niche where I can make a good living for myself making something cool, and my guess is that that probably doesn't include big, world changing ideas. Can't speak for anyone else, but I'd probably look askance at anyone who describes themselves to others as a "revolutionary". Guess I'm at an age where I'm content to leave the world a better place than I found it by doing my part.
- Tichy 19y agoStartup People are just people like everybody else, though, somehow trying to get by. It is not like most of them are swimming in money, trying to be successful just for fun. So why should they have a special responsibility? I am not against solving the worlds problems, but I suspect it makes more sense to focus on the problems you also have a chance of solving. And I buy into the "to create wealth, create value" mantra (or what is it exactly). Anyway, I think if somebody is successful with their startup, they probably have build something that people want, and hence made the world a better place. Even if it is just a game or some stupid network, I think it is still valid and valuable. If the starving people get their first computer, they'll want to have something to play, too. If the only goal would be survival for everyone (without any prospects of fun), I would probably look into deep freezing technologies. Finally, I would like the challenging blogger what he himself is doing about those problems?
- menloparkbum 19y agoHe's not that far off the mark. The amount of partying going on in Silicon Valley right now is extreme. There are startup mixer events at least every three days. Last week during "Web 2.0 Expo" there were 2-3 per NIGHT. These aren't wine and cheese and show us your powerpoint type events, either. It is straight up barfing on the sidewalk and the sales team doing coke in the bathroom. The frequency and intensity of these events has been steadily increasing over the past year, in the same manner as they did right before the dot-com bust.
- be_evil 19y agoYou still have not provided a reason why partying is immoral or bad for business. People in tech live terribly isolated, anti-social lives for the most part.