10 ms·
> Backfeeding the power grid, according to some lineworkers I've talked to, is really not a big concern for two reasons. First, lineworkers assume lines are liv
by taneq 8y ago
> Backfeeding the power grid, according to some lineworkers I've talked to, is really not a big concern for two reasons. First, lineworkers assume lines are live until proven otherwise. And, second, no residential system is going to successfully backfeed a large dead section of grid. [...] it's really not that big a concern from a technical/safety perspective.
This is wrong and dangerous. Suddenly energising a section of grid which has been isolated from all known power sources could easily kill someone working on it. Yes, lineworkers will isolate and test lines before touching them. No, this won't protect them because your inverter could start outputting after they've tested. Yes, your inverter will probably overload and trip out before putting too much voltage into your local section of the grid, depending on where it's isolated. No, it's not OK to bet a random stranger's life on it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoI like to always highlight the difference between a technically correct statement and a public health and safety policy statement. A thing may be technically correct, but for the health and safety of the public at large we need to adhere to a consistent policy with what we say in the public sphere. Mains voltage is dangerous and kills kills kills. Never connect anything to the mains power supply unless you are licensed to do so, or employ someone who is licensed to do so. Always assume a circuit is live unless you-personally have checked and locked out the breaker with your own personal lockout device that only you have the key to.
- maxerickson 8y agoYou are supposed to have a license to plug a TV into the wall? I'm being silly, but you are going on about how the wording of statements matters.
- jjeaff 8y agoFunny enough, if you've ever done a tradeshow at a venue that has union labor, they will literally make you fill out a request and wait for a licensed union electrician to come and plug your TV (or phone charger or anything with a plug). You will then receive a bill for their time. And if you plugged in your TV yourself, and they find out, you just unplug it immediately and wait for the licensed union electrician to come plug it in for you again.
- megaman22 8y agoI hope you are not suggesting that that is in any way reasonable.
- whatsstolat 8y agoHold on... Show me your HN posting license.
- HappyFapMachine 8y agoIn my country, it's required by law for every employee to have a certificate even for plugging in a toaster. The training is easy though and serves mostly to prevent injuries.
- ethbro 8y agoWhat do they teach you not to do?
- ryandrake 8y agoQuestion ever-expanding bureaucracy?
- jandrese 8y agoWhat does the training cover? "Do not rest your tongue on the plug as you insert it into the wall." I get that electricity is dangerous, but are there really functioning adults hired by a company that can't be trusted to plug in a simple appliance without a safety briefing first? It seems insulting to their intelligence. Or do they make everybody do this so the one or two absolute morons don't feel bad about being forced to take the "completely basic life skills" course before they're allowed to function at even a very low adult level?
- organsnyder 8y agoThat's not been my experience (in a previous life I did 5-6 shows a year, and was yelled at by union reps more than once for hand-carrying my own materials in). At the shows I did (which included venues like the Cobo Center, various downtown hotels, and other union-heavy shops), the union electrician would wire up an outlet for you, but you were then free to plug in what you wanted (as long as it was UL-listed).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoHa! Good one ;) Yes, it’s meant to say something like us unlicensed folk aren’t permitted to hardwire anything to the mains supply. In Australia you’re not even supposed to replace an existing power point outlet thingo unlicensed. If course, the hardware stores sell them, and we do. But there ya go.
- taneq 8y ago> In Australia you’re not even supposed to replace an existing power point outlet thingo unlicensed. In fact you're not allowed to install any fixed wiring without an electrical license. It's ridiculous - technically you aren't even allowed to install Ethernet outlets in your own house because it counts as "fixed wiring". Other trades have just as bad a grip on legislature, you're technically not allowed to replace your own tap seals either. > Of course, the hardware stores sell them, and we do. But there ya go. Of course, in theory there's no difference between theory and practice... ;)
- ethbro 8y agoAs far as I know... there's no documentation of home power systems in the US. So the difference between "electrician installed" and "mysterious, unknown person installed" is only in the finished product.
- ams6110 8y agoIndeed. It happens all the time that a homeowner does significant wiring projects in their own home. Everything you need is available at the local hardware store or Home Depot. Some do a good job. I've also seen things like lamp cord used in fixed wiring behind walls or in attics.
- 13of40 8y agoI inherited some piece of furniture - I don't recall what - that my wife's ex had attached a florescent lamp to. He used a telephone cord for the 120v power connection.
- zaarn 8y agoI mean, in the US you should be careful atleast since the US plugs expose mains voltage where your fingers might be able to reach (UK and EU plugs are much better and make it mechanically impossible to touch the exposed copper before they make contact with mains). Generally, playing with voltages above 50V is something that should be done with care and a professional/adult present.
- herf 8y agoTR plugs are required now in the US. We replaced ours because it looks a lot better than outlet covers.
- zaarn 8y agoInteresting, is there some image of the TR plug, I couldn't find anything online?
- mixmastamyk 8y agoFound this: https://www.esfi.org/resource/what-is-a-tamper-resistant-receptacle-538 https://www.esfi.org/resource/what-is-a-tamper-resistant-rec...
- maxerickson 8y agoSearch "Tamper-resistant electrical receptacles". They don't really look all that different, there's just a mechanism in the holes that prevents some foreign objects from being inserted.
- zaarn 8y agoYeah that's not really better at all. You can get the same protection with 3$ child-protection covers here. The issue is exposed live voltage when you plug it in. Schuko and Europlugs generally don't allow this (even the flat plug is designed such that the contact aren't exposed anymore when they make contact)
- 8y ago
- dang 8y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- maxerickson 8y agoMy comment is snarky, but it doesn't criticize a weaker interpretation of what they said, it points out a problem with the phrasing. The "I'm being silly" is an acknowledgement that the snark isn't really addressing the substance, the strongest plausible interpretation of "I'm being silly" is that I understood their meaning well enough.
- dang 8y agoFair enough on the "I'm being silly"—that does take the edge out of the comment and that's good. But I'm not sure it gets rid of it. Pointing out "problems with the phrasing" doesn't make for very substantive discussions. Also, snark is deprecated here. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- slededit 8y agoI disagree with you on the phrasing aspect for this specific case. When discussing an advertising message the phrasing is extremely important. Albeit the thread didn't invite substantive discussion on it because of the snark.
- alkonaut 8y agoWhen I work on electrical wires at home, I test if they are hot after flipping what I believe is the correct fuse. If I’m right I know it won’t become hot while I work on it because I control the switches and fuses. If I worked on wires where I was not in control of incoming power, then I can not be sure the wire isn’t hot just because I measured once. This is for example the case when working with stuff with big capacitors. So my point is: can line workers really assume a wire isn’t hot just because they tested it? They don’t control both ends, since as you pointed out, anyone could have a) a power source or b) a faulty connection, whether it’s allowed or not. So as a line worker I’d basically just not touch anything even in supposedly dead grid sections.
- crististm 8y agoWhen they work on train power lines, what they do is physically short them to the tracks.
- zaarn 8y agoI recommend shorting to ground. Even if it's your own fuse. Shorting means that if you picked the wrong fuse you notice. And when your friend comes by and flips the fuse back on you don't get a spark shower (something like this has happened to me, don't underestimate people willing to flip fuses for no reason)
- wlesieutre 8y agoA common solution for this is lockout-tagout, where you physically lock the breaker open using a lock with your name on it, and nobody can flip it until you come back and take the lock off. Used on electrical circuits as well as dangerous machines if you need to climb inside a compactor for maintenance or something. https://www.osha.gov/Publications/3120.html https://www.osha.gov/Publications/3120.html http://www.deenergize.com/?target=Universal_Circuit_Breaker_Lockout_Device_(PSL-CB) http://www.deenergize.com/?target=Universal_Circuit_Breaker_...
- zaarn 8y agoThat works too, though IIRC the common procedure in the industry in my country is to use a warning label/shield and hang it on the breaker box during repairs, locking the breaker box itself, then short out the circuit to ground and measure to be sure. Locks on the breaker itself are more rare (usually for low voltage repairs where the common person might frequent the area)
- lb1lf 8y agoI guess the point is that if your residential solar setup attempts to backfeed a dead grid, it will effectively see a short circuit which it, try as it might, will be unable to generate any voltage across, trip and your house is as dead as the rest of the grid. For this reason, I'd be most surprised if there's a single backfeed system in existence which doesn't isolate your house from the grid once the grid goes down. Edit: Finally got around to reading the blog post to the end and found that the author makes this exact point in the paragraph following the one quoted in the comment above.
- cesarb 8y ago> Yes, lineworkers will isolate and test lines before touching them. No, this won't protect them because your inverter could start outputting after they've tested. The lineworkers I've seen that aren't working with live wires use a special tool to ground the wires (it's a set of three clamps connected by a thick wire to a grounding rod). Once the wire's grounded, it's going to be hard to put any voltage on it.
- tzs 8y agoHere's a photo just after they did that while repairing a break near my house a few months ago: https://i.imgur.com/6TckAa8.jpg https://i.imgur.com/6TckAa8.jpg The obviously missing third top line is the one that broke. It simply snapped around the middle of the span between that pole and the pole that is outside the photo on the right. They went up in the cherry picker, cut the dangling line, and then put on those clamps. They then covered the lower arms of the pole with orange sheets: https://i.imgur.com/zZ3DFSd.jpg https://i.imgur.com/zZ3DFSd.jpg Does anyone happen to know what the orange sheets are for? They did not use them anywhere else where they grounded the wires.
- cesarb 8y agoI've seen lineworkers use orange covers many times, when working near live wires. The place where they put these orange sheets in your photo looks like a disconnect switch between the wires on either side of the pole. So the wires coming from the left side of your photo are still live, and the disconnect switch itself is still live. Since they would be working near the disconnect switch (to hang the new wire), they put these insulating orange covers for extra protection.
- sandworm101 8y agoIt can also do strange things to outage reporting equipment that assumes power to be flowing a paticular way.
- amluto 8y agoI would also expect that a larger residential inverter could successfully backfeed the load side of a single distribution transformer (i.e. just a few houses). If the line workers are repairing a distribution transformer or its associated hardware, this could be a big deal. I don’t know if the workers make a habit of physically disconnecting all of the houses that are connected.
- sathackr 8y agoI'm not a lineman but am a generally curious person, which has caused me to watch and analyze their work when I see it. Any time I see them working directly on high-voltage lines, they connect a device that looks like jumper cables in-between the phase(s) and ground. They also put bright orange flags on this device so that it is easily visible to anyone nearby. It seems to be a great practice and seems to make things nearly fool-proof because this effectively shorts out any power that may occur on those lines. I don't think I've ever seen a lineman work on a power line in a manner that would cause him to be electrocuted if surprise power were to occur on the line. I'd bet it's in policies and procedures somewhere, possibly even in OSHA requirements. The requirement of not backfeeding is another layer in this multi-layer protection scheme. If a system is successfully backfeeding the grid, something is badly wrong. If a linemen is then electrocuted by this backfeed, something is almost impossibly wrong.
- planteen 8y agoI agree with your comment about back feeding and shorting lines that are supposed to be de-energized, but linemen also sometimes have to work on hot lines. They have all kinds of neat tools and techniques for doing this. Seeing a lineman with a cheater stick (fiberglass pole) or insulated gloves working on a live line is pretty neat.
- Retric 8y agoDuring a flood I once saw a HV line that was occasionally dipping into the river. It would float down for a little bit, build up some tension, then shoot into the air creating a ~4-5 foot blue arc as the line shorted into the river before landing back in the water and producing a huge thumping sound. That completely changed my perspective on all those quite lines dancing in the wind.
- sathackr 8y agoYep, and when they work on hot lines, they treat them as such, using the protective gear you mentioned. I cannot think of a time that I saw a lineman working on a power line that was not shorted, without protective gear. Working on a hot wire is a whole different story because every thing around you becomes a hazard. I do work on towers, sometimes in hot-RF environments (TV and radio antennas transmit with up to ~100,000 watts). The antennas will literally cook(like a microwave oven does) you if you get too close while they are live. For lower power situations, you can even hold your hand near the antenna -- it feels like a heat-lamp. Even at reduced levels, it can be harmful to areas of your body with poor circulation and cooling(such as your eyes), often causing damage before you're even aware of it. We wear an RF monitor when in those situations that alerts us if the RF field becomes stronger than is safe. I wonder if linemen wear a similar device that can alert them if an EM field becomes stronger than expected?