4 ms·
Xmarks might not be quite dead yet but it probably will and should be. They seem really attached to the idea that the data (or as they ponderously call it, 'th
by pvg 16y ago
Xmarks might not be quite dead yet but it probably will and should be.
They seem really attached to the idea that the data (or as they ponderously call it, 'the corpus') they have is very valuable. $9 million (with an impressive $2 mil/year burn rate) later they haven't figured out a way to extract any of that elusive value.
Browser bookmark sync is becoming a built-in feature in many popular browsers. Cross-browser support is an edge case that overlaps with the functionality of a number of web-based bookmarking services which generally offer a richer and more useful feature set than in-browser bookmarking.
In the period of about a week they've persuaded fewer than 30k of their users to maybe pay them $10/yr. This is probably not all that surprising given the above and the fact they've already announced that should they run into difficulties, they'll simply give up. Short of Stockholm Syndrome, it's hard to imagine why anyone would choose to rely on their service going forward, even if someone is foolish enough to buy them out.
- jacquesm 16y ago> even if someone is foolish enough to buy them out. Well, wait a bit longer and the price just might become right.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoProblem is I stopped using Delicious years ago. I need my bookmarks in my browser. If I have to go to a website to find something, that's going to be Google or DDG. A great solution would be for Delicious/Yahoo to buy Xmarks and integrate the two technologies - your bookmarks are stored on Delicious as they currently are, but synched to every supported browser you use.
- pvg 16y agoProblem is I stopped using Delicious years ago. That sounds like a personal problem! More seriously, there are several extensions that provide in-browser interfaces and local storage for bookmarking services. For the hardcore bookmarker, there are even a desktop apps - the ones I know of for OS X are Delibar and Pukka. Personally, I don't find the browser integration extensions terribly useful. In the case of Firefox, the Bookmark Manager is probably slower than using just about any bookmarking service. It's certainly slower and clunkier than pinboard. Firefox's Live Bookmarks can also be used to give you a local menu of bookmarks if you point it at the RSS feed of a bookmarking service. I think there are extensions that let you do that in Chrome and Safari as well.
- blaix 16y agoI tend to use Delicious for "this is interesting" type stuff, especially stuff I want to share. I use my browser's bookmarks for stuff that is only important to me: work-related stuff, bill stuff, etc. Having cross-browser syncing for built-in bookmarks in addition to my Delicious bookmarks has been great. I'm hopefull they can live on and pledged my support. Edit: There's also bookmarklets. These are not a good fit for Delicious. Having these synced as well is wonderful.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoThanks a good system, I might start doing that too.
- lurchpop 16y agoI think that's a great idea. Another possibility is instead of charging users they should charge site operators to get preferred listings on that site.
- joshu 16y agoBrowser bookmarks w/ folders never mapped to delicious w/ tags. We tried.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoInteresting, each folder can't be mapped to a tag of the same name?
- st3fan 16y ago"They seem really attached to the idea that the data (or as they ponderously call it, 'the corpus') they have is very valuable." This is very scary. This likely means that their data ... No, YOUR private data, is sitting on their servers, completely UNENCRYPTED. Your bookmarks, your history. This worries me greatly. If they can use YOUR private data to make money, then they can also give YOUR private data to any government organization that asks for it. This is stark contract with for example Firefox Sync, which uses strong cryptography that is initiated by the client. The server simply stores encrypted blobs. There is no way anyone can look into your data. Or analyze it. Or sell it. Or give it away. Or get hacked and expose it. Encrypted data is worth nothing to anyone except YOU the owner.
- jonknee 16y agoIf the Feds want your bookmarks they can already get them now. I can't think of anything exciting in my bookmarks, maybe you somehow have a bunch of secrets in yours?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- htsh 16y agoI don't think you're fighting effectively by screaming and calling the person you're talking to uneducated. Fighting for privacy is great, but you're not always going to be right just because you're on the right side. I think there's a valid point made here, that bookmarks aren't that much of a worry relative to other information. Also, xmarks has been quite open about their practice of using these bookmarks to make money to operate. They have never hidden the fact that they were working on a curated search engine with this data. -h