3 ms·
> slavery was immoral, but that immediate manumission was impractical and would lead to serious social and political consequences, both for those who would have
by mixmastamyk 8y ago
> slavery was immoral, but that immediate manumission was impractical and would lead to serious social and political consequences, both for those who would have been freed and for the nation itself.
Indeed, we saw the effects of that during the Civil War. Perhaps Jefferson had more of a sense of the rising conflict than folks tend to give him credit for.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Indeed, we saw the effects of that during the Civil War. No, because to the extent that immediate manumission happened during the Civil War, it's hard to separate the effects from those of the war and the occupation of rebel states by the Union itself; manumission as a policy (the Emancipation Proclamation) was adopted as a result of the war, not a factor contributing to it.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThe two are intertwined, not cause/effect. A pure state's-rights argument doesn't hold unless you've the primary reason for conflict.