7 ms·
"banks are overlooking or turning away a large group of creditworthy customers, and so far it doesn't seem like that is happening." Bank do refuse to lend to l
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
"banks are overlooking or turning away a large group of creditworthy customers, and so far it doesn't seem like that is happening."
Bank do refuse to lend to large segments of the population which can be lent to profitably.
In China, part of the reason is caps on loan interest rates.
But banks in developed countries, like the US and the UK, also fail to serve a large segment of the population. Those underserved by banks have limited options to get loans for emergencies etc., and difficulty building their credit history to gain access to cheaper credit in future.
If you're based in London and are a software engineer or data scientist interested in solving this problem, please email me (personal address in profile) and I can tell you about what we've built so far and what's ahead.
- pkaye 8y ago> Bank do refuse to lend to large segments of the population which can be lent to profitably. Why do they refuse to lend if it is profitable?
- TooBrokeToBeg 8y agoBecause of risk. Just because there's 10k people out there that can afford to borrow and repay, doesn't mean you set 100k loans hoping you got some of them.
- sanderjd 8y agoThat's the point the parent is making. If the risk profile is as you say, that isn't a profitable segment for the banks. The question being asked is: why would the risk profile be any different for peer to peer lenders than it is for the banks? If it isn't profitable for the banks, and the risk profile isn't different for the peer to peer lenders, then it won't be profitable for them either.
- Viliam1234 8y agoThe profit made by the bank needs to also cover the cost of employees, bureaucracy, huge buildings, etc. For a peer-to-peer lender, even tiny profit is enough. As an example, imagine that you lend someone $100, and there is a 50% chance they will pay you back, and in that case they will pay you $210. And all this costs you is a mouse click. Some individual would click "yes". In their free time. Now in the bank, there is an employee doing this as a part of their paid job. They have a manager, that manager also has a manager, plus you need to pay the janitor, etc. You also need to pay diversity training for all of them. And all financial transactions they do must follow all kinds of regulations, which regularly change. Simply, the overhead is not worth it.
- ksec 8y ago$100 > $210 is an ridiculously high interest rate. In a world today where borrowing cost for a lot of people are ~10% APR. But I do see mobile payment and mobile borrowing could be mounted together.
- xivzgrev 8y agoSee points above. Banks, being an integral part of the financial system, are only allowed to take on so much risk. Third party companies have no such restrictions. But they can’t issue loans because they are not a bank. So what happens is a bank issues a loan according to criteria the bank and the third party agree to. Then the bank sells it the next day to the third party. That way the bank is more insulated from risk because they aren’t holding the loan.
- bboreham 8y ago> they can’t issue loans because they are not a bank I have to think there is some misunderstanding here - lots of nonbank companies issue loans. Ford Motor Credit is not a bank. The thing that banks are uniquely allowed to do is to take deposits, and lend out that money.
- echevil 8y agoAlso, they need to "predict" whether the loan would be profitable as they have not loaned the money yet. The decision largely depends on the precision of their prediction
- SatvikBeri 8y agoIn the US, a major portion of it is that banks are limited in the data they use. For example, certain lenders highly restricted in how they can use zip code in any automatic algorithm. So they stick to manual processes (which are only profitable on large loan sizes) or very simple automated algorithms. Non-bank smaller lenders often have many fewer regulations, allowing them to make more targeted automated algorithms, which means they can serve people banks can't.
- AlexCoventry 8y agoAre there documented cases of non-bank lenders redlining?
- rahimnathwani 8y ago> > Bank do refuse to lend to large segments of the population which can be lent to profitably. > Why do they refuse to lend if it is profitable? Good question. Note I didn't say it is profitable for the banks to lend to those segments. I said those segments can be lent to profitably. In order to profitably lend to customers who banks turn away (mostly those with a 'bad' credit history based on credit bureau data, or those with little/no data at the credit bureau), you need: 1) Effective credit underwriting (i.e. accurate models/processes to decide whether to accept a particular application, and how much to lend to that applicant at this time), and 2) Efficient processes of acquiring, onboarding and servicing customers. When a bank lends 10k at 8% for 3 years to a low risk customer, they'll make over 1k in interest over the life of the loan. So they can afford to have inefficient operations/systems. When you lend 500 to a customer who is likely to pay back, e.g. 600 over the next 6 months, there's only 100 in risk-adjusted margin there, to cover all your costs of underwriting the loan, following up on missed payments etc.
- Someguywhatever 8y agoI feel like the Market Segment is so small, and your costs will be so high, and it requires so much expertise and oversight/monitoring that it won't be worth it.
- Woberto 8y ago"Worth it" is subjective; it doesn't necessarily have to be about turning a big profit. In fact if it's a nonprofit, then the goal could be to just help under-served communities, and it seems like it could have a positive enough impact to attract some angel investors
- Spooky23 8y agoMost places cap interest at 25-35%, that’s too low for high default customers.
- neffy 8y agoBanks are limited in the total amount they can by regulatory controls to prevent uncontrolled expansion of the money supply.
- brownbat 8y agoFor the same reason Google shutters profitable projects, or why oil drilling companies often pack up but sell the rights to someone else to pull out the dregs, or why Annhauser doesn't make high quality craft brews. They aren't profitable enough for an organization of that size. Markets get segmented into tiers. With banks that might create a situation where the easiest lending targets get processed by the highest volume, lowest cost institutions, and the small valuable cases become boutique. The problem with that is, unlike other boutique areas, the wealthier person can spend a little more for a limited run high quality good. But here the boutique has to sell to the poorest groups, so it's hard to compensate the provider through pricing for the lower efficiencies of being smaller. It might shut down services that the industry would provide if less consolidated. I'm not defending this, just presenting one possible way this could be playing out even with everyone acting more or less rationally.
- jklinger410 8y agoI tried Affirm (https://www.affirm.com/ https://www.affirm.com/) -- I missed one payment because of a bad check from my employer and I was barred from the service permanently. Even though only a week went by between payments, and I payed off all of my loans as soon as I got paid.
- thephyber 8y agoSeems like it's clearly spelled out in their FAQs: Q: Do I have a credit limit with Affirm? A: Unlike a credit card, Affirm is not a revolving line of credit. While customers can take out multiple Affirm loans at once, each Affirm loan application is evaluated separately as a closed-end transaction. An application from a returning customer may be denied, however, if that customer has failed to repay other Affirm loans on time or if the customer shows excessive borrowing behavior.
- Spooky23 8y agoThat’s a very fancy appeal to advocate for usury. The credit building is a little much... not sure what >30% interest builds.
- schnevets 8y agoNon-bank lenders have plenty of other motivations besides usury. - Many immigrant populations thrive because more established members of the community invest in and loan to their peers (especially family members). They may not have twenty years of credit history and market research, but they have close-knit ties that go back generations and a person's reputation as leverage. - A Planet Money episode after Hurricane Sandy mentioned studies that proved a small business was more likely to survive a natural disaster if it worked closely with other businesses. The conclusion was that businesses would provide informal loans to one another to keep everyone afloat until the insurance claims could be processed (which could take months)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- samstave 8y agoOne problem is that the populations that are underserved by banks are over-exploited by those options made available to them; "Cant get a loan due to less-than-perfect credit? Then pay 4,000% interest!" --- The finance charge ranges from $15 to $30 to borrow $100. For two-week loans, these finance charges result in interest rates from 390 to 780% APR. Shorter term loans have even higher APRs. Rates are higher in states that do not cap the maximum cost. https://paydayloaninfo.org/facts https://paydayloaninfo.org/facts
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"The finance charge ranges from $15 to $30 to borrow $100." For context, US banks typically charge this $15 to $30 in overdraft fees, for payments of less than $50. For example, see the table and note immediately below it here: https://www.alaskausa.org/overdraft/optin.asp https://www.alaskausa.org/overdraft/optin.asp
- emodendroket 8y agoIn my opinion, if it only possible to lend to someone at usurious interest rates, we're trying to paper over more serious problems with lending (e.g., the person may need the money for some necessity of life but cannot really afford whatever it is)
- rahimnathwani 8y agoI imagine that most (but not all) people reading this comment have savings that could cover either (i) an unexpected expense of $500, e.g. to repair the car they use to drive to work, or (ii) an unexpected one-off $500 drop in income, e.g. due to a gap between casual jobs. But many people, even in rich countries like the US, don't have a buffer to deal with situations like these. To many of them, paying $100 interest so that they can get their car fixed today, and continue to go to work and earn a living, is a rational and reasonable decision when compared with the alternative (can't drive to work -> no income -> can't pay bills -> ...).
- emodendroket 8y agoRight, so there is an example of a serious problem which I don't think is best addressed by predatory lending. Sending your child to work in a coal mine or selling them off to someone into slavery were also rational economic decisions but there is a reason that, as a society, we no longer tolerate these things.
- taurath 8y agoI wish we, as a society (being the US) could agree on what is intolerable. It feels like a near majority is cynical that actually helping anyone will improve their lot, and that the only thing that works is a stick.
- emodendroket 8y agoYeah, I'm not even sure we can agree on the child labor one anymore.
- vram22 8y ago>Bank do refuse to lend to large segments of the population which can be lent to profitably. >In China, part of the reason is caps on loan interest rates. How exactly is that the reason? I thought about it, and guessed that you may mean that it is because lenders cannot charge high interest rates to those segments, but if they are a risk anyway (guessing because poor or have unpredictable income), why would banks want to lend to them? I mean, even if banks were allowed to charge higher interest, the borrowers could default on the principal or the interest, right? [Not a financial expert here.]
- b_b 8y agoI believe Grameen Bank deployed in Bangladesh [1] is an innovative and effective example of one way to solve some of these problems. [1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grameen_Bank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grameen_Bank
- godzillabrennus 8y agoIn the USA we get http://www.avant.com http://www.avant.com