5 ms·
To be fair, I'm not entirely convinced that a truly universal system is the best. After all, a single parent has significant additional expenses - and should ta
by vorpalhex 8y ago
To be fair, I'm not entirely convinced that a truly universal system is the best. After all, a single parent has significant additional expenses - and should taxpayers be paying to give violent criminals a work-free existence? (Would you pay a living wage to someone who sexually assaulted your daughter?)
In the US, this is especially a problem. The cost of living in Texas is low enough that my salary as an engineer gives me a very high quality of life - but the same salary in NYC would be very different in life results. A federally set UBI then seems... well, to have the same issues that minimum wage do.
- dota_fanatic 8y agoWith money comes mobility, so people are free to move somewhere cheaper. Currently, those in the poverty cycle are trapped and chronically stressed, making it quite difficult to execute a plan that involves anything more than what's right in front them—moving out of city or out of state is out of the question. One of the biggest problems facing humanity is sustainability towards the planet. Unbounded population growth eventually breaks everything we all need to survive. If we incentivize having children more than it already is, some people will spawn just to get at that extra money for themselves and do the bare minimum to "raise" their children. And the kind of person that does that does not raise stable, healthy children who will come into their own as productive, healthy members of society...
- macintux 8y ago> With money comes mobility, so people are free to move somewhere cheaper. I'm skeptical that most people who are currently trapped in poverty would receive enough UBI to make that practical. Money doesn't stretch as far in a strange place with no network to fall back on, even if nominally the cost of living is lower.
- rcxdude 8y ago> With money comes mobility, so people are free to move somewhere cheaper I think generally people are not very willing to move regardless of cost. It takes (on average) quite a large economic gradient to move people out of a location they are comfortable in. Social ties to a location can be very strong indeed.
- delecti 8y ago> and should taxpayers be paying to give violent criminals a work-free existence This is exactly the problem. Recidivism is high because society doesn't give released prisoners any way to support themselves. Giving ex-cons a lifeline as soon as they get out would go a long way toward keeping them from ending up back in prison. So yes. Taxpayers should give ex-cons (even violent ones) a way to support themselves without resorting to crime again. And we shouldn't release prisoners if they're still a danger, which means we should focus on rehabilitation instead of just punishment.
- bunderbunder 8y ago> should taxpayers be paying to give violent criminals a work-free existence? If doing so significantly reduces the recidivism rate (which I strongly suspect it would), then yeah, I'd say that be an easy 'yes'. I wouldn't be at all surprised if $X in free money given to ex-cons translates into much more than $X money saved by society. Getting mugged costs a lot more than just the money that was in your wallet. There's (often) medical bills, there's police officers to pay, there's lost productivity due to having to replace ID cards and whatnot, etc. If someone then gets charged with the crime, the costs balloon even further as you deal with further police costs, jail time, time for taking the case through the courts, etc. And if they get convicted, there are even more costs associated with that.