3 ms·
> Oh and when people read instruction manuals. A decent manual beats a "discoverable" GUI almost always. Sorry, but nope. You can rant about GUIs all you want,
by xg15 8y ago
> Oh and when people read instruction manuals. A decent manual beats a "discoverable" GUI almost always.
Sorry, but nope. You can rant about GUIs all you want, but UX research did yield a lot of actual insights about how people interact with systems and learn usage. From a learning standpoint, RTFM is enormously inefficient and error-prone.
You can learn about usage of an application a lot faster if you can use existing knowledge (e.g., leveraging standard UI widgets or menu items) and if the application gives you feedback loops, so you can evaluate what a command did or will do (ideally before it does anything consequential)
- oblio 8y agoWhat do you mean by that? Didn't you also learn about balls by someone giving a 100 page dissertation into spheroids? After all, all the info you needed was in there!
- PurpleRamen 8y agoI think most people couldn't read yet when they learned about balls. A better example would be games. Remember how thick the manuals were 20-30 years ago? Remember when you last time read a manual for a modern game?
- oblio 8y agoI'm perfectly fine not having to read manuals for games...
- boomlinde 8y agoI don't think that this is a question with an absolute answer. Standard UI widgets and current design conventions aren't always great or even good ways to tackle the problem in terms of productivity and efficient use. For a complex productivity application that I'll use daily for a long time, learning the basics is always a relatively small initial hurdle whether it takes an hour or a week. It's much more important that its application of standard UI widgets doesn't get in the way of productivity later on when I am at a stage of learning where I can perform the basic operations from muscle memory. For such an application, say a music sequencer, 3D modelling software or CAD software, I'd much rather have a terse UI and a manual in a binder than standard UI widgets that are worse than specialized solutions that take into account every aspect of the problem.