16 ms·
GUIs, on the other hand, are much better about showing a user what options / commands are available. Except when they're not. Take Blender for example - the GU
by onion2k 8y ago
GUIs, on the other hand, are much better about showing a user what options / commands are available.
Except when they're not. Take Blender for example - the GUI is contextually sensitive in the sense that buttons do different things in different circumstances, but they don't inform you why or what you can do to change their action. Consequently options are greyed out seemingly randomly. You can't discover things because you can't know the way they work consistently.
Good GUIs are discoverable. Bad GUIs actively work against discoverability.
- atticmanatee 8y agoThat is just bad design. You would have the exact same problem with CLI if a command was contextual sensitive.
- kaffeemitsahne 8y agoBlender has a fantastic UI though.
- fwsgonzo 8y agoIt is objectively one of the worst in existence. Same as with photoshop. It just ended up like that, everyone learned it that way, and now no one dares to revolutionize. I tried to work strictly with the B (3rd) and A (4th) color channels separately in photoshop but I clearly don't understand how its supposed to be done. Blenders UI is a horror show unlike anything in existence. Blender is extremely capable though. No question about that.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Blenders UI is a horror show unlike anything in existence. Blender is extremely capable though. That kind of goes together, though. Simple UI is usually a symptom of lack of capabilities of the software at hand. When your software has a lot of power, UI design becomes tricky. Doubly so when, like in case of Blender, you aim for efficiency of usage, which is usually at odds with typical UX guidelines, and instead expects the user to actually learn something.
- gaius 8y agoIt’s extremely difficult to craft any interface, GUI or CLI, that is both efficient for regular users and easy for casual users.
- onion2k 8y agoI have no doubt that if you work in it every day and properly learn how it works then you can do amazing things with it very efficiently. It's a complex tool for doing complicated tasks that works for those users who need to do that. But it definitely isn't discoverable, and it's often touted as a good app to learn 3D graphics with or something to use to make a quick 3D sketch. It's neither of those things.
- pasabagi 8y agoI think perhaps the most important thing to learn about 3D graphics is patience. 3D graphics is a craft. If you're from an art background, you're used to the idea of drawing the same things every day for decades, and still not being 'ready' - because you're not just training your brain, you're training your eye and your body. It's the same with Blender. So I'll agree that it's not a good program for a quick sketch - but I think it is a good program to learn 3D graphics. Ultimately, what you learn in a craft is how to train your body and eye to make fine movements and spot fine differences, at a good rate. That's why people who are good at drawing are good at clay sculpture. The nice thing about Blender is it's really designed to appeal to somebody who knows the program like the back of their hand. You can incrementally improve your process, taking repetitive tasks and working out how to do them more efficiently. Ultimately, it's this approach which will make you a better artist - and the unfortunate truth is, there isn't an easy road to this point - you get there by being frustrated.
- justinjlynn 8y agoAnother blender example: hidden options revealed by sliding the container (which doesn't scale the contents displayed but instead slides out hidden space to reveal additional controls and options)
- mikenew 8y agoVim is contextually sensitive too, and it doesn’t tell you why “q” sometimes types a letter, or starts recording a macro, or exits the program. Because vim is specifically designed for power users who want a lot of capability and a very effient workflow. And so is Blender. Blender has an almost unbelievable amount of capability and it can give you access to nearly all of it with a few keystrokes. It’s designed so that you can keep your right hand on the mouse and your left hand on the keyboard to do almost everything. It has a fantastic UI that can reconfigure to do modeling or video editing or texture mapping or rigging or animation or a dozen other things. Discoverability is not one of the design goals. Don’t take an overly simplistic view of an incredibly powerful program.
- boomlinde 8y agoVim is not primarily a CLI program, it's an interactive editor with a GUI. That this GUI is sometimes laid out in a row/column addressable terminal is besides the point. CLI means that you operate the interface via a command line. I guess this is true for Vim if you use the Ex mode exclusively, in which case there is no context sensitive 'q'