3 ms·
How a newspaper, magazine, or book publisher works: 1. a writer creates content (which can sometimes just be figures like a table); 2. an editor reviews the c
by derefr 8y ago
How a newspaper, magazine, or book publisher works:
1. a writer creates content (which can sometimes just be figures like a table);
2. an editor reviews the content;
3. the editor passes the content to a layout artist + typographer to fit the text into one or more spreads, manually tweak padding and add page breaks where appropriate, and style it to fit the house style;
4. and then, crucially, the editor signs off on it again, ensuring that the layout process hasn’t changed or misconstrued the meaning or importance of the text.
This is likely exactly how e.g. Apple’s keynote presentations are made. It’s likely how their website and printed materials are made. It’s how any modern publishing workflow works, in fact. So why shouldn’t it be how their financial statements are made?
To do anything else is to invite error—both brand-messaging error, and semantic error. Whoever pasted the Excel sheet into Word and formatted it probably was probably doing so with much less oversight and auditing than a real publishing workflow would introduce. They could have introduced errors, not just of formatting, but of meaning (by e.g. cutting off a column of the report in the final PDF, even though the preview looked okay, because it went past the bleed of the margin.)
Financial people aren’t supposed to have to care about things like margin bleeds, and everything else that goes into preparing a “proper” PDF; that is the job of a publishing department. Financial people have an exacting eye for ledgers, but that doesn’t make them experts on editing non-tabular data. As soon as their tabular data is on a page, a publishing editor is what is needed to ensure the result is correct. And it is much better still if the publishing department is the one who puts the tabular data on the page. It is strange, to me, that Apple is not having them do it.
(All that being said, probably Pages wouldn’t be used, since Pages isn’t really an Apple-scale desktop-publishing software in the way that Keynote is an Apple-scale presentation software. Apple, internally, probably uses “real” desktop publishing software—Adobe InDesign, or Microsoft Publisher—for all this kind of work.)