3 ms·
President Trump ran on a slogan of "Make America Great Again", MAGA on his campaign merchandise. His actual platform consisted largely of protectionism for var
by nostrademons 8y ago
President Trump ran on a slogan of "Make America Great Again", MAGA on his campaign merchandise. His actual platform consisted largely of protectionism for various old-line industries like steel, coal, and manufacturing, on the theory that this would restore jobs to the American Rust Belt, a geographic area that's been hard-hit by the shift to the information-age economy. It also included a heavy dose of anti-immigrant sentiment and opposition to policies like net neutrality that the tech industry heavily favors.
dfee is pointing out that the initials of the top-4 most valuable U.S. companies also spell out MAGA - Microsoft, Apple, Google, Amazon. And this is hugely ironic, because the employee base at these companies skews heavily towards Trump's opposition party. And is largely composed of immigrants. And they are headquartered in regions - Seattle and Silicon Valley - that are overwhelmingly anti-Trump. And he has been not all that friendly towards them.
And yet one of the greatest accomplishments he takes credit for during his presidency is the surging stock market. Which is largely driven by these MAGA tech stocks. So the actual beneficiaries of this newfound wealth are Bay Area homeowners, who hate him, and Indian & Chinese engineers, who hate him, and other young Americans who work for these companies, who by and large hate him.
Meanwhile the primary effect of the tariffs that were supposed to "Make America Great Again" has been to trigger stiff retaliatory tariffs on rice & soybean farmers, who are staunch Trump supporters. And the primary effect of his anti-immigration policies has been to deport small business owners in the Midwest or migrant farm workers in California's Central Valley, both areas that strongly support him.
American politics is weird, and largely theater.
- BadassFractal 8y agoFantastic write-up, I commend you for writing the above in a way that feels factual and non judgmental. Rare to run into writing like that, that doesn't immediately reveal one's political allegiances. Got a Twitter or some other outlet of your writing that one can follow?
- kirubakaran 8y agoI have https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=nostrademons https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=nostrademons bookmarked and I regularly check to see if he has made any new comments. I've done this for years.
- BadassFractal 8y agoGlad I'm not the only one who felt that way, thank you!
- ataturk 8y agoTrump is not anti-immigrant, the policy is about illegal immigration primarily. It is also about making sure that companies don't abuse the H1-B rules, which they clearly do and have done, which drove wages down and made plutocrats more wealthy. I read a lot of negative sentiment in your post, but I wonder, if you aren't a populist, what are you? As far as Silicon Valley goes, I think they are tone deaf as to the plight of the rest of the nation. I think people their believe they are smart, which they are in certain dimensions, but perhaps not very smart overall. If they were smart, they would be more pro-American as those who were born citizens have tremendous advantages in life and those who have made the US their adopted land, owe their prosperity to their new citizenship. Instead, as you so rightly pointed out, those areas have imported a workforce that holds loyalty back to their home countries (and China is a communist country) and thus they really don't aspire to the American dream or making America a better country. And that's just sad. As far as tariffs go, the re-negotiation of trade agreements is a long-term play, the effects of which will not be felt for many years. The breathless media paints it as bad, but they hate Trump and want to bring him down, so does their opinion even count? The second reason for the tariffs, beyond economic, is strategic. To provide for our defense, the US might take steps to protect certain key industries. And we can debate US militarism on and on (and I am not a fan of US Imperialism at all) but the bottom line is that other nations protect their strategic industries and the US has a strong reason to do so, too.