2 ms·
The best advice I can offer for people who know what they are doing (eg: HN readers), for their homes and home offices, is to separate the functions of modem, r
by walrus01 8y ago
The best advice I can offer for people who know what they are doing (eg: HN readers), for their homes and home offices, is to separate the functions of modem, router and wifi.
Have a DOCSIS3 / DOCSIS3.1 modem that is a dumb L2 bridge. TP-Link makes decent ones that are compatible with Comcast. You can find them and their reviews on Amazon.
Use something like a Ubiquiti ER-X (Edgerouter X) for your WAN-to-LAN interface and NAT. The Ubiquiti EdgeOS is developed by a team of people they hired away from vyattta when vyatta was sold to Brocade. It's a fork of Vyatta with a decent UI on top of it, and full SSH access. Which is of course based on Debian.
Have no wifi functions in your router!!!
And then something like a set of ubiquiti UAP-AC-LITE or UAP-AC-PRO access point(s), as needed. You can set up the ubiquiti unifi controller inside of a debian VM in virtualbox. The controller does not need to run persistently , just once to provision the APs, if you're doing basic WPA2-presharedkey authentication for your home. Bring up the VM again in the future on your laptop if you need to make changes.
This is a pretty low budget but highly effective solution ($65 cablemodem + $48 router + $78 wifi AP).
If you prefer Mikrotik to ubnt, there are a lot of small, similarly sized things you could replace the ER-X with that are in the $45 to $80 price range that will perform similarly.
- wtallis 8y ago> Have no wifi functions in your router!!! Separating the ISP-controlled modem from the router is certainly good advice, but I can't see any strong reason to recommend separating the AP from the router. If you know your AP needs to be located far from the router in order to provide decent coverage, then it makes sense. Otherwise, there's no technological or economic justification for putting three exclamation marks on that point. You just make your setup a lot more complicated (a whole extra VM for the admin tools?!)
- walrus01 8y agoThe Venn diagram overlap of routers that have serious admin features and routers that have wifi built in is not very large. Separating the wifi allows you to replace or change wifi without bringing down services to local hardwired home servers.
- wtallis 8y agoWhat do you mean by "serious admin features" for a router? They run Linux and any third-party firmware will give you ssh access. What's missing? And swapping out WiFi radios is something that you only need to do once every few years, so it's nothing that should weigh on the decision about what to use in the meantime—especially since new APs can be added to the network without requiring you to physically decommission the WiFi capabilities of your primary router.