3 ms·
>The point of wikileaks is that they verify the authenticity of things they publish, and the veracity of past leaks gives credibility to future ones. How, exac
by krapp 8y ago
>The point of wikileaks is that they verify the authenticity of things they publish, and the veracity of past leaks gives credibility to future ones.
How, exactly, does one verify the authenticity of illegally obtained, classified information?
Other than to just publish it and see how angry the government gets, I mean.
- ceejayoz 8y agoYou vet the source, you corroborate with other sources, you check against unclassified info available, etc. In many cases, you can ask the government if they want to comment before you publish. Sometimes they will (and sometimes it'll be "on background" or "an anonymous source"), other times they'll ask you not to publish, sometimes they'll just shrug their shoulders. National security reporters do this pretty much daily.
- krapp 8y agoNational security reporters have credentials, Constitutional protection and a working relationship with the military and intelligence, often coming from that world. Wikileaks is considered an espionage organization and Julian Assange is hiding in an Ecuadorian embassy, probably avoiding the windows. I don't think he or his organization gets the same leeway as, say, CNN or Reuters when it come to that.
- ceejayoz 8y agoSure, but that only prevents the "get a comment" part... and that you could probably get around if you had a friendly relationship with a reporter. The "verify against other sources, public info, etc." stuff is still entirely doable. In the case of Collateral Murder, info about the incident was already public, making the video something you could vet... and I'd imagine plenty else in Manning's leaked info was vettable.