3 ms·
"but I can never get them to say what any particular idea(s) he has that's useful or true/important but not already well known" Philosophy does not rack up fac
by pmoriarty 8y ago
"but I can never get them to say what any particular idea(s) he has that's useful or true/important but not already well known"
Philosophy does not rack up facts in some sort of storehouse of knowledge.
Much of the value of reading Plato is that he gets you to question your own assumptions and those of others, and does so in an accessible and easy to understand way.
What is justice? What is good? What is the best way to govern? What is true? Where does knowledge come from? Why should any of this matter?
Most people without any philosophical training go around acting like they have the answers to all of these questions, or that they're self-evident, or that they don't matter.
Plato helps us to see that we and various self-styled experts might not know as much about these as we thought.
Later philosophy tends to get more and more technical and jargon-filled, and (at least in Western philosophy) tends to assume a familiarity with Plato.
In many important ways, you would be either lost or missing an important piece of the puzzle were you to try to dive in to later philosophy without a knowledge of Plato, as philosophy to a large extent is a dialogue with earlier philosophers, of whom Plato is a seminal figure.
Plato is also a good sparring partner for when you're just dipping your feet in to the waters of philosophy. A boxer shouldn't expect to knock out the reigning heavyweight champion the first time he puts his boxing gloves on. Similarly, you should really have a go at Plato before you have a go at later philosophers, who themselves have engaged with Plato and tried to answer Plato or have another go at issues first raised by him.
A familiarity with philosophers from every historical period is just part of a well-rounded philosophical education. Skipping to contemporaries would just leave huge gaps in your education, especially if you skip some of the greatest and most influential philosophers of all time, like Plato.
- westoncb 8y agoI've probably read a hundred or so pages on my own, and 'recaps' by Russel, Durant, and have spoken with practicing philosophers about him. I have enough exposure that I've been able to make much more sense of why later philosophers seem obsessed about certain points that only make sense if you consider the historical philosophical tradition from Plato. But hearing people talk about him, especially when they insist on his continued relevance, it makes me think either I'm missing something or they're faking something. But then again, I'd answer the questions you mentioned in a way I feel that most philosophers would find to be 'missing the point'. For example: > What is justice? A concept useful for regulating human societies. It's based on ultimately arbitrary heuristics that are effective for satisfying an approximately maximum number of people. > What is good? A word we use to label a fundamental behavior in our brains: we use values as something like utility functions in optimization processes. Ultimately there are constraints placed on the values we're capable of selecting which are imposed on us by our evolved biology, but we do have a good amount of freedom, so by studying human nature we can figure out which values are the most effective for creating the sort of lives we're interested in. > What is the best way to govern? We don't know yet. There probably is no best. If there is, we'll probably find it algorithmically. > What is true? There is too much ambiguity here to really answer, so I'll just choose one interpretation and say: whatever it is, it's highly unlikely that human minds would be capable of 'understanding' it ('understanding' being a human faculty, and not likely something important to the nature of the universe). > Where does knowledge come from? Brains. > Why should any of this matter? Because experience is real.
- pmoriarty 8y agoIt's not about the answers, but about thinking deeply about these questions and questioning your own assumptions (and those of others). I'd highly recommend taking an intro to philosophy course, or one on ancient philosophy, where you can read the Socratic dialogues and engage with them in a group setting, along with others who are encountering these for the first time. When done well, if you're lucky enough to have a good teacher and be in a group of students who are willing to engage fully with the reading and talk about it in class, this can be an experience like no other.
- westoncb 8y agoI've already taken in intro philosophy class. Furthermore, I've been debating philosophical points with friends since I was a kid—and since I've grown up two of my good friends who I spent multiple years talking philosophy with were either presently in grad school for philosophy or had finished with it. I see what you mean about doing philosophy in a group setting, but for what I'm interested in anyway, I'm not going to have a great time debating the above questions with an intro to philosophy class. A starting point for me to enjoy it would be that my interlocutors would need to be able to have some degree of understanding of the answers I gave above, what points might be in their favor, and what their limitations might be. I can say no philosopher I've met personally would answer those questions like I did (though I think I've read some who would), so I'm still very curious to see why we choose different ways. But my guess is still just that they'd answer differently if they had more knowledge of cognitive science and other topics.
- skissane 8y ago> > What is good? > A word we use to label a fundamental behavior in our brains: we use values as something like utility functions in optimization processes. That position limits the degree to which ethics can be objective. Suppose some other culture believes in doing things we believe to be gravely immoral. If our idea of good is just "a behaviour in our brains" or a "utility function" or a product of "evolved biology", well then theirs is too, so how can we say our moral views are objectively better than theirs? The ability to say that certain behaviour is immoral, in an objective and transcultural way, is threatened by your position; and I think that threat is a good reason to reject it. > > Where does knowledge come from? > Brains. You seem to treat (some version of) materialism as if it were obviously true, but I don't think its truth is obvious. I'm inclined toward idealism, and I don't believe there are any good reasons to believe that materialism is more likely to be true than idealism.