8 ms·
I think what is going to happen is people are going to realize robot cars are death traps. Not because their rate of accidents will be any higher, but that whe
by colechristensen 8y ago
I think what is going to happen is people are going to realize robot cars are death traps. Not because their rate of accidents will be any higher, but that when they do have accidents they will seem bizarre and inhuman mistakes that even the most incompetent human driver would never make.
Driving on the open road requires real intelligence. Not the pretend intelligence that modern AI gives, but real understanding of situations and terrain. Before that happens (which is basically skynet, and a very very long time away) all you have is a bag of tricks cobbled together. Those tricks will miss things and get confused and make mistakes. Maybe not very often but definitely in strange ways that are frightening.
The unknown is scary. Drunk drivers, tired drivers, old drivers, et al. are plenty dangerous, but they still behave in ways that can be understood. AI mistakes will be / are / have been strange unsettling things that can't be reasoned about if you're a person in the area of the misbehaving vehicle.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> when they do have accidents they will seem bizarre and inhuman mistakes that even the most incompetent human driver would never make. I agree -- but it's even worse. Even if robots do make human-like mistakes, that doesn't mean humans will be forgiving of the same mistakes. For one thing, I might forgive a human being unable to react due to a 1/2-second reaction time, but I sure as heck wouldn't be that forgiving for a robot. I would expect and demand an order of magnitude better. For another thing, people have more tolerance for mistakes made by "closer kin", if you will. (e.g. if my own child steals from me, even 10x as much as a random thief does, that doesn't mean the thief can expect more lenience than I had for my kid.) Self-driving cars pretty much have to be strictly _and_ significantly better than more than the majority of humans for people to trust having them around. Merely being better than average, even if it's in all respects, isn't necessarily enough to cut it.
- philwelch 8y ago> Driving on the open road requires real intelligence. Not the pretend intelligence that modern AI gives, but real understanding of situations and terrain. People used to say this about every single thing that computers can do better than people. In my college town, some pedestrians got ran over by a driver who later pled insanity due to "caffeine-induced psychosis". I think you're seriously overrating the predictability of human failure modes.
- a3n 8y ago> People used to say this about every single thing that computers can do better than people. And they were right, until they were eventually wrong. There will be this phase for automated vehicles too.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoTrue. However, "eventually" is a long time - the assumption "level 5 hardware exists today" is IMNSHO premature by many decades.
- rayiner 8y ago> People used to say this about every single thing that computers can do better than people Even if that’s true (and I doubt it is), there is ample precedent (AI winter) for the industry dramatically overestimating what computers can do. I bet if you time traveled and showed Siri/Cortana to an AI researcher from 1960 they’d be incredibly disappointed.
- ghaff 8y agoNot sure why people are disagreeing. That seems a blindingly obvious comment. There's so much today that would seem almost like magic to pretty much everyone living in 1960. But coice assistants? (And even just voice recognition.) almost certainly seemed like relatively "easy" problems. Perhaps less so to AI researchers than the general public but still.
- rayiner 8y agoI don't know about "magic." A modern smart phone might be "magic" to someone in 1860--it operates based on technologies that didn't exist back then. But by 1960, the building blocks of modern computing were already in place: digital von Neumann computers built out of transistors, radio communications, signal processing, etc. AT&T used frequency-division multiplexing of multiple voice channels in phone transmissions in 1918. The mathematical framework for modern technologies like LTE was in place by the 1950s and 1960s. Would it really have surprised anyone that transistors would continue to get smaller and faster, allowing higher complexity, higher-throughput signal processing, which would allow Facebook?
- verelo 8y agoThe funny thing here is we might already have the best solution to the "easy" automation scenario: Trains. It's a shame they're so expensive and require special tracks. If we could invent a hybrid train / car, that behaved like a train, but didn't require special track...that might actually be a better direction.
- ghaff 8y agoYou're pretty much describing a truck or a bus in that breaking up a train is one of the things you need to do to allow it to travel on non-dedicated/special right-of-way. And, with respect to freight, a lot of the easy automation is handled by trains. A huge amount of truly long distance freight in the US (including but not limited to bulk cargo) goes by train for much of its overland transport.
- TylerE 8y agoAussies have been doing this for decades. https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-2bc514ba621d41419fabd66ac36d089e.webp https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-2bc514ba621d41419fabd6...
- Piskvorrr 8y agoThe special/segregated track is one of the major reasons they're more secure.
- jlebar 8y ago> I think what is going to happen is people are going to realize robot cars are death traps. Drop the "robot" -- it's cleaner.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoWhile that's true, the debate rages around "the devil you know x the one you don't." Death traps on wheels are known (and risks ignored), their autonomous modes...not yet.
- conquistadog 8y agoPeople seem to have much greater fear of spectacular and bizarre deaths than of considerably more likely but relatively mundane deaths.
- tigershark 8y agoWhy are you so sure? Waymo demonstrated that they can handle correctly a duck-chasing wheelchair rider that used a broom. I’m not sure that all the human drivers would have handled it so well.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoAnd Uber demonstrated that incorrectly classifying a detected obstacle is solvable by running it over. I'm pretty sure that no sane human driver would have handled "could be a bike or a human or an animal, but it sure is something in my path" by ignoring it for six seconds before the collision and even afterward. "But we should let it out on the road, it drives on par with an insane, legally blind and completely drunk driver" is not a very convincing proposition.