2 ms·
I think you might be using an overly simplistic meaning for "classical". There is nothing preventing a classical description of ferromagnetism, for instance [1]
by naasking 8y ago
I think you might be using an overly simplistic meaning for "classical". There is nothing preventing a classical description of ferromagnetism, for instance [1]. Bohmian simulations of atoms has established stability despite the orbits, and would similarly entail the diamagnetism needed for this phenomenon, so classical theories can in fact explain it.
> well it doesn't explain anything new and the only problems it might solve are related to prejudices.
Correct, it actually explains everything old which prior interpretations like Copenhagen could not. I assume by "prejudices", you're referring to classical prejudices, but I think those prejudices are perfectly warranted.
> In this kind of situations just go for the more simple and consistent theory as the only thing that matters is measurements.
I disagree! John Bell formed the first no-go theorem because he was a fan of Bohmian mechanics. Without this focus on interpretations and quantum fundamentals, we may never have seen that landmark result or the series of subsequent no-go theorems which have all proven critical to our scientific understanding.
Science and physics does not consist solely of measurements; considerations of ontology are at least equally important because they inform the thought experiments which really drive scientific revolutions.
> Bell has written about this elsewhere, it's not pretty but I'm sure somebody has arrived to a working model by now
There are a few workable models, but Bell was correct to say that non-locality was the unsolved problem of quantum mechanics. Other interpretations let you "solve" it by sweeping it under the rug, but it always rears its ugly head elsewhere.
[1] https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/365970/43861 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/365970/43861
- mnl 8y agoNo, they can't explain ferromagnetism. Sometimes you use a semiclassical approximation, but that's a technical term. Don't look into the words used in Physics, this is not a social science, words in themselves don't carry an inherent meaning, they're just labels. You need spin to describe ferromagnetism, there's no room for that in a classical model of charges. I'm not opposed to alternative formulations of QM, but I'd rather prefer people would try to come up with more fundamental theories than QM (if possible) instead of trying to get the same results with something else because for some ideological reason they don't like standard QM. And it really is all about the measurements: Physics is an experimental science. You can think all you want and do crazy math and lots of gedanken, but we need at least a number and see what Nature thinks about it.
- naasking 8y agoDid you even read the link I provided? I mean, you've basically said that the physics textbooks are wrong and used a bunch of words, which you yourself said I shouldn't trust, to dismiss them without evidence. > You need spin to describe ferromagnetism, there's no room for that in a classical model of charges. I suggest you actually read the link I provided. A classical theory has certain characteristics that distinguish it from something like a quantum theory. As I suspected in my initial reply to you, you have a bizarre notion of what constitutes a classical theory. Rest assured, a classical theory of spin and ferromagnetism is entirely possible. As for measurements, physics is not solely an experimental science. Yes, theory must match experiment because empirical knowledge is what we're after, but measurements alone do not advance this agenda.
- mnl 8y agoYes, I've checked it and understood what it said. If you take spin, which can't exist by itself in classical physics and use it in a semiclassical approximation you get a good enough approach for your problem that has workable maths. People do this all the time in quantum optics, you consider for instance quantum atoms and classical EM fields, because the whole machinery would be too much trouble. But that's not classical at all, it's just model building. With classical physics alone you wouldn't be able to calculate anything because it wouldn't provide the basic phenomenology. Try to build a classical theory of the photoelectric effect, it's impossible yet it opens the door of your elevator.
- naasking 8y ago> If you take spin, which can't exist by itself in classical physics There are literally dozens of papers you can readily find that reproduce spin predictions using classical statistical mechanics. You denounce this as "model building", but every physical theory was model building. > Try to build a classical theory of the photoelectric effect, it's impossible yet it opens the door of your elevator. http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2009APS..TSS.C1003E http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2009APS..TSS.C1003E