4 ms·
Considering the fact that UK is a rather largeish (4th largest) contributor to ESA (which operates Arianne programme and several other scientific programs), doe
by izacus 8y ago
Considering the fact that UK is a rather largeish (4th largest) contributor to ESA (which operates Arianne programme and several other scientific programs), does it make sense to say they "abandoned it"?
It seems more like they pooled resources with other European countries to make a meaningful space programme.
- macintux 8y agoSeveral years passed before the ESA was founded, and the UK didn't join until later, so I would say it was abandoned.
- jamiewildehk 8y agoAfter Blue Streak was cancelled the UK joined up with other European countries to form ELDO, which was in some ways the precursor to ESA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Launcher_Development_Organisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Launcher_Development_...
- macintux 8y agoGood point, didn't know that. I'd still characterize the program as abandoned: abruptly cut all funding, everyone left for other work.
- pjc50 8y agoAnd then abandoned that: https://phys.org/news/2018-01-europe-space-agency-braces-brexit.html https://phys.org/news/2018-01-europe-space-agency-braces-bre...
- detritus 8y agoExcept we're not - it says it right there in the article you linked, trying to suggest otherwise.. "But Britain will likely stay in the ESA, which is autonomous from the European Union." A lot of us aren't particularly happy about Brexit, but please don't dilute the issue with flustered misinformation. -ed I mean, heck - Canada's part of the ESA!
- gonvaled 8y agoBut not on the same terms: it is questionable if access to Galileo for example will continue, and if it does, what kind of access level the UK will have. As a EU citizen, I worry that a fierce competitor (and in some aspects a potential foe) is going to be (mis-?) using EU infrastructure. Why would the EU choose to be put at a disadvantage by giving the UK more negotiating tokens? We have seen that the UK tries to advance negotiations in some areas by using leverage from other areas. Which is fine, it is part of the game. Let's just avoid falling into more traps. The underlying problem is that of trust: trust is not the right tool to build international relationships: independent institutions must be there to arbitrate whenever disputes arise. But the UK refuses to be held to account. It is thus an unreliable partner.
- detritus 8y ago> But the UK refuses to be held to account. It is thus an unreliable partner. Really? Crikey, I had no idea paranoia ran so deep on the European side[1]. Would you care to expand on why Britain apparently refuses to be held to account? As far as I'm aware, Britain is one of the most compliant members of the EU ruleset - aside from our much mentioned and ascribed financial concessions[2], our government doesn't tend to bend the rules to its own whims, as is often the case in France, Spain and Germany (re: abuse of subsidies and stature to corporate behemoths to go on spending sprees on infrastructure concerns in other EU states, in energy and construction in particular). Galileo is a seperate concern - an EU project whose delivery will be overseen by ESA - and I appreciate the use of it as a pawn in the Brexit negotiations. However, that does somewhat fly in the face of the FrancoAnglo drive towards military cooperation anad partnership, which given the spend and reach of the two largest military EU nations, would make sense to not toy with too much. To then go further and view the UK as a foe, whereas prior it was seen as a jigsaw-fit partner (we don't have any launch capability or ambitions to do so otherwise) seems .. well, as I said - paranoid. Brexit's division is not so much divisory as putting a foot down. It's a sentiment shared across Europe, and not acknowledging that is dangerous, I think. Anyway, love from the UK - we're not out to get you - I think we're just keeping trying to keep our options open. [1] I don't for a minute think it does - my partner and most of my friends are European and this whole Brexit mess is a frequent topic of conversation. Your stance here is the first I've come across that draws things in such stark, 'cold war' terms. I wonder if you hold the same opinion of the classes in France, Italy and Germany who are as equally unkeen on the European government? Is Britain somehow a deserving outlier of this mode of thinking? [2] mostly in regard to CAP spending, which now even Macron is beginning to appreciate the damage it causes