3 ms·
Umm, no? I mean, yes, Richard Florida wrote that CityLab piece, but the quote I gave at the start of this thread ("The conclusion must be that Jackson has an ov
by eesmith 8y ago
Umm, no? I mean, yes, Richard Florida wrote that CityLab piece, but the quote I gave at the start of this thread ("The conclusion must be that Jackson has an oversupply of parking.") is from the report that Florida cites, that is, "Quantified Parking: Comprehensive Parking Inventories for Five U.S. Cities", by Eric Scharnhorst, Principal Data Scientist Parkingmill.
As I pointed out, it seems that Jackson is willing to rent out parking spots for housing, which suggests that they think there is too much free parking at the height of the tourist season, and not enough housing.
I don't see the point of your seemingly ad hominem statements. Eg, "internet personality"? What does that mean? Wouldn't "urban studies theorist" or "best-selling author" be better descriptions?
Since it wasn't Florida making the statement I quoted - it was not made by an 'internet personality' - does it make the statement more accurate?
If only we could find the "Town Of Jackson Parking Garage Challenges to Success" document.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 8y agoThanks for explaining. For what it's worth, back in 2002 I worked as an urban planner for the city of St. Petersburg. The one in Florida. Like every city in the US we were fooling round with parking and since I had a background in structured parking going back to 1991, I was tasked with looking at some options. Not options I chose but options that various people with various levels of political power but a pretty much uniform lack of parking expertise...beyond the non-professional kind that one gets from parking cars over the years. So anyway, being a diligent design professional, I went to the planning department library and studied all the previous downtown parking studies I was able to find on the shelves. About a dozen going back to 1961...roughly forty years worth. Each of them was similar in that if parking was free in 1961, the 1961 study recommended charging for parking. The 1965 study would recommend making parking free. The 1970 study would recommend installing parking meters. The 1974 study would recommend taking parking meters out...and so on. In 2001, paid parking was prevelant. You can guess at the options under consideration. To Richard Florida's credit, he doesn't have to vary his policy pitch. There's always a market for voices advocating exclusionary policies for urban neighborhoods...e.g The Mortgage Bankers Association that commissioned the study and Parkingmill that is in the business of managing scarce parking. Richard Florida doesn't actually do studies. Influencers don't do studies.