7 ms·
How the CIA’s Fake Vaccination Campaign Endangers Us All
- mikestew 8y agoCollateral damaged be damned, all for simple revenge. Thanks to U. S. actions, a generation will be skeptical of vaccines. Not exactly Nazi levels of evil, but at a minimum it gives credence to every "CIA conspiracy" out there. But that's all old news, including TFA. What I want to know is, which heads rolled after this? Oh, none? Because we caught bin laden and "USA! USA! USA!"?
- otakucode 8y agoI don't think that was the reason. I think no heads rolled because heads can't roll for things like this. The CIA, at least the portion of it which conducts operations like this, has no oversight or ability to be punished whatsoever. They raise their own funding, maintain their own army, navy, and air force, and conduct operations internationally without the slightest but of input from the US government. In every way that matters except name, they are a fully autonomous international criminal cartel. We learned about the whole 'run their own army, navy, and air force and fund their own ops' stuff way back in the 80s when Oliver North testified before Congress (which is on YouTube buts its hours and hours of testimony)... and nothing was done. I don't think it's an exaggeration to refer to them as the single biggest threat to democracy that exists. They actively prop up dictators in order to prevent democratic movements from gaining control in many countries because they fear democratically elected leaders in those places might not be pro-American. At least I think that's why they do it. It might just be because the dictators give them a place where they can hide drugs or whatever.
- matt4077 8y agoThat's just a (rather cynical) conspiracy theory. While there are severe (and problematic) limits to judicial oversight of these programs, the CIA et al are subject to oversight by the executive (i. e. the presidency). While there were times in the past when the three-letter agencies had too much power to be effectively controlled (the J. Edgar Hoover era mostly), the possibility of a de facto coup is rather remote today. Specifically, President Obama could have easily prosecuted the torturers. His decision not to do so was motivated by the long-standing custom of not using criminal prosecution against your predecessors. More recently, just a handful of Republicans doing the right thing would have prevented Gina Haspel from becoming CIA chief, which would have been a rather encouraging message. Yes, neither of those things happened. But the reason was spinelessness and political expediency, not fear of the "deep state".
- otakucode 8y agoDe facto coup? I didn't say anything about anything remotely like that... How about when did Congress or the CIA in Washington, DC approve the purchase of the Predator drones run for years in Pakistan and Yemen before people got wind of it and they signed up with the military to make the program semi-legit? They didn't. They just decided to buy a bunch of drones and start tele-killing people on their own. They got ahold of the drones somehow, and went for it. Who in DC approved the fake vaccination program? No one did. Permission was never asked for. I'm not afraid of a 'deep state' or anything of the sort. I think it's just a bunch of people who realized that they have carte blanche to do literally whatever they want, and that no government on the planet can or will bring them to task. So they do what they want. There's certainly still a legitimate portion of the agency, those at Langley and all who run normal intelligence operations, but they don't seem to have much connection and certainly no control over those operating however they please with no regard for law. I don't actually know how they jive their multitude of active operations destroying democratic movements (which are not conspiracy theories, I'm only referring to the documented ones). I presume, very cynically I suppose, that they have concluded that democracy is a nice story to tell the naive civilian children, but that in harsh reality there has to be 'hard men' in the shadows making 'hard decisions' and putting boots on some throats to construct and protect the artificial bubble of happiness the US enjoys. I think, very not cynically, that they are absolutely and completely wrong on this mark and that they are profoundly immoral and destructive to the world in general, including the US in their misguided quest. Democracy is right and works ok enough. The alternatives are indefensible philosophically. When I hear things like about the drone program, I never understand why there isn't more controversy. The CIA is a CIVILIAN organization. They are in no way military or affiliated with the military. They have no mandate to execute military operations or use military resources, equipment, or tactics. It would seem to me that they committed some sort of fundamental and very cardinal error there...
- nl 8y agoI don’t know about most of your claims, but I do know about the drone program and you are so completely wrong about that it makes me question the rest of your unsourced statements. The CIA’s drone program had direct approval including explicit budget line items since the Clinton administration. the consequent need for repairs prompted a budgetary row between the Air Force and CIA, with, in hindsight, the measly sum of $3 million dollars further delaying the project and prompting direct budget amendments from the Clinton White House in the summer of 2000. The CIA’s use of drones for assignations started with direct presidential approval: The bureaucratic deadlock was broken on September 17, 2001 when Bush signed a finding that created a secret list of high-value targets that the CTC was authorized to kill https://www.lawfareblog.com/origins-drone-program https://www.lawfareblog.com/origins-drone-program
- pandasun 8y agoOne of the issues with the vaccination debate (in my opinion anyway) is that there's no ability to have a decent discussion. Especially online on sites like Reddit and even here on HN, you either support vaccines or you are literally the worst person on the planet. It's a bit disappointing. Edit: Ah there's the downvotes, new record, thanks for proving my point.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- strictnein 8y agoThis isn't what the article was about. Hence, the downvotes.
- pandasun 8y agoIt's about vaccinations. You're acting as if the discussions on HN are always narrowed down to the EXACT topic. Which is never the case.
- strictnein 8y agoYou clearly hadn't read the article before commenting. Would it be proper to discuss BMW's production of planes in WW2 when an article about one of their electric cars is posted?
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoI actually went on a facebook group where they encouraged anti-vacination discussion. It quickly devolves into anecdotes from parents who describe things like their unvaccinated child not getting sick much, or how their first child was vaccinated and completely changed into a different child, but their second child is perfect without vaccines. The science is pretty-fucking-clear on vaccinations that have been approved for use by the general public. There is no debate, there is no autism link, your kids won't die from a state-run vacination programme. Any "debate" is just conspiracy theories being bounced around by people who want to feel bigger than their doctor / nurse / scientists / other people.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoDetails of the program: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vaccinations-osama-bin-ladens-dna https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vacci... The doctor was denied a lawyer and given a 33 year prison sentence. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/23/doctor-bin-laden-cia-jail https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/23/doctor-bin-lad...
- writepub 8y agoThis is a classic "shifting of blame". Notice how no one other than the Taliban & it's ilk protest vaccine use!!! The blame here lies with the Taliban and co. Not with the CIA. Anyone can pose as anything - from mailmen to drivers were rigged to catch bin-laden. Should the CIA's use of fake mail-men and drivers be condemned? Stop lending credence to the horse-shit pedaled by unreasonable terrorists/tyrants - if not vaccines they'd blame cell phones, or regular phones, or roads, or ….
- boomboomsubban 8y agoImagine if members of the Taliban pretended to be US doctors and collected a sample of your DNA without your knowledge. Who would you blame any resulting outrage on? >Stop lending credence to the horse-shot pedaled by unreasonable terrorists/tyrants It's hard to consider their lack of trust "unreasonable." They have proof that we've done this before, and we've shown a willingness to kill them without much regard for the civilian cost.
- writepub 8y agoI think your understanding of spycraft is naïve. If you are a target of an international spy agency, like Osama was, trust nothing or no-one. CIA is blameless. They didn't mass infiltrate the vaccination program of the entire country, or state or city. Then ran a targeted mission on a particular neighborhood, which is what spy agencies do and are supposed to do. Again, this is a blatant and obvious shifting of blame. 1. the Pakistani state protected and harbored Osama --> their fault. 2. Informing them about the mission would have jeopardized it as Pakistan plays both sides routinely --> Pakistan's fault. 3. Osama was a ruthless murderer of innocents, and a target of international spy agencies --> his fault How is any of the above CIA's fault?
- nl 8y agoThe CIA should consider operational blowback and the consequences.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoI have mixed feelings. I feel like vaccinations are important and choosing to use that for cover is risky. At the same time any covert operation someone will pose as someone they are not or use their role in a way ... covertly. If someone discovers this and decides to take action against everyone or every organization that also includes those roles.... I don't think that's the CIA's fault. If a doctor intentionally chose to kill someone I knew, and I chose to kill doctors, that would not be ok and it would be my fault. Same goes with the Taliban and anyone else who behaves similarly.
- mikeash 8y agoYou’ll damage public trust in whatever you pose as. Let’s say you pose as a hotel bellhop. Following your exposure, hotel bellhops will be less trusted by the public, just like this. Except that lack of public trust in bellhops doesn’t have any serious consequences. A few people will carry their own bags instead of getting help, maybe. Big deal. Poss as doctors distributing vaccines, and you’ll hurt vaccination rates and people will does. That’s qualitatively different.
- ergothus 8y agoBut imagine a less one-sided scenario: You have the job of national security, with the presumption that $HUGE_NUMBER of lives are impacted. You have a medical aid group allegedly doing something good. But you know they could be a cover for a force trying to do something that would threaten that $HUGE_NUMBER. There's a cost-benefit analysis that goes into deciding how much of an obstacle you put up in front of said group. It might be minor, such as checking credentials, or posting a dedicated solider/analyst/guide to keep track of things, or scheduling delays, or perhaps denying/delaying access to different areas. There are a lot of ways to respond that aren't on the "kill doctors" side of your example and yet still impair the $GOOD_DEED. To avoid such debates, It makes sense on both a humanitarian level as well as a public moral-high-ground marketing level to have a line you don't cross even when an individual case looks to justify it. <Insert MIB speech about there's always a crisis here>
- ggggtez 8y agoIt's against the Geneva Conventions to use hospitals as military bases, or to attack hospitals. The idea that no country should mix public health and military operations is mutually agreed on, and is to help keep war, for lack of a better word, "civilized". If you start doubting that doctors are truly just trying to save lives, then the line between civilians and soldiers becomes so blurry that war can become even more horrible than it already is. Countries must hold firm that civilians doctors must not be ever construed as soldiers, for the safety of those doctors, and the people they treat.
- mirimir 8y agoScientific American doesn't like dating articles, but this is clearly old, Obama-era. And yeah, it's predictable blowback. Especially given the conspiracy theory that HIV was intentionally spread through vaccination programs.
- zamadatix 8y agoFYI the date is in the "Rights & Permissions" link at the bottom of their articles. In this case it's dated May 1, 2013. The beginning of the article does note that the events happened ~2 years before the publishing date though.
- mirimir 8y agoOK, thanks. But whatever, the title needs to include (2013).
- vaccinethrowa 8y agoHere's a video of a scientist presenting at the Pentagon, advocating vaccinating against religious fanaticism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8Lsvt1z0n4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8Lsvt1z0n4 Apparently they have found that certain genes are expressed differently in people they consider religious fanatics. And the proposal was to administer a virus through a vaccine that would restrict the expression of that gene.