3 ms·
I think you are right. Here's what I think the issue is: 1. Sun invents java. 2. Sun patents several aspects - including the security model, bytecode, etc. 3
by sandGorgon 16y ago
I think you are right. Here's what I think the issue is:
1. Sun invents java.
2. Sun patents several aspects - including the security model, bytecode, etc.
3. Sun open sources java and has a patent grant agreement in place if (whatever flavor of ) java passes the TCK.
4. Sun does not release the TCK as opensource
5. Apache Harmony does not comply with TCK - some weird stuff that if Harmony uses the TCK, it ceases to be opensource (might be applicable to mobile domain only). This means that it does not enjoy patent grants.
6. Dalvik uses the Harmony class library, as well as having a similar security model as Java (Patents 6,125,447 and 6,192,476).
So the problem is that, indeed the Dalvik bytecode is different, but that was never part of Oracle's patent claims IMHO. The patent claims are allegedly due to Harmony AS WELL AS other stuff like security models, PACK200 Java compression scheme for DEX, etc.
Side note: there is a Android fork called Sundrop which claims to be a non-infringing Android because it uses the official jvm. I disagree because it does not take care of the other patents.
- wtallis 16y agoIt's not so much that Harmony doesn't comply with the TCK as Harmony wasn't allowed to be tested against the TCK except under Faustian terms: in order to be allowed to test Harmony against the TCK, Apache would have had to make Harmony non-Free.