3 ms·
> But..., I don't think people really understand what this means. One thing it means is larger corporations. The first thing that happens when a market regulate
by munificent 8y ago
> But..., I don't think people really understand what this means. One thing it means is larger corporations. The first thing that happens when a market regulates is usually "consolidation."
Consolidation is the natural trend of all businesses, regardless of regulation.
Adam Smith in the 1700s said "People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices."
Business owners have a lot in common with owners of similar businesses, so it's pretty natural for them to know each other, get along, and have aligned goals. From there, it's a pretty short step to cooperation. Why make your business a zero-sum game by competing when you can make it non-zero-sum by cooperating?
So cartels and monolithic businesses form all the time and have all the way batch to the Dutch East India Company (though that also had government support too).
Remember, anti-trust regulation is a kind of regulation too.
> I'm not suggesting that banks should be a unregulated, just that quality matters. Quality is inadequate, currently.
I agree, completely. One of the things I've always found dumb is arguments around big government versus small government. What really matters is smart versus stupid. People seem to assume that it's simply impossible to change how well a government works. So small government people "solve" poor government by minimizing it while "big government people" generally think government works pretty well, at least relative to profit-driven enterprises.
- dalbasal 8y agoThe dutch & east india companies had "royal charters" which is essentially a monopoly license, the equivalent of a modern patent. This was the modern way of regulating industries that were thought to need regulation. At the time (and for most of human history), foreign trade was thought of as one these. I'm not sure the relevance, not driving at anything in particular. Cartels and monopolies have all sorts of origin stories. The biggest monopolies historically (and currently^) were formed via royal charter. ^Saudi Aramco is arguably the world's biggest company and holds a royal monopsony charter.