2 ms·
Very different things are in Indian semiconductor industry in comparison to China: 1. Availability of professionals India: makes tons of electronics engineers
by baybal2 8y ago
Very different things are in Indian semiconductor industry in comparison to China:
1. Availability of professionals
India: makes tons of electronics engineers and semi specialists, but very very few of them find employment in the country.
China: there is a somewhat ok amount of undergraduate cadres, but for anything above this, you have to attract people from abroad. And yes, Chinese fabless were hiring from abroad since the very beginning. In fact, people who make SoCs at Allwinner, Rockchip and etc are around 50% undergrad and 50% masters level people. In their early days they were eager to hire random college grads and teach them verilog on site.
2. Goals
India: a research program, all work in the past few decades was about delivering some kind of proof of concept level "national chip"
China: make money quick - 9 out of 10 Chinese fabless start with bog down standard, off the shelf "solutions" from ARM, and add some flavour: here you have 4 channel camera controller, here eDP on chip, and here 10G Ethernet for pennies.
3. Markets
India: with all respect, the truth is there are none. And from many people I hear the same criticism - even if the 10th in a row state backed effort to make the "national chip" will succeed, there will be no chances of it ever sustaining it with microscopic domestic market as demanded by political mandate.
China: foreign markets - even 15 years ago, Chinese fabless well understood that their value proposition is actually lesser in domestic market than for the export manufacturing. Most Chinese buying a PC 20 years ago were not deliberating whether their PC has Sigmatel audio codec or some cheaper domestic analogue, but for somebody making stuff for export, every penny saved on expensive imported chip mattered a lot. Even today, the pattern holds: Chines domestic market smartphone models have high-end Qualcomm or Samsung flagship class chips in their majority, and for export they do Mediatek, Allwinner, and Spreadtrum
- nickik 8y agoI think the difference could be that now they are playing in the RISC-V space that is developing in a global movement. Now the Indian national program is developing and working together on the same stuff that many silicon valley start ups and western university do. We are seeing something really exiting in the works and many companies in China also see the potential.
- PeCaN 8y agoThe biggest difference is that China can actually deliver. They built their own top supercomputer on a new architecture.