3 ms·
> freedomben? Can you tell me how one might meaningfully characterize "diversity of thought"? For lack of a better definition, by "meaningful" I mean "incorpora
by freedomben 8y ago
> freedomben? Can you tell me how one might meaningfully characterize "diversity of thought"? For lack of a better definition, by "meaningful" I mean "incorporate it into hiring decisions such that the result is to the overall benefit of the company and the society which allows the company to exist".
You make some good philosophical points (that "assholes" are part of the diversity of thought), but practically I don't think "assholism" is what you want to look for.
When I say "diversity of thought" I think of things much like the author of the piece mentions: different socio-economic status (if you've never been dirt poor, you think differently than someone who has been well off. both viewpoints can be good), different political views, different learning styles, etc.
Political diversity is also good I think. I think progressives bring good stuff to the table, as do conservatives, libertarians, and socialists. When one view predominates, the organization tends to suffer (not a universal truth, just an observation I've made (so clearly not scientific)).
Your desire for a "meaningful" definition however that one could "incorporate it into hiring decisions such that the result is to the overall benefit of the company and the society which allows the company to exist" is really hard however (at least for me). I'm not currently part of hiring, but I have been in the past (tho my involvement is typically limited to technical questions, and I rarely delve into anything other than technical stuff). I like to look for areas where we are strong and weak. For example, if we have mostly people that love UI design and front end work, a candidate that feels strong on the backend may be more desirable. I think it's good to remember that diversity of thought is insanely broad, and encompasses tons of areas (which seem to me to be the point you are trying to make). As such, coming up with an example that generally demonstrates it is likely not possible.
I feel like I just rambled and didn't answer very well. Sorry about that. I think it's time for bed ;-)
- eesmith 8y agoYes, diversity is "insanely broad" which is why I don't think it's meaningful. As the old saying goes, "you are unique, just like everyone else." This means that any criteria can be used in the selection process in order to weight what one things of as "diverse", and it cannot be opposed in court. I can understand the issues regarding so-called 'diversity hiring' - it's due to the generations of systemic racism, sexism, homophobia, and other bigoted practices. I think some turn it into a "diversity for the sake of diversity" argument, but I think that's because we (meaning Americans) often do that to avoid facing up to our history, and the problems of how to right those imbalances. That's why it's so easy for me to reject a "diversity of thought" argument - it's not quantifiable or actionable. I also think it's a misnomer. No one cares about "thoughts", only the expression of those thoughts.