4 ms·
I understand what it means to at least estimate representation based on gender, race, religion, nationality, veteran status, etc., and from that infer possible
by eesmith 8y ago
I understand what it means to at least estimate representation based on gender, race, religion, nationality, veteran status, etc., and from that infer possible discrimination.
I can also understand the reasons for having civil rights laws to protect members of those groups, and I fully acknowledge the long history of discrimination in the US (I'm from the US) against Native Americans, blacks, women, non-heterosexuals, non-Protestants, and more.
But I can't wrap my head around what "diversity of thought" means, in any meaningful way.
Look at all the places with 'No-Assholes' hiring policy. Aren't "assholes" part of the diversity of thought?
I think it's pretty obvious that there may be good reasons to not hire people based on which thoughts they decide to express and how they express them. (I assume 'diversity of thought' refers to expressed thoughts - our mind reading devices aren't that good.)
The author doesn't address this topic, and instead proposes an evaluation based "entirely on performance in anonymous technical interviews."
How does that evaluation have anything to do with "diversity of thought"? If people from school X are 80% likely to pass the interview and people from elsewhere are 20% likely to pass the interview, then woudn't that process result in a monoculture of thought?
freedomben? Can you tell me how one might meaningfully characterize "diversity of thought"? For lack of a better definition, by "meaningful" I mean "incorporate it into hiring decisions such that the result is to the overall benefit of the company and the society which allows the company to exist".
- woodman 8y ago> But I can't wrap my head around what "diversity of thought" means, in any meaningful way. For that to be true, you'd have to be unaware of the fact that people can process data and reason through complex problems differently. > I assume 'diversity of thought' refers to expressed thoughts - our mind reading devices aren't that good. That is a poor assumption that requires the redefinition of the word "thought". Our mind reading devices are pretty good: "Here is a complex problem that can be solved in more than one way - show your work." > How does that evaluation have anything to do with "diversity of thought"? By clearly demonstrating an applicant's competing priorities by way of solution selection? It sounds like you've never worked on a team that had that one guy who would regularly shoot down seemingly sensible textbook solutions, and instead offer a solution that either sounded like more work or just plain insanity. Have you never heard the story of Mel [0]? I can tell you from my own experience, as a former full stack developer who had to do a lot of interdepartmental work at a non-software company, diversity of thought is very useful. [0] https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/net.jokes/k2JVKQzJSpY https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/net.jokes/k2JVKQzJSp...
- eesmith 8y ago> "people can process data and reason through complex problems differently" This was in the context of hiring, and I gave my operational definition - how does one apply 'diversity of thought' to the hiring process? > "Here is a complex problem that can be solved in more than one way - show your work." Presenting a solution, or an attempt at a solution, is an expression of one's thoughts. > "diversity of thought is very useful" How do you apply it to the hiring process? How does the proposed method (skills testing) result in improved diversity of thought? I'll be more concrete with two examples. Example 1: Suppose there are only three schools which teach COBOL programming, and you are a bank which is looking to hire junior COBOL programmers. Do you design your test for COBOL competency, which will result in preferential selection from those small number of schools and hence reduce the diversity of thought? Or do you hire for more general diversity of thought and expect more overhead to train people in COBOL? Example 2. Suppose you put the applicant on an Ubuntu box and ask them to write a sort program in C++ which takes two command-line arguments. The first is an input file name containing set of lines (ending with a '\n'), the second is the output file name containing the input lines but sorted by byte value. Of those that pass the test, 50 do the 'standard' vector<string> with a sort from the standard library, but only 10 do I/O failure checking, and 1 of the 50 decides to make the parent directories if the filename's directory doesn't already exist. But wait, another 40 treat C++ as C, and use stdio along with a resizing array of char * . Of those, 30 use qsort, 8 implement quicksort, and 2 use bubble sort. (Oh, and one person who didn't finish was 90% of the way through implementing a Timsort.) That's a diversity of thought. Do you give preference to them for thinking about the problem in a different way? But wait, another 7 think about it a bit, realize that 'sort' is on the Ubuntu box, and construct system("sort filename1 -o filename2"). That's surely thinking outside the box, so should be encouraged in the name of diversity of thought, yes? Except another 2 think about it further, realize that the filenames may contain spaces or shell metacharacters, so construct the exec call directly. Security thinking is hard to train, so they should have preference, yes? And finally, the last one writes a C++ program which uses the Python C API to pass in a Python program as a string. Surely that's even more diverse thinking - and completely within the test protocol as given. Now to reverse the direction. I know all of these solutions. If I were given the task and I know that the employee wants to hire for "diversity of thought". Which implementation should I do to improve my chances of being hired? That is, should I do something which I know is less maintainable simply because I know it's more obscure and thus shows my diversity of thought?
- ubernostrum 8y ago"Diversity of thought" is a euphemism in the tradition of "teach the controversy". Reflect on that and you'll understand what it means and what is intended by people who advocate for it.
- basementcat 8y agoI still struggle to characterize "diversity of thought" in a way that is actionable by an institutional hiring process. I had a former colleague with whom I initially clashed. Only when realizing that he approached problems very differently than me (I could solve problems that he struggled with and he effortlessly solved problems that completely stomped me) did I realize that we needed to work together all the time. The only time I screamed at my management was the day he was laid off. The organization never recovered. When interviewing candidates, I am constantly afraid that I'm selecting for clones of myself.
- freedomben 8y ago> freedomben? Can you tell me how one might meaningfully characterize "diversity of thought"? For lack of a better definition, by "meaningful" I mean "incorporate it into hiring decisions such that the result is to the overall benefit of the company and the society which allows the company to exist". You make some good philosophical points (that "assholes" are part of the diversity of thought), but practically I don't think "assholism" is what you want to look for. When I say "diversity of thought" I think of things much like the author of the piece mentions: different socio-economic status (if you've never been dirt poor, you think differently than someone who has been well off. both viewpoints can be good), different political views, different learning styles, etc. Political diversity is also good I think. I think progressives bring good stuff to the table, as do conservatives, libertarians, and socialists. When one view predominates, the organization tends to suffer (not a universal truth, just an observation I've made (so clearly not scientific)). Your desire for a "meaningful" definition however that one could "incorporate it into hiring decisions such that the result is to the overall benefit of the company and the society which allows the company to exist" is really hard however (at least for me). I'm not currently part of hiring, but I have been in the past (tho my involvement is typically limited to technical questions, and I rarely delve into anything other than technical stuff). I like to look for areas where we are strong and weak. For example, if we have mostly people that love UI design and front end work, a candidate that feels strong on the backend may be more desirable. I think it's good to remember that diversity of thought is insanely broad, and encompasses tons of areas (which seem to me to be the point you are trying to make). As such, coming up with an example that generally demonstrates it is likely not possible. I feel like I just rambled and didn't answer very well. Sorry about that. I think it's time for bed ;-)
- eesmith 8y agoYes, diversity is "insanely broad" which is why I don't think it's meaningful. As the old saying goes, "you are unique, just like everyone else." This means that any criteria can be used in the selection process in order to weight what one things of as "diverse", and it cannot be opposed in court. I can understand the issues regarding so-called 'diversity hiring' - it's due to the generations of systemic racism, sexism, homophobia, and other bigoted practices. I think some turn it into a "diversity for the sake of diversity" argument, but I think that's because we (meaning Americans) often do that to avoid facing up to our history, and the problems of how to right those imbalances. That's why it's so easy for me to reject a "diversity of thought" argument - it's not quantifiable or actionable. I also think it's a misnomer. No one cares about "thoughts", only the expression of those thoughts.