5 ms·
David Bohm, Quantum Mechanics and Enlightenment
- rimher 8y agoGreat video that showcases the Pilot Wave idea: https://youtu.be/WIyTZDHuarQ https://youtu.be/WIyTZDHuarQ I really do hope that we can find a way to make sense of everything in Physics, but Bohm's description of the infinite in the article is rather fascinating. Maybe there's no way out after all
- SidiousL 8y agoI didn't read the article but, in case you don't know quantum mechanics, I should tell you that the vast majority of people who study such things think that Bohm's theory is plain wrong. I should also say that it is not taught in schools, papers about it are not published in serious journals and the field is just not an active field of research. It's quite likely that all the people trying to develop this idea are crackpots.
- okket 8y agoThe articles says Bohm's ideas "remain influential". Are there any examples in recent Physics where this is the case?
- codethief 8y agoThere are still plenty of research groups working on Bohmian mechanics.
- naasking 8y agoVarious no-go theorems were formulated due to looking into this question. For instance, the very first no-go theorem, Bell's theorem, was published because Bell was such a big fan of Bohmian mechanics.
- a_d 8y agoKip Thorne here [1] agrees with one aspect of Bohm’s philosophy (not Physics) —- he posits that theories that explain nature’s laws with more and more precision are like Matryoshka Dolls (Greeks->Newton->Einstein->String Theory->{??}), where each new layer improves on the predictions of the previous one —- and at one point in the discussion, he says this could go on until infinity. (Regardless, this is a great interview to watch if you are interested in physics) In similar vein, here is Eric Weinstein [2] talking about why we can’t find the theory of everything — and has similarly...kooky...ideas as Bohm. He is short-String theory (https://www.edge.org/response-detail/25547 https://www.edge.org/response-detail/25547). His main critique comes from the demands that the theory starts imposing about wanting 11 or 26 dimensions. All this in some level is super exciting and suspenseful, as I do believe Physics is on the cusp of a “new big idea from a lone genius” type revolution, that might push things forward! [1] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFJr3pJl27pItxUFeZlx98GQzl-5UBroJ https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFJr3pJl27pItxUFeZlx9... [2] https://youtu.be/Yw88utUCx9M https://youtu.be/Yw88utUCx9M
- catawbasam 8y ago'Kooky' seems a bit dismissive, especially as applied to thinkers of this caliber.
- dominotw 8y agoMaybe something to do with him hanging out with Jiddu Krisnamurthi for decades ( before falling out). Joking aside, I did enjoy the conversations between the two that some kind soul uploaded to youtube couple of yrs ago.
- samratjp 8y agoWere you perhaps referring to this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SqYCFRzqNoA&list=PL1n30s-LKus4MyNuceRoFAes5teZS_guW https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SqYCFRzqNoA&list=PL1n30s-LKu...? I love this series and highly recommend it to anyone interested in either of them or in Non-duality.
- raverbashing 8y agoIMHO the Copenhagen interpretation should have been taken as "this is the best we can come up right now" (instead of an "all-in") and while the original Bohmian mechanics do have some issues it does sound like they threw the baby out with the bathwater. (In the end the most successfully interpretation has been the "shut up and do the math" one, but the interpretations help us find unexplored and contradictory sides of the theory and hopefully help to find new experimental possibilities)
- mnl 8y agoMaybe the bad idea is insisting in having a classical physics pictorical interpretation when there's no reason why there should be one. At some point having just Maths is the more reasonable outlook.
- kaolti 8y agoWhat is the point of having just Maths if it doesn't help in the actual understanding of the world?
- mnl 8y agoAll of it: that's the actual understanding of the world, right there. What else should it be? I don't expect the laws of Nature being intuitive for advanced mammalian brains ultimately.
- naasking 8y ago> Maybe the bad idea is insisting in having a classical physics pictorical interpretation when there's no reason why there should be one Actually there is a reason: we see classic physics with our own two eyes every day. We know classical physics exists at the macroscopic level, and so a theory that simply explains the transition from microscopic to macroscopic physics and how this works. This transition is unbelievably simple in Bohmian mechanics, since in principle, it's just classical physics with an extra term to account for quantum influences. The picture isn't nearly so simple for many other interpretations.
- mapcars 8y ago>For him, truth-seeking was not a game, it was a dreadful, impossible, necessary task. Bohm was desperate to know, to discover the secret of everything, but he knew it wasn’t attainable, not for any mortal being. No one gets out of the fish tank alive. This is a very, very big question. Its a little pity he didn't meet Sadhguru.
- dwarman 8y ago"not a game" - well, he certainly hid this well behind a playful and enthusiastic way of teaching, as when he was our Props of Matter lecturing prof at Birkbeck College in the early 70's. And very effective too, not that I followed the Physics path beyond that (the siren call of computers was stronger for me).
- kkylin 8y agoThe (completely classical) fluids "experiment on television" mentioned in this article is presumably something like this (which is really cool if you haven't seen it before): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcBpDVzBPMk Said experiments starts about 40 seconds in. A bit more info here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stokes_flow#Properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stokes_flow#Properties
- axilmar 8y agoMy apologies for the seemingly unrelated comment, but I do not understand why 'spooky action at a distance' has to be 'action at a distance' and not photons getting entangled when created. I.e. why couldn't it be that a pair of photons are generated with their properties already in such state that, when measured, a correlation is present? the photons don't communicate, they are already in the appropriate state when measured.
- jostylr 8y agoThat is what Bell's work showed is not possible. The inequality he derived assumes the values already exist and then proves that a certain inequality for the predictions must be satisfied. This is without specifying the actual theory, just simply that the values already exist in the right correlations. Experiments has proven that the inequality is violated. Thus, the properties cannot be determined beforehand. So either there is a connection that is, essentially, faster than light, or the results of the experiments do not become finalized until compared (that is, the researchers first reading the results exist in a multi-state, allowing for various outcomes yet to be determined [this is what the many worlds view basically is] ). http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Bell%27s_theorem#Bell.27s_inequality_theorem http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Bell%27s_theorem#Bell.27...
- amai 8y agoIn contrast to what the article says, Einstein didn’t think Bohm had a sensible theory. In a letter to Max Born he wrote about Bohm’s theory: “That way seems too cheap to me.” https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/De_Broglie–Bohm_theory https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/De_Broglie–Bohm_theory