6 ms·
Going sponsor-free – 3blue1brown
- stephengillie 8y agoThese videos are excellent. They earned my "patreonage" a couple months ago.
- ainar-g 8y agoI agree. His neural networks series[1] was a real eye-opener for me, and whenever someone wants to know how they work, I point them to the playlist. [1] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZHQObOWTQDNU6R1_67000Dx_ZCJB-3pi https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZHQObOWTQDNU6R1_6700...
- andrepd 8y agoI enjoyed his one about blockchain even more.
- ehsankia 8y agoI'm a huge fan and a patron too, but I'm curious. He doesn't show his monthly earning but I see he has 5000 patrons. Even at the minimum 1$ tier, that would still be 5000$ a month. While that's not "Youtube rich", I don't think that's "small audience either. I assumed that he had enough backing to comfortably make videos without having to worry about money or sponsors.
- pitaj 8y agoHe's hired a couple of extra staff to help with animation and stuff, so it's likely that he has a good amount of revenue.
- edanm 8y agoFYI, he later decided to go back to working solo.
- majewsky 8y agoSupport is per video, not per month. So that's a minimum $5000 per video. The Youtube channel says "new video every third Friday +/- 1 week", so "per video" is slightly more often than "per month".
- MarkMc 8y ago5000 patrons is good, but YouTube advertising is where the real money is because (a) these math-type of videos have no expiry date; (b) Google are getting better at monetising videos; (c) 3blue1brown is possibly the best videos on the topic and not likely to be beaten by the competition. In 10 years his 'Essence of Calculus' videos will probably earn more money per month than now.
- zaarn 8y agoI think (a) assumes that there is an infinite supply of people interested in watching these kinds of video. In reality, you're going to make most of the money in the first few days after uploading and after that you'll get a trickle of people who find it via search, recommendation or rewatching it from a playlist.
- ehsankia 8y agoSure, I'm sure he gets decent money from ads too. My point was that, I don't see why he needs sponsors in the first place. My 5000$ estimate was a bare bare minimum. Realistically, I would guess around $10k-$15k from Patreon and another $5k from Youtube at least (he has 1M subscribers, which is the "Made it" threshold).
- Rjevski 8y agoI fully agree with him. In-video ads should die. I don’t really mind product placement as long as the brand matches the content of the video (a gun channel promoting gun manufacturers is fine by me) but I’m getting so tired when a totally unrelated video promotes some shitty pay-to-win mobile games or forex/binary options exchanges/betting sites.
- CraneWorm 8y agoall ads should just die
- jxub 8y agoWell, that may be an overstatement for now but on a level of individual enjoyment of life, ecology and a saner lifestyle we really need a means of matching sellers and buyers that's less of the current emotional status-based exchange of useless products and more a pragmatic as-is transaction with minimal collateral waste and middlemen moat. This isn't as simple as it seems though because with the transition to that model the global economy would take a serious hit, as there would be less demand (of the emotion-driven kind). For me and many though (which may not have a say in the market as big as the consumerist group), the choice is clearly the self and planet-conscious one.
- andrepd 8y agoUnironically this. For reasons which I won't bother expounding on unless someone asks, I consider (all) advertising to be immoral. The world would be a much better place if advertising was heavily regulated or banned.
- Hasz 8y agoGenuinely curious, do you mind explaining?
- jmts 8y agoI've recently decided that a lot of advertising for childrens toys can be suspect, though I don't watch a lot of TV anymore so I'm not exposed to it anymore. To me the idea is that a company will build something that amounts ultimately to garbage, then back it with an exciting advertising campaign and catchy tune targeted at childen. Often it's a set of toys, so you're encouraged to collect them all. The children will then nag their parents for such a thing, until the parents relent. An example from my childhood would be the Mighty Max toys (or Polly Pocket for the female demographic). I know that once I was finally given a Mighty Max toy I quickly moved on to other things, with a total play-time probably measured in hours. Contrast that with Lego, where I was regularly building and creating cars, and castles, and bridges, and towers, for well over a decade. From my parent's perspective the Lego was much better value for money - and I'm sure they knew that - but they were sometimes coerced into buying junk.
- Jagat 8y agoIf you're reliant on ads, you tend to optimize your content to attract more advertisers and eyeballs. If you're reliant on donations, you tend to optimize your content to cater to the richer (or upper middle class) segment of society with disposable income. I'm pointing out the widespread belief among the techies that the second option is inherently more noble than the first. If I create content that caters to the local population of, say, Mombasa, am I more likely to produce more if I rely on donations, or if I rely on google displaying ads of Mombasa businesses? Would you, a techie in the USA/Western-Europe with disposable income, even hear about my channel? (edit: That said, I don't like brand promotion from the creator within the video either since that introduces a huge bias. But I'm all for algorithmically generated ads where the creator has little control)
- Barrin92 8y agomost independent content creation does not seem to be paywalled, so people who do not have the means to support the content can still enjoy it, while the people who can back it financially. This seems like a pretty reasonable solution to me. I'm also not sure that producing ad-driven content for business in Mombasa necessarily aligns with the content the people of Mombasa want to see any more then it does here. The big benefit of independent funding is that the creator is solely responsible for her audience, and not beholden to third parties.
- Jagat 8y ago>> most independent content creation does not seem to be paywalled, so people who do not have the means to support the content can still enjoy it Another hypothetical scenario: I make videos of mobile phone reviews, and I'm an amazing reviewer. And I rely on donations. I start with the noble intent of not biasing towards expensive phones, and treat all phones the same, because I've a noble intent of catering to all segments of society. I'm also reliant on the donations for my livelihood because I hate ads. Over time, I notice that I get more donations (Say $12) whenever I review some feature of iPhone, or Samsung Galaxy. It doesn't even have to be about a new phone - just a tiny feature. When I review a $10 phone that folks in Mombasa use, I get none. I have finite time, and I need money. But I'm completely against ads, algorithmic or otherwise. So I now talk more about mundane iPhone features than I do about that $10 chinese phone. Choice 2: I rely on google's targeted ads. It's learnt to show pre-roll Mercedes ads on my channel when someone in Manhattan views it, and a local business ad when someone in Mombasa views it. I make $11 from Manhattan ads and $1 from Mombasa ads. I still don't get as much money as I do with donations. But if it's noble purpose we're talking about, my latter choice seems more noble than the former to me.
- Aardwolf 8y ago3blue1brown is awesome, some videos are extremely interesting and useful but others are too specific imho, like, I love his videos explaining general concepts about algebra, analytics, machine learning, quantum mechanics and blockchain, but not really his videos about a particular obscure mathematical problem, especially if the same obscure thing recurs multiple times (say, something involving pi and lighthouses). But glad to hear there won't be "b r i l l i a n t . o r g" (made hard to copypaste on purpose since I've no interest in encouraging them due to spamming too many of videos I watch) interruptions in the videos anymore I think 3blue1brown's formula is amazing for laying the fundamentals of advanced mathematics. But it's not needed for deep diving into specific topics. And there are more than enough advanced core topics remaining to cover instead.
- thicknavyrain 8y agoThat's really interesting. I found that I loved, similar to the occasional video numberphile does, watching Grant explain how one might realistically solve an interesting problem. A particular favourite is the one on the Inscribed Square Problem, which, although introducing some elements of topology, engages me more from the get go. He poses a problem and my curiosity keeps me engaged until the very end, it feels a bit like a detective story, I get the same satisfaction as some of the better Sherlock Holmes stories where in the course of reading I think "Damn, I could have come to that conclusion if I'd paid a bit more attention!". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmgkSdhK4K8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AmgkSdhK4K8
- diminoten 8y agoIt's always fascinating to watch the various thrashings about that creators will do to try and protect something that's clearly special to them, especially when those wild decisions end up being completely irrational. This move is not rational. Ads do not behave like this article says they do, and every draw or consequence of ads listed here are resistable or mitigatable on his part, since he is the content creator. People do crazy things for love, and this content creator clearly loves his creation.
- gmiller123456 8y agoI am usually amazed twice by 3B1B videos. First by the way he presents the material, then by the fact that I've never seen it presented anything like the way he did it. While I'm no mathematical scholar, I have read and re-read a lot of "basic" linear algebra and calculus. Usually choosing a different source every time I have to go back and re-read it. And I've never come across anything that does as good as his series on those two subjects. Granted, I'll still forget the material since I don't use it every day. But I do believe it gave me a deeper insight, and will help me remember it longer.