3 ms·
It just occurred to me that there may be another thing I don't see yet mentioned in this thread that gets in the way of repairing Teslas - from what I've read,
by perl4ever 8y ago
It just occurred to me that there may be another thing I don't see yet mentioned in this thread that gets in the way of repairing Teslas - from what I've read, they make constant changes in their cars during model years, so how do you know which exact parts you have in your car? I bet it's underdocumented.
I have been trying to fix various things in an old car from the 80s, and one of the more annoying aspects is trying to get a replacement part and finding there is a rare variant that I need but has the same part number as the common one. There are also a lot of parts that don't have diagrams or part numbers at all, because they weren't anticipated to be serviced normally.
- chaboud 8y agoIt's impressive to me that they can make running changes (like reducing the number of spot welds in the Model 3) without having to retest/recertify.
- jacquesm 8y agoThat's not that impressive, in fact it tends to be a signal of poor design. The more changes to a model in a short time the worse it will be later to find parts and to keep the car running. It will also end up being more expensive. That's why it is generally good practice to avoid the first year of a new model (unless you are into collecting low serial number cars...). And if a manufacturer that is facing a financial issue would start to reduce the number of welds on the cars (which you would assume engineering put there for a reason) I would be very suspicious, especially if they did not retest and recertify.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoWelds are actually weak points as far as I'm aware. Perhaps reducing them and using another method (usually adhesive) is actually stronger overall. It can also reduce weight. It's why a lot of high end cars these days use bonded aluminium panels instead of spot welds.
- jacquesm 8y agoNowhere that I've seen did they say they were replacing welds with adhesives or other construction methods, it was just said that a number of welds were dropped for efficiency reasons. Usually the engineers that determine how many welds you will need to hold something together know what they are doing and you can't just replace welds with bonding without further cascading impact to the rest of the work.
- chaboud 8y agoRereading my original comment, what I meant was "it's impressive that they can get away with not retesting and recertifying when making material changes to safety-related elements of the vehicles."
- RaceWon 8y ago^This. 3 years ago I had to scrap a low milage 2009 VV GTI because the ABS computer was shot. Of course that module also communicates with all the other electronics on the car and is not readily accessible. Go online to the forums and read about the nightmare of trying to do this yourself without VW diagnostics to get the new module to work with all the existing components. Even my local shop, who uses a VV tech on the side would not warranty a $3,000 fix. The dealership wanted over $4,500 to fix it. In the end I traded it in where I bought it (I worked there many moons ago and the owner leaned on a wholesaler to buy the car at a very reasonable price). Just to clarify my point; this was a GTI- a loved car with all kinds of known fixes, fixers and available parts.
- userbinator 8y agofinding there is a rare variant that I need but has the same part number as the common one. That's usually because the replacement is a drop-in compatible replacement; otherwise the part number would also have changed. Note that sometimes this also means a few other parts need to be replaced with new versions too, and if so that would be something mentioned in a service change bulletin (unfortunately rarely available, in contrast to service manuals.)
- perl4ever 8y ago"That's usually because the replacement is a drop-in compatible replacement" I wish. When I had it installed, I was told there was an issue, but I was sure it was the right part so I told them to go ahead and just do it. Afterwards, there was a heavy bag of leftover parts, and I said "what's this?" It was the stuff that had to be taken off to fit the wrong part. That stuff, coincidentally, doesn't have part numbers or documentation itself. Also not helping - salvage places that don't send you the exact part that's pictured on their website.