3 ms·
The article says the desired pumping station would be located 20 miles downstream from the dam. Why would it need to be so far?
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
The article says the desired pumping station would be located 20 miles downstream from the dam. Why would it need to be so far?
- progfix 8y agoMy guess is to get an economically height difference to the dam.
- phire 8y agoNo, any extra height to pump water up compared to the height of the dam is just wasted power. They wouldn't do that without a good reason. My understanding is you can't just stick an inlet on the river, otherwise you could only pump water up when the dam was running (defeating the point). You need to build some kind of reservoir. Additionally, with hydropower it's not enough to build a dam above your generators. You also need to get rid of the water exiting your generators fast enough. If there is any restiction on the outflow, the back pressure will decrease the generation capacity. My guess is the distance is needed to meet these requirements. Enough space to let the water slow down, then enough space to build a reservoir.
- progfix 8y agoWhy would it be wasted power? Height difference = stored potential power. I was talking about that maybe 20 miles downstream the pump-size/-energy consumption to stored power is more efficent.
- phire 8y agoBecause the height difference that matters is the difference between the water level in the lake and the turbines. If your pumping station inlet is 20m below the turbines, then any energy used pumping water upto the height of the turbines is wasted, because it can't be recovered when the water comes back down.
- evgen 8y agoIf you look at the topography of the area in google maps you will see that the sides of the canyon are somewhat steep and rugged for quite a ways downstream of the dam. Go a bit further and you find Willow Beach, which has a nice flat run north and then west back to the reservoir. I am guessing that being able to run the pipe using trenching equipment rather than tunneling through canyon walls is a big advantage.