3 ms·
Disclosure: I don't have any published papers to speak of, though I have some patents. But I write similar things -- technical reports -- within my day job. I
by analog31 8y ago
Disclosure: I don't have any published papers to speak of, though I have some patents. But I write similar things -- technical reports -- within my day job.
I think the scientific paper or report has always been fictionalized to some extent. The earliest scientists may have been more overt about it. It's doubtful that a bunch of soldiers ever tried to burn an enemy ship with mirrors, but that's how Archimedes reported his idea. As I understand it, it's also doubtful what experiments Galileo actually performed on falling bodies before reporting his results.
It seems to me that in a typical paper, one should strive to make the work reproducible, to present the ideas in a form where errors shine out if they are present, and generally to be useful to others.
Using the scientific paper to reveal how science is actually done isn't necessarily a good use of paper or readers' eyeballs. We're bad enough writers as it is, and trying to express a "narrative" in every paper may turn the literature into an unreadable and possibly irreproducible mess. There may be better ways of learning the "narrative" of scientific research, namely by just getting in there and doing it, or at least hanging out with scientists for a while.
- xamuel 8y agoPart of the problem, I think, is these days there are more people who want to write than there are people who want to read. So it's an endless battle to draw attention to your own writings. "Look at me! Look over here!" Unless you have some sort of "hook", your paper will never be read outside of a very small circle. Because everyone's too busy writing their own papers to look at yours. In some sense, it reminds me of the story of the Tower of Babel. The harder we try to mass produce science, the harder it is for scientists to make their voices heard above the noise.