2 ms·
> No one has ever reconciled that with how the black hole is supposed to form in the first place. Incorrect. The first scientific paper that showed how to reco
by pdonis 8y ago
> No one has ever reconciled that with how the black hole is supposed to form in the first place.
Incorrect. The first scientific paper that showed how to reconcile these things was by Oppenheimer and Snyder, published in 1939. In the late 1950s through the 1970s, this subject was studied in detail in the idealized cases where exact analytical solutions exist. Since the 1980s, numerical simulations have confirmed that the key properties of those solutions remain in much more realistic cases. If you read some actual textbooks or peer-reviewed papers on GR, instead of pop science magazines and web forums, you would know all this.
Oh, wait--you did link to a peer-reviewed paper by Penrose. Have you looked at Fig. 2 of that paper and its accompanying text? It describes exactly the reconciliation that you claim doesn't exist (the model being described is basically the 1939 Oppenheimer-Snyder model in coordinates that make things easier to see than the ones O&S used).