8 ms·
Police accused of deploying facial recognition 'by stealth' in London
- dosy 8y agoisn't using it by stealth sort of the point?
- b_b 8y agoThe article says that the police had pledged to notify people of its use in the areas using leaflets and such, but failed to do so even when deploying the technology, so this is why it is labeled as secrecy.
- dosy 8y agothey had posters. > Lots of people didn’t seem to be noticing the posters at all… from a basic data protection point of view they’re not informing people well about what data they’re collecting or what is going on. i don't think data protection applies to state surveillance. if people knew what data the state collected about them, it would defeat the point.
- mtgx 8y agoYou're painting everything with a very broad brush. The "state" by and large has to be transparent to the public.
- dosy 8y agointeresting theories. not how i think of it. i think it could be more like to protect the privacy of other citizens whose data it collects, and the effectiveness of its intelligence, the state must be opaque to the public and selectively transparent to itself. Maybe one reason for the confusion /polarity on this topic, Is individuals think of privacy Through a framework of shame or something to hide, or nothing feel like sharing, But for states and organisations Privacy and secrecy is about maintaining Operational / strategic effectiveness.
- wjn0 8y ago> i don't think data protection applies to state surveillance. if people knew what data the state collected about them, it would defeat the point. What? The people the system is meant to protect shouldn't know about the system... at all?
- dosy 8y agoYes so they cant interfere with how it protects them, as another commenter noted. That parts of a system must be prevented from knowing/interfering with the inner workings of each other to protect the integrity of the whole is a general pronciple in many things Itl think.
- faceplanted 8y ago> if people knew what data the state collected about them, it would defeat the point. No, it wouldn't. The point of keeping data is to be able to detect unusual activity and cross reference information. Not to spy. The people are the country and they should be able to make an informed decision on what they want the government to be tracking about people.
- drusepth 8y ago>No, it wouldn't. The point of keeping data is to be able to detect unusual activity and cross reference information. Not to spy. The people are the country and they should be able to make an informed decision on what they want the government to be tracking about people. This ideal mindset breaks down for everyone other than "the good guys". The point of keeping what is tracked a secret is to prevent the-actual-people-you're-looking-for from just occluding that particular information. They can't really "opt in" to the kind of surveillance that is necessary to find predictive patterns in their behavior, because they (obviously) won't, and knowing what is tracked just tells them what to spend the extra effort hiding.
- dosy 8y agois it weird i think there's no such thing as privacy between state and individuals, and probably remains privacy between individuals? i accept this model of reality and actually think its sensible. personally i have no issue with that.
- ascorbic 8y agoThe article says that the information commissioner threatened legal action about this. I doubt she'd do that if the laws didn't apply.
- dosy 8y agoi think her political ambitions combined with consumer privacy being an electoral issue is a better theory
- mtgx 8y agoNo? Police actions are supposed to be transparent to the public. Should we treat every single government agency as if they deal with super-secret national security issues and allow them to keep everything secret?
- dosy 8y agopolice must present as open and transparent because presence is a crime deterant, order is more effectively kept when people trust / relate / engage with them, and they are service and public facing and an image of transparency reinforces faith in justice. but investigations and methods and intel must be secret to preserve capability. and also legal / judiciL integrity.
- alex_hitchins 8y agoHow is this different to lots of coppers activly looking for suspects? We have so much intrusive CCTV here I can’t quite get the complaint. Was it just the introduction with lip service to community engagement?
- drasticmeasures 8y agoIt's a gradual worsening of civil freedoms and rights. Intrusive CCTV is intrusive. Facial recognition is more intrusive. It wouldn't be different from an impossibly high number of law enforcement officers keeping watch on everyone at all time like in a high-tech big brother nightmare -- except the tech doesn't work properly, and there are high numbers of false positives that will lead to the wrong innocent people being put under suspicion and potentially having their life ruined by a police investigation that presumes you're guilty until you've been illibated by a court. They shouldn't be watching or tracking us in the first place.
- faceplanted 8y agoThe difference is automation, and the issues that come with that. If you look like someone the system is looking for, there's nothing you can do to whitelist yourself other than wear something on your face, you will be flagged, every single time until a human looks at it, and if they're stopping people, that means being stopped, every time. If the system has the wrong face in the database, bad luck. If someone finds a way of preventing detection, say, make up, or big glasses, the system doesn't work any more, as far as I know, even the best facial recognition that only relies on cameras and not depth cameras significantly lose accuracy with either of those. There are a lot of people in London, the false positive and negative rates aren't usually published and anything above zero means those technical problems happen an undisclosed amount too much. Did you ever hear the story of the guy with a very common name ending up on the no fly list? The no fly list was for a long time, and I think still now, literally only a list of names, meaning if someone with a common name goes on the list, everyone with that name gets stopped at the airport as the database gets checked to see if they're the same person. Now think what happens if someone with a generic looking face ends up in the police database.
- 8y ago
- drasticmeasures 8y agoWhat are you going to do about it?
- dosy 8y agoI think for people who live in a place / do a job where a state harasses/meddles instead of protects them, knowing how it works lets them protect themsleves and even meddle back. I think this is why activists / journalists / spies in some areas try to study the operation and practice tradecraft / opsec / cs. Info asymmetry is power, isnt it?
- wpdev_63 8y agomassachusetts is such a place
- devmunchies 8y agoWell UK doesn’t have the same free speech laws rights as the US so it’s much more risky to protest, especially in London these days.
- tribby 8y agoignoring issues related to scale, I wonder how the tech's accuracy compares to london's team of human "super-recognizers."[1] 1. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/08/22/londons-super-recognizer-police-force https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/08/22/londons-super-...
- drasticmeasures 8y ago>Ignoring scale, I wonder how the tech's accuracy compares to london's team of human "super-recognizers." You can't ignore scale when it is the game-changer of automated facial recognition. The tech compares very poorly to super-recognizers, with an absurdly high number of false positives, putting the wrong innocent people under an aggressive suspicion that they won't be able to know about and dispute.
- tribby 8y agoin a hypothetical you can ignore whatever you want :) infinite super-recognizers vs. infinitely available facial recognition is what I'm wondering about here. > The tech compares very poorly to super-recognizers, with an absurdly high number of false positives, putting the wrong innocent people under aggressive suspicion. well that's not good!
- drasticmeasures 8y ago>well that's not good! The whole concept is a nightmare for our civil freedoms even if the tech was perfect -- precisely because of realistically being able to scale -- and must be protested until the whole idea is let go of. >infinite super-recognizers vs. infinitely available facial recognition is what I'm wondering about here. You keep editing your comments to remove contentious remarks. I can only reply to the one I've read.
- drusepth 8y agoWhy doesn't such a system scale? What about it makes it undesirable even if the tech was perfect?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- laichzeit0 8y agoCombine this with the recent advances in deep learning based lip reading and you should really know how fucked we all are.
- gaius 8y agoFacial recognition tech can spot you in a crowd if you take part in a demo against the government Self-driving car tech can simply refuse to take you there
- whatsstolat 8y agoStick on an anonymous mask and walk?
- homero 8y agoMasks are illegal sometimes because of that
- hjek 8y agoThey're not illegal in the UK.
- noir_lord 8y agoYet.
- M2Ys4U 8y agoNot by default. But police can impose an order - for a defined area for a limited amount of time - under Section 60AA of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 allowing officers to demand that one removes "any item which the constable reasonably believes that person is wearing wholly or mainly for the purpose of concealing his identity".
- hjek 8y agoInteresting. Never seen that it action yet. Sounds like there's some wiggle room, e.g. for carnival masks for entertainment purposes.
- justinclift 8y agoSomewhat ironically, burqa's might be able to get around some restrictions because of their use in religious contexts.
- 0xBA5ED 8y agoPerhaps the time has come to invest in Groucho glasses.
- justsomedude43 8y agoWhat exactly is the use for this facial recognition exactly? We all know from experience that British police couldn't catch a cold let alone a criminal, with all those tens of thousands of 240p cameras out of which maybe 20% actually work. What is facial recognition going to solve if they can't even see the face on the camera?
- secfirstmd 8y agoAlso IMSI catching is used widely by police. https://news.vice.com/article/vice-news-investigation-finds-signs-of-secret-phone-surveillance-across-london https://news.vice.com/article/vice-news-investigation-finds-... And none of this surveillance compares to the extent of surveillance in Nothern Ireland.