4 ms·
Do you have an actual point to make rather trying to shame me? Even if I was wrong that Facebook doesn't profit from outrage(and knows it), that doesn't have a
by ravenstine 8y ago
Do you have an actual point to make rather trying to shame me? Even if I was wrong that Facebook doesn't profit from outrage(and knows it), that doesn't have any bearing on whether Facebook users as a group are better judges of validity of content over another group that thinks more about these issues in general. I'd be open to hearing why my perspectives aren't correct.
- krapp 8y agoFirst, Facebook users as a group comprise too large and diverse a set to make such general inferences about, such as whether or not they are better or worse judges of the validity or quality of content than Hacker News users. Second, there is no quantifiable measure of validity or quality with which one could make a meaningful comparison. Third, the sets of Facebook and Hacker News (and Twitter, Reddit, 4chan, etc) users likely overlap significantly, calling the premise of distinct userbases with distinct social and intellectual qualities into question.
- ravenstine 8y agoOn a purely data-driven basis, your points are sound for the most part. Although I don't agree that your third point, since that can be used to try to discredit any assessment of a particular group of people; for example, there can be a country with a distinct culture, but smaller states within that country can have its own distinct culture even though 100% of its occupants belong to a larger country, and there's nothing about that overlap in itself that calls into question the premise of the existence of subcultures. However, I was not addressing the question in a data-driven sense, hence why I said "In my experience." My subjective experience tells me that one group of people is more likely, even if that likelihood is ever so small, to make a more reasonable judgment in a particular area than a different group. Now everyone's experience is going to be different, but I never claimed that my experience is universal. In my experience, the very kind of conversation that we are having is much less likely to end well if it was to take place anywhere on Facebook. People on Facebook have threatened me several times for saying far more milquetoast things than I say on HN, yet on HN I've not once received a single threat. Whatever it is about Facebook, I've found that its users on average are much more likely to jump down the throats of others than to have a real conversation. If you can't agree that personal experience can't mean anything to the person having such experience, then we're at an impasse.