4 ms·
I received the same rant/incredulity from several of my own professors (in Philosophy). It was incredibly disheartening to see academics essentially give up on
by woodruffw 8y ago
I received the same rant/incredulity from several of my own professors (in Philosophy). It was incredibly disheartening to see academics essentially give up on any sort of robust future for their field.
- rdtsc 8y agoIsn't it better they are honest rather than set unrealistic expectations that students will regret years later.
- woodruffw 8y agoIt's one thing to be realistic about the economics of pursuing a field, and another to be defeatist or outright dismissive of the idea itself. Edit: I should say that my professors came off more as defeatist than dismissive. I was never told that I couldn't study Philosophy at the graduate level.
- xigma 8y agoThe thing is, when you are young and idealistic, you will say to yourself things like "I don't care about the money!", which is probably what these people told themselves. These people are disillusioned and so will the future you be, but your present you has to make the decision. It's incredibly valuable that they're being honest to you and to themselves.
- grimbly 8y agoHow funny that someone taking the holier-than-thou approach cannot even use the right punctuation.
- codeulike 8y agoI know people that were enthusiastically encouraged to continue, and completely wrecked their lives.
- watwut 8y agoI think that it is good thing that they talk openly with students who are deciding about their future. It was way more respectable then pretending everything is cool in order to sell you some unlikely dream.
- fsloth 8y agoIt's not about whether the academics give up or not. It's about whether they get funding or not. No funding, no future.
- woodandsteel 8y agoBasically the philosophy profession has given up on trying to persuade students and society as a whole of its value. I think to a great extent this is due to the logical-positivism and Russellian analytic focus that took over the profession after WWII. Before that American philosophers focused on classical philosophy, Hegelianism, and Pragmatism, all of which could be related to the realities of contemporary life and society. But then, as Rorty has explained, philosophers got the idea of turning their field into an exact science that would be the handmaiden of the natural and social sciences. This made philosophy inaccessible to non-specialists, and furthermore was a gigantic intellectual failure. One result was the profession came to be populated by several generations of teachers who have no idea about how to talk to non-philosophers. Hence you get people like Steven Hawking and Neil Degrasse Tyson arguing that philosophy is irrelevant. And the only other group is the postmodernists, who tend to be marxists who turn off most Americans. All this is quite unfortunate, in part because liberal democracy is based to a great extent on philosophical ideas that go back to the Greeks, and hence philosophy has a great deal to say that is relevant today.
- frozenport 8y agoStop spewing this postmodernism = Marxist crap. Denial of meta narratives is incompatible with the idea of a revolution or the dialectic of history. You cannot commit to both postmodernism and Marxism.
- qubax 8y agoSame here. Apparently the job market for philosophers, especially in academia, is terrible because there is a glut of philosophy PhDs and tenured philosophy professors stick around for decades. So most philosophy professors are associate professors who get paid a couple of thousand per semester. Can't imagine living on that in NY. Imagine having a doctorate and making $6K per year. So I double majored in computer science and philosophy like a lot of my class mates.