3 ms·
> after that they can become Quark stars (if such things exist). We do not have enough knowledge of quark degeneracy pressure to be able to tell.The only known
by pdonis 8y ago
> after that they can become Quark stars (if such things exist). We do not have enough knowledge of quark degeneracy pressure to be able to tell.The only known signals are black hole mergers
That doesn't matter. The derivation of the neutron star maximum mass actually doesn't require that the star is made of neutrons. Anything that responds to the strong interaction (including quark matter that for some reason is not bound into hadrons) will do. The key point is that physicists have modeled such objects using basically every possible equation of state for strongly interacting matter, and the maximum masses all lie in the range I gave (the reason for the range is that we don't know the precise equation of state, we only know it's somewhere within the range we've modeled). So even if quark stars exists, they will have a maximum mass somewhere in that range (which might not be precisely the same as the maximum mass for neutron star matter).
> how do you know the object is compact? Our telescopes do not have anywhere near sufficient resolution to distinguish that.
Sure they do. We know the object at the center of the galaxy is confined within a radius of less than about 10^13 meters; we know its mass is about 4 million solar masses. The only way to pack that much mass into that small a space without an object being there that would be easily visible to our telescopes is a black hole.
> what sort of events would that be?
X-rays and gamma rays emitted by hot matter falling into the hole. See, for example, the list of stellar mass black hole candidates here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_black_holes#Stellar_black_holes_and_candidates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_black_holes#Stellar_bl...
> The only known signals are black hole mergers
Not at all. See above. You really, really don't know much about black holes, do you?
> You are forgetting the objects on the other side of the black hole.
Huh? We were talking about a single object falling into a black hole. An object on the other side won't be able to see that object anyway; the hole will block its view.
> They need all the mass nearby to make a black hole, but time dilation makes such mass unavailable.
Incorrect. You are peddling misinformation here; you obviously do not have a good understanding of the actual physical model of black holes based on General Relativity.
- ars 8y ago> So even if quark stars exists, they will have a maximum mass somewhere in that range You don't know that. If the quark degeneracy pressure is high it could support far more massive objects. After all simple heat is enough to support far more massive objects (large suns easily exceed that limit). Why would you assume, without data, that there is no other degeneracy pressure that could support such pressures? > within a radius of less than about 10^13 meters; we know its mass is about 4 million solar masses Run the numbers - that's about a factor of 1,000 too large to be a black hole. Here's a calculator: https://space.geometrian.com/calcs/black-hole-params.php https://space.geometrian.com/calcs/black-hole-params.php > The only way to pack that much mass into that small a space without an object being there that would be easily visible to our telescopes is a black hole. That is not true. A cold object would be invisible. If the area around it is empty of mass there would not be any jets to see either. > X-rays and gamma rays emitted by hot matter falling into the hole. How do you know it's a black hole and not a neutron star? The jets would look identical. You can not tell that there is an event horizon. > An object on the other side won't be able to see that object anyway; the hole will block its view. It would "see" it gravitationally. > Incorrect. You say that, yet you have not explained how I'm able to see anything fall toward the black hole. Anything heading toward a black hole would (from my POV) look like it was frozen in time. This isn't something I've made up - all scientists agree about that part. No one has ever reconciled that with how the black hole is supposed to form in the first place. Read for yourself: http://www.astronomy.com/magazine/ask-astro/2014/11/frozen-stars http://www.astronomy.com/magazine/ask-astro/2014/11/frozen-s... https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/2441/does-matter-accumulate-just-outside-the-event-horizon-of-a-black-hole https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/2441/does-matt... Edit: And more: "Light from the collapsing material takes longer and longer to reach the observer, with the light emitted just before the event horizon forms delayed an infinite amount of time. Thus the external observer never sees the formation of the event horizon; instead, the collapsing material seems to become dimmer and increasingly red-shifted, eventually fading away." https://web.archive.org/web/20130526224126/http://www.imamu.edu.sa/Scientific_selections/abstracts/Physics/Gravitational%20Collapse%20The%20Role%20of%20General.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20130526224126/http://www.imamu.... How much clearer than that can you get? And you should recognize the name of the author. Join the black-hole deniers club and take that next step: Since we can never see any black holes form, black holes do not exist.
- pdonis 8y ago> You don't know that. If the quark degeneracy pressure is high it could support far more massive objects. Nope. Go read Shapiro and Teukolsky's textbook on compact states of matter. They go into excruciating mathematical detail to show that this is not true. It has to do with relativistic degeneracy, which is a general phenomenon that applies to any kind of compact state of matter. > Why would you assume, without data, that there is no other degeneracy pressure that could support such pressures? Because physicists have already figured out a general model that applies to all possible states of compact matter. See above. > Run the numbers - that's about a factor of 1,000 too large to be a black hole. You're missing the point. For a system of that mass, there is nothing else that could fit even inside a radius 1,000 times the Schwarzschild radius and remain stable for a significant period of time. For example, if there were a million stars (or neutron stars) of one solar mass each, they would not be in stable orbits; the whole system would collapse to a black hole. This has been studied in detail numerically and is part of why astronomers are highly confident that the object at the center of our galaxy is a black hole. > A cold object would be invisible. There would have to be on the order of a million cold objects, not just one, because of the maximum mass limit. See above. > How do you know it's a black hole and not a neutron star? All of the candidates I linked to are well over the maximum mass limit. > It would "see" it gravitationally. I'm not sure what you mean. If you mean, would an object on the other side of the hole detect the increase in mass when the first object fell in, yes, it would. > Anything heading toward a black hole would (from my POV) look like it was frozen in time. Not until it got very, very close to the hole. For example, in the case of the hole at the center of the galaxy, whose Schwarzschild radius is about 10 million kilometers, you could see an object fall to within well under a million kilometers of the horizon before the light emitted from it would be too redshifted to detect. (How close would depend on how low a frequency of EM radiation your detectors could detect; we can detect very low frequencies, which means my estimate above might be quite a bit larger than our actual current detection capability.) > all scientists agree about that part About the general fact of light from objects falling into a black hole being redshifted, yes. But I strongly doubt you have actually run the numbers to see how close an object has to get to the hole before the redshift becomes significant. > Since we can never see any black holes form, black holes do not exist. Faulty logic. Nor do any of the scientific sources you quote from make this claim. They know better.