5 ms·
How common is this, really? Are parents in the US being regularly harassed for minor things like in the article? I'm not trying to discredit this person's sto
by ravenstine 8y ago
How common is this, really? Are parents in the US being regularly harassed for minor things like in the article? I'm not trying to discredit this person's story, but it's easy to believe that this is an "issue" when everything is anecdotal.
- jsight 8y agoI feel like there is something really meta about your comment. I also feel like I have read this exact article about 3 years ago. EDIT: Oh, of course, I remembered this article by the same writer: https://www.salon.com/2014/06/03/the_day_i_left_my_son_in_the_car/ https://www.salon.com/2014/06/03/the_day_i_left_my_son_in_th... In some ways, I think the 4 year old article was better.
- jshevek 8y agoAll I have are anecdotes, and I can't speak to the frequency of law enforcement getting involved, but regarding the general perception of what is 'appropriate parenting' there is a culture of micromanagement, paranoia, and shaming.
- magduf 8y agoIn reality, it probably varies a lot by location. Apparently, in Utah (as stated in the article), they actually passed "free range parenting" laws. But try that in certain other metro areas and you're going to get in big trouble. Personally, I'd rather leave the country than live in Utah...
- rubidium 8y agoYes. As noted in the article, the now-extensive reach and power of CPS-type investigations is the most damaging typical harrassment. Other parents concerns are annoying but a bit silly. Cops don't have much legal ground in the minor things, as noted. But CPS can pretty do whatever it wants.
- blattimwind 8y agoI'm always fascinated by sentiments given by people living in the self-declared land of freedom of the form: > Cops don't [...]. But [govt agency] can do whatever they want. It seems to me as-if there aren't many real freedoms beyond the first one.
- aidenn0 8y agos/parents/mothers/ and the answer is yes. My wife gets constant flak about her parenting, but men are graded on a curve: you didn't skip town before your child was born? Awesome!
- bvc35 8y agoWith men, the sexism is on the same class as "look at how good these black students are doing!"
- spamizbad 8y agoIt's going to vary based on where your live. And even if there are local laws, you might be subject to just how much of a busy-body your neighbors are. In Illinois, it's illegal it keep children ages 6 and under in a vehicle unattended for more than 10 minutes. Someone 14 years or older must either accompany or be within eyesight of them. These laws largely exist because of advocacy groups such as Kids 'n Cars[1] whose founders often had children who died while unattended in vehicles and they want to "save" other parents. As a parent myself, I think these rules are absolutely bonkers. Kids might be less safe these days in hot cars because windows are now automatic and not manual, but there's likely a technical solution to that problem that does not require jailing anyone or ripping families apart because they ran in to get a coffee. [1]: https://www.kidsandcars.org/ https://www.kidsandcars.org/
- jessaustin 8y agoWow that organization may be worse than MAD. How many poor families have been made poorer still because parents who never harmed anyone have been thrown in prison by our overzealous drunk driving laws?
- 40acres 8y agoPeople are being harassed about minor things all the time in this country. The age of social media has just made it more visible. This summer there has been a trend of stories regarding people (usually white) calling the police on their neighbors (usually black) about things like: wearing socks to a pool, barbecuing, sleeping in the common area of the dormitory, and starting a lemonade stand. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/11/us/black-white-police.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/11/us/black-white-police.htm...
- jessaustin 8y agoTo take just one example, and assuming that it really is terrible to wear socks in a pool (I know that's not actually terrible)... If the sock-wearer were of the same race, would the white person just complain directly: "Hey this is a family-friendly pool: take those damn socks off!" or would the person not care at all because it's fine for white people to wear socks in the pool? The two possibilities both have racist implications, but different racist implications. I almost feel that in the first case we all just need to get together and talk it over. In the second case the racism is fairly irredeemable...